@phdthesis{Dekant2024,
  author    = {Dekant, Raphael H.},
  title     = {Species-differences in the \(in\) \(vitro\) biotransformation of trifluoroethene (HFO-1123)},
  doi       = {10.25972/OPUS-31403},
  url       = {http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-314035},
  school      = {Universit{\"a}t W{\"u}rzburg},
  year      = {2024},
  abstract  = {1,1,2-trifluoroethene (HFO-1123) is intended for use as a refrigerant. Inhalation studies on HFO-1123 in rats suggested a low potential for toxicity, with no-observed-adverse-effect levels greater then 20,000 ppm. However, single inhalation exposure of Goettingen Minipigs and New Zealand White Rabbits resulted in mortality. It was assumed that conjugation of HFO-1123 with glutathione, via glutathione S-transferase, gives rise to S-(1,1,2-trifluoroethyl)-L-glutathione (1123-GSH), which is then transformed to the corresponding cysteine S-conjugate (S-(1,1,2-trifluoroethyl)-L-cysteine, 1123-CYS). Subsequent beta-lyase mediated cleavage of 1123-CYS may result in monofluoroacetic acid, a potent inhibitor of aconitase. Species-differences in 1123-GSH formation and 1123-CYS cleavage to MFA may explain species-differences in HFO-1123 toxicity. This study was designed to test the hypothesis, that GSH-dependent biotransformation and subsequent beta-lyase mediated formation of monofluoroacetic acid, a potent inhibitor of aconitase in the citric acid cycle, may play a key role in HFO-1123 toxicity and to evaluate if species-differences in the extent of MFA formation may account for the species-differences in HFO-1123 toxicity. The overall objective was to determine species-differences in HFO-1123 biotransformation in susceptible vs. less susceptible species and humans as a basis for human risk assessment. To this end, in vitro biotransformation of HFO-1123 and 1123-CYS was investigated in renal and hepatic subcellular fractions of mice, rats, humans, Goettingen Minipigs and NZW Rabbits. Furthermore, cytotoxicity and metabolism of 1123-CYS was assessed in cultured renal epithelial cells. Enzyme kinetic parameters for beta-lyase mediated cleavage of 1123-CYS in renal and hepatic cytosolic fractions were determined, and 19F-NMR was used to identify fluorine containing metabolites arising from 1123-CYS cleavage. Quantification of 1123-GSH formation in hepatic S9 fractions after incubation with HFO-1123 was performed by LC-MS/MS and hepatic metabolism of HFO-1123 was monitored by 19F-NMR. Rates of 1123-GSH formation were increased in rat, mouse and NZW Rabbit compared to human and Goettingen hepatic S9, indicating increased GSH dependent biotransformation in rats, mouse and NZW Rabbits. NZW Rabbit hepatic S9 exhibited increased 1123-GSH formation in the presence compared to the absence of acivicin, a specific gamma-GT inhibitor. This indicates increased gamma-GT mediated cleavage of 1123-GSH in NZW Rabbit hepatic S9 compared to the other species. 19F-NMR confirmed formation of 1123-GSH as the main metabolite of GSH mediated biotransformation of HFO-1123 in hepatic S9 fractions next to F-. Increased F- formation was detected in NZW Rabbit and Goettingen Minipig hepatic S9 in the presence of an NADPH regenerating system, indicating a higher rate of CYP-450 mediated metabolism in these species. Based on these findings, it is possible that CYP-450 mediated metabolism may contribute to HFO-1123 toxicity. In contrast to the increased formation of 1123-GSH in rat, mouse and NZW Rabbit hepatic S9 (compared to human and Goettingen Minipig), enzyme kinetic studies revealed a significantly higher beta-lyase activity towards 1123-CYS in renal cytosol of Goettingen Minipigs compared to cytosol from rats, mice, humans and NZW Rabbits. However, beta-lyase cleavage in renal NZW Rabbit cytosol was slightly increased compared to rat, mouse and human renal cytosols. 19F-NMR analysis confirmed increased time-dependent formation of MFA in renal Goettingen Minipig cytosol and NZW Rabbit (compared to human and rat cytosolic fractions). Three structurally not defined MFA-derivatives were detected exclusively in NZW Rabbit and Goettingen Minipig cytosols. Also, porcine kidney cells were more sensitive to cytotoxicity of 1123-CYS compared to rat and human kidney cells. Overall, increased beta-lyase mediate cleavage of 1123-CYS to MFA in Goettingen Minipig and NZW Rabbit kidney (compared to human and rat) may support the hypothesis that enzymatic cleavage by beta-lyases may account for the species-differences in HFO-1123 toxicity. However, the extent of GST mediated biotransformation in the liver as the initial step in HFO-1123 metabolism does not fully agree with this hypothesis, since 1123-GSH formation occurs at higher rates in rat, mouse and NZW Rabbit S9 as compared to the Goettingen Minipig. Based on the inconsistencies between the extent of GST and beta-lyase mediated biotransformation of HFO-1123 obtained by this study, a decisive statement about an increased biotransformation of HFO-1123 in susceptible species with a direct linkage to the species-specific toxicity cannot be drawn. Resulting from this, a clear and reliable conclusion regarding the risk for human health originating from HFO-1123 cannot be made. However, considering the death of Goettingen Minipigs and NZW Rabbits after inhalation exposure of HFO-1123 at concentrations great than 500 ppm and greater than 1250 ppm, respectively, this indicates a health concern for humans under peak exposure conditions. For a successful registration of HFO-1123 and its use as a refrigerant, further in vitro and in vivo investigations addressing uncertainties in the species-specific toxicity of HFO-1123 are urgently needed.},
  subject      = {Biotransformation},
  language  = {en}
}