@phdthesis{Asmus2016,
  author    = {Asmus, Elisabeth},
  title     = {Mode of Action of Adjuvants for Foliar Application},
  url       = {http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-138159},
  school      = {Universit{\"a}t W{\"u}rzburg},
  year      = {2016},
  abstract  = {Adjuvants are compounds added to an agrochemical spray formulation to improve or modify the action of an active ingredient (AI) or the physico-chemical characteristics of the spray liquid. Adjuvants can have more than only one distinct mode of action (MoA) during the foliar spray application process and they are generally known to be the best tools to improve agrochemical formulations. The main objective for this work was to elucidate the basic MoA of adjuvants by uncoupling different aspects of the spray application. Laboratory experiments, beginning from retention and spreading characteristics, followed by humectant effects concerning the spray deposit on the leaf surface and ultimately the cuticular penetration of an AI, were figured out to evaluate overall in vivo effects of adjuvants which were also obtained in a greenhouse spray test. For this comprehensive study, the surfactant classes of non-ionic sorbitan esters (Span), polysorbates (Tween) and oleyl alcohol polyglycol ether (Genapol O) were generally considered because of their common promoting potential in agrochemical formulations and their structural diversity. The reduction of interfacial tension is one of the most crucial physico-chemical properties of surfactants. The dynamic surface tension (DST) was monitored to characterise the surface tension lowering behaviour which is known to influence the droplet formation and retention characteristics. The DST is a function of time and the critical time frame of droplet impact might be at about 100 ms. None of the selected surfactants were found to lower the surface tension sufficiently during this short timeframe (chapter I). At ca. 100 ms, Tween 20 resulted in the lowest DST value. When surfactant monomers are fully saturated at the droplet-air-interface, an equilibrium surface tension (STeq) value can be determined which may be used to predict spreading or run-off effects. The majority of selected surfactants resulted in a narrow distribution of STeq values, ranging between 30 and 45 mN m- 1. Nevertheless, all surfactants were able to decrease the surface tension considerably compared to pure water (72 mN m- 1). The influence of different surfactants on the wetting process was evaluated by studying time-dependent static contact angles on different surfaces and the droplet spread area on Triticum aestivum leaves after water evaporation. The spreading potential was observed to be better for Spans than for Tweens. Especially Span 20 showed maximum spreading results. To transfer laboratory findings to spray application, related to field conditions, retention and leaf coverage was measured quantitatively on wheat leaves by using a variable track sprayer. Since the retention process involves short time dynamics, it is well-known that the spray retention on a plant surface is not correlated to STeq but to DST values. The relationship between DST at ca. 100 ms and results from the track sprayer showed increasing retention results with decreasing DST, whereas at DST values below ca. 60 mN m- 1 no further retention improvement could be observed. Under field conditions, water evaporates from the droplet within a few seconds to minutes after droplet deposition on the leaf surface. Since precipitation of the AI must essentially being avoided by holding the AI in solution, so-called humectants are used as tank-mix adjuvants. The ability of pure surfactants to absorb water from the surrounding atmosphere was investigated comprehensively by analysing water sorption isotherms (chapter II). These isotherms showed an exponential shape with a steep water sorption increase starting at 60\% to 70\% RH. Water sorption was low for Spans and much more distinct for the polyethoxylated surfactants (Tweens and Genapol O series). The relationship between the water sorption behaviour and the molecular structure of surfactants was considered as the so-called humectant activity. With an increasing ethylene oxide (EO) content, the humectant activity increased concerning the particular class of Genapol O. However, it could be shown that the moisture absorption across all classes of selected surfactants correlates rather better with their hydrophilic-lipophilic balance values with the EO content. All aboveground organs of plants are covered by the cuticular membrane which is therefore the first rate limiting barrier for AI uptake. In vitro penetration experiments through an astomatous model cuticle were performed to study the effects of adjuvants on the penetration of the lipophilic herbicide Pinoxaden (PXD) (chapter III). In order to understand the influence of different adjuvant MoA like humectancy, experiments were performed under three different humidity levels. No explicit relationship could be found between humidity levels and the PXD penetration which might be explained by the fact that humidity effects would rather affect hydrophilic AIs than lipophilic ones. Especially for Tween 20, it became obvious that a complex balance between multiple MoA like spreading, humectancy and plasticising effects have to be considered. Greenhouse trials, focussing the adjuvant impact on in vivo action of PXD, were evaluated on five different grass-weed species (chapter III). Since agrochemical spray application and its following action on living plants also includes translocation processes in planta and species dependent physiological effects, this investigation may help to simulate the situation on the field. Even though the absolute weed damage was different, depending both on plant species and also on PXD rates, adjuvant effects in greenhouse experiments displayed the same ranking as in cuticular penetration studies: Tween 20 > Tween 80 > Span 20 ≥ Span 80. Thus, the present work shows for the first time that findings obtained in laboratory experiments can be successfully transferred to spray application studies on living plants concerning adjuvant MoA. A comparative analysis, using radar charts, could demonstrate systematic derivations from structural similarities of adjuvants to their MoA (summarising discussion and outlook). Exemplarily, Tween 20 and Tween 80 cover a wide range of selected variables by having no outstanding MoA improving one distinct process during foliar application, compared to non-ethoxylated Span 20 and Span 80 which primarily revealed a surface active action. Most adjuvants used in this study represent polydisperse mixtures bearing a complex distribution of EO and aliphatic chains. From this study it seems alike that adjuvants having a wide EO distribution offer broader potential than adjuvants with a small EO distribution. It might be a speculation that due to this broad distribution of single molecules, all bearing their individual specific physico-chemical nature, a wide range of properties concerning their MoA is covered.},
  subject      = {Adjuvans},
  language  = {en}
}
@phdthesis{Staiger2022,
  author    = {Staiger, Simona},
  title     = {Chemical and physical nature of the barrier against active ingredient penetration into leaves: effects of adjuvants on the cuticular diffusion barrier},
  doi       = {10.25972/OPUS-19937},
  url       = {http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-199375},
  school      = {Universit{\"a}t W{\"u}rzburg},
  year      = {2022},
  abstract  = {Agrochemicals like systemic active ingredients (AI) need to penetrate the outermost barrier of the plant, known as the plant cuticle, to reach its right target site. Therefore, adjuvants are added to provide precise and efficient biodelivery by i.a. modifying the cuticular barrier and increasing the AI diffusion. This modification process is depicted as plasticization of the cuticular wax which mainly consists of very long-chain aliphatic (VLCA) and cyclic compounds. Plasticization of cuticular waxes is pictured as an increase of amorphous domains and/or a decrease of crystalline fractions, but comprehensive, experimental proof is lacking to date. Hence, the objective of this thesis was to i) elucidate the permeation barrier of the plant cuticle to AIs in terms of the different wax fractions and ii) holistically investigate the modification of this barrier using selected oil and surface active adjuvants, an aliphatic leaf wax and an artificial model wax. Therefore, the oil adjuvant methyl oleate (MeO) and other oil derivatives like methyl linolenate (MeLin), methyl stearate (MeSt) and oleic acid (OA) were selected. Three monodisperse, non-ionic alcohol ethoxylates with increasing ethylene oxide monomer (EO) number (C10E2, C10E5, C10E8) were chosen as representatives of the group of surface active agents (surfactants). Both adjuvant classes are commonly used as formulation aids for agrochemicals which are known for its penetration enhancing effect. The aliphatic leaf wax of Schefflera elegantissima was selected, as well as a model wax comprising the four most abundant cuticular wax compounds of this species. Permeation, transpiration and penetration studies were conducted using enzymatically isolated cuticles of Prunus laurocerasus and Garcinia xanthochymus. Cuticular permeability to the three organic solutes theobromine, caffeine and azoxystrobin differing in lipophilicity was measured using a steady-state two-chamber system separated by the isolated leaf cuticles of the evergreen species P. laurocerasus and G. xanthochymus. Treating the isolated cuticles with methanol selectively removed the cyclic fraction, and membrane permeability to the organic compounds was not altered. In contrast, fully dewaxing the membranes using chloroform resulted in a statistically significant increase in permeance for all compounds and species, except caffeine with cuticles of G. xanthochymus due to a matrix-specific influence on the semi-hydrophilic compound. Crystalline regions may reduce the accessibility to the lipophilic pathway across the waxes and also block hydrophilic domains in the cuticle. Knowing that the aliphatic wax fraction builds the cuticular diffusion barrier, the influence of the adjuvants on the phase behaviour of an aliphatic cuticular wax as well as the influence on the cuticular penetration of AIs were investigated. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) were selected to investigate the phase behaviour and thus possible plasticization of pure Schefflera elegantissima leaf wax, its artificial model wax comprising the four most abundant compounds (n-nonacosane, n-hentriacontane, 1-triacontanol and 1-dotriacontanol) and wax adjuvant mixtures. DSC thermograms showed a shift of the melting ranges to lower temperatures and decreased absolute values of the total enthalpy of transition (EOT) for all adjuvant leaf wax blends at 50 \% (w/w) adjuvant proportion. The highest decrease was found for C10E2 followed by MeO > OA and C10E8 > MeLin > MeSt. The aliphatic crystallinity determined by FTIR yielded declined values for the leaf and the artificial wax with 50 \% MeO. All other adjuvant leaf wax blends did not show a significant decrease of crystallinity. As it is assumed that the cuticular wax is formed by crystalline domains which consist of aliphatic hydrocarbon chains and an amorphous fraction comprising aliphatic chain ends and functional groups, the plasticizers are depicted as wax disruptors influencing amorphization and/or crystallization. The adjuvants can increase crystalline domains using the aliphatic tail whereas their more hydrophilic head is embedded in the amorphous wax fraction. DSC and FTIR showed similar trends using the leaf wax and the model wax in combination with the adjuvants. In general, cuticular transpiration increased after adding the pure adjuvants to the surface of isolated cuticles or leaf envelopes. As waxes build the cuticular permeation barrier not only to AIs but also to water, the adjuvant wax interaction might affect the cuticular barrier properties leading to increased transpiration. Direct evidence for increased AI penetration with the adjuvants was given using isolated cuticles of P. laurocerasus in combination with the non-steady-state setup simulation of foliar penetration (SOFP) and caffeine at relative humidity levels (RH) of 30, 50 and 80 \%. The increase in caffeine penetration was much more pronounced using C10E5 and C10E8 than MeO but always independent of RH. Only C10E2 exhibited an increased penetration enhancing effect positively related to RH. The role of the molecular structure of adjuvants in terms of humectant and plasticizer properties are discussed. Hence, the current work shows for the first time that the cuticular permeation barrier is associated with the VLCAs rather than the cyclic fraction and that adjuvants structurally influence this barrier resulting in penetration enhancing effects. Additionally, this work demonstrates that an artificial model wax is feasible to mimic the wax adjuvant interaction in conformity with a leaf wax, making it feasible for in-vitro experiments on a larger scale (e.g. screenings). This provides valuable knowledge about the cuticular barrier modification to enhance AI penetration which is a crucial factor concerning the optimization of AI formulations in agrochemistry.},
  subject      = {Adjuvans},
  language  = {en}
}