@phdthesis{Schilling2020,
  author    = {Schilling, Klaus Jussi},
  title     = {Liquid chromatographic analysis of weakly- and non-chromophore compounds focusing on Charged Aerosol Detection},
  doi       = {10.25972/OPUS-20211},
  url       = {http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-202114},
  school      = {Universit{\"a}t W{\"u}rzburg},
  year      = {2020},
  abstract  = {Liquid chromatography has become the gold standard for modern quality control and purity analytics since its establishment in the 1930s. However, some analytical questions remain very challenging even today. Several molecules and impurities do not possess a suitable chromophore for the application of UV detection or cannot be retained well on regular RP columns. Possible solutions are found in derivatization procedures, but they are time consuming and can be prone to errors. In order to detect non chromophore molecules underivatized, the concept of aerosol based universal detection was established with the introduction of the evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD) in the 1970s and the charged aerosol detector (CAD) followed in 2002. These two challenging fields - polar and non chromophore molecules - are tackled in this thesis. An overview of applications of the CAD in the literature and a comparison to its aerosol based competitors and MS is presented, emphasizing on its high sensitivity and robustness. Parameters and techniques to overcome the drawbacks of CAD, such as the use of gradient compensation or adjusted evaporation temperatures are discussed. A consideration of aspects and drawbacks of data transformation such as the integrated power function value (PFV) in the GMP environment is performed. A method for the fatty acid analysis in polysorbate 80 that was developed on HPLC CAD was transferred to UHPLC CAD. Time and eluent savings of over 75\% and 40\%, respectively, as well as ways to determine the optimal CAD parameters resulted from this investigation. The evaporation temperature was determined as the most crucial setting, which has to be adjusted with care. Optimal signal to noise ratios are found at a compromise between maintaining analyte signal and reducing background noise. The incorporation of semi volatile short chain fatty acids enabled the observation of differences based on volatility of the analyte. E.g. for semi volatiles, an improved linearity by means of adjusting the PFV is achieved at values below 1.0 instead of at elevated PFVs. Using sugars and sugar related antibiotics, a proof-of-concept was given that artificial neural networks can describe correlations between the structure and physicochemical properties of molecules and their response in CAD. Quantitative structure property relationships obtained by design of experiment approaches were able to predict the response of unseen substances and yielded insights on the response generation of the detector, which heavily relies on the formed surface area of the dried particle. Further work can substantiate upon these findings, eventually building a library of diverse eluent compositions, analytes and settings. In order to cope with a chromatographically challenging substances, the application of ion pairing reversed phase chromatography coupled to low wavelength UV detection has been shown as a possible approach for the amino acid L asparagine. A method capable of compendial purity analysis in one single HPLC approach, thus making the utilization of the semi quantitative TLC-ninhydrin analysis obsolete, resulted from this. One cyclic dipeptide impurity (diketoasparagine) that was formerly not assessed, could be identified in several batches and added to the monograph of the Ph.Eur. Studying ibandronate sodium with CAD and ELSD, it was found that randomly occurring spike peaks represent a major flaw of the ELSD when high sample load is present. The research with this non chromophore bisphosphonate drug furthermore shed light on possible drawbacks of mixed mode chromatography methods and ways to overcome these issues. Due to strong adsorption of the analyte onto the column, over ten injections of the highly concentrated test solution were found to be necessary to ensure reproducible peak areas. Preconditioning steps should thus be evaluated for mixed mode approaches during method development and validation. Last, using a ternary mixed mode stationary phase coupled to CAD, a method for the impurity profiling of pamidronate disodium, also applicable to the assessment of phosphate and phosphite in four other bisphosphonate drugs, has been developed. This represents a major advantage over the Ph.Eur. impurity profiling of pamidronate, which requires two different methods, one of which is only a semi quantitative TLC approach.},
  subject      = {HPLC},
  language  = {en}
}
@phdthesis{Pawellek2021,
  author    = {Pawellek, Ruben},
  title     = {Charged Aerosol Detector Performance Evaluation and Development of Optimization Strategies for the Analysis of Amino Acids},
  doi       = {10.25972/OPUS-24319},
  url       = {http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-243197},
  school      = {Universit{\"a}t W{\"u}rzburg},
  year      = {2021},
  abstract  = {The charged aerosol detector (CAD) is an aerosol-based detector employed in liquid chromatography which has become established in the field of pharmaceutical analysis due to its outstanding performance characteristics, e.g. the almost uniform response for nonvolatile analytes. Owing to its principle of detection, the response of the CAD depends on the volatility of a compound and is inherently nonlinear. However, the newly implemented instrumental settings evaporation temperature and power function value (PFV) are valuable tools to overcome some of these drawbacks and can even enhance the detector's capabilities when adjusted properly. This thesis aimed to evaluate the impact of the new instrumental settings on the CAD performance. Additionally, the influence of modern separation techniques for small polar compounds on the CAD was assessed and the applicability of hyphenated UV-CAD techniques explored. The optimization strategies derived from the evaluation procedures and the conjunction of the instrumental and chromatographic techniques investigated were utilized for the challenging impurity profiling of amino acids and amino acid-like drugs. The results of the method validation procedures confirmed the broad applicability of the CAD in the pharmaceutical analysis of nonvolatile compounds, supported by satisfactory sensitivity and reproducibility for meeting the regulatory requirements with respect to the ICH guidelines Q2(R1) and Q3A(R2). The limits of applicability include the analysis of semivolatile compounds, and the method transfer between current and legacy CAD models. Further advances in the definition and standardization of allowed ranges for the instrumental settings and the establishment of general optimization procedures in the method development could lead to a more widespread use of the detection technique in compendial methods.},
  subject      = {Instrumentelle Analytik},
  language  = {en}
}
@phdthesis{Leistner2023,
  author    = {Leistner, Adrian Dieter},
  title     = {Improving the quality analysis of monographed drugs - dapsone, baclofen, acarbose and other selected APIs},
  doi       = {10.25972/OPUS-30331},
  url       = {http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-303318},
  school      = {Universit{\"a}t W{\"u}rzburg},
  year      = {2023},
  abstract  = {All presented studies aimed on the improvement of the quality analysis of already monographed drugs. Thereby different LC methods were applied and coupled to i.e., the UV/VIS detector, the CAD or a hyphenation of these detectors, respectively. The choice of the chromatographic system including the detector was largely dependent on the physicochemical properties of the respective analytes. With the risk-assessment report on the API cetirizine we presented an exemplary tool, that can help to minimize the risk of the occurrence of unexpected impurities. An in- deep analysis of each step within synthesis pathway by means of reaction matrices of all compounds was performed. It is essential to understand the complete impurity profile of all reactants, solvents, and catalysts and to include them in the matrix. Finally, the API of this synthesis was checked if all impurities are identified by this tool. Of note, a shortcoming of such a targeted approach is that impurities can still occur, but they are not captured. This disadvantage can be partially compensated by non-targeted approaches if they are performed in parallel with the other studies that represent most of the impurities. However, this work also shows that even in a supposedly simple synthesis, potentially hundreds of by-products can be formed. For each of them, it must be decided individually whether their formation is probable or how their quantity can be minimized in order to obtain APIs, that are as pure as possible. In the dapsone project it was aimed to replace the existing old Ph. Eur. TLC method with a modern RP-HPLC method. This was successful and since Ph. Eur. 10.6, the method developed in this work, became a valid monograph. Within the revision process of the monograph, the individual limits for impurities were tightened. However, this new method needs HPLC instrumentation, suitable to perform gradients. As this is not always available in all control laboratories, we also developed an alternative, more simple method using two different isocratic runs for the impurity analysis. The obtained batch results of both, the new pharmacopoeial method and the more simple one, were in a comparable order of magnitude. Furthermore, within the method development stage of the Ph. Eur. method, we could identify one unknown impurity of the impurity reference by high-resolution MS/MS analysis. Also, in the baclofen project it was aimed to replace the existing Ph. Eur. method with the introduction of an additional impurity to be quantified. A corresponding method was developed and validated. However, due to the harmonization process of the pharmacopoeias, it is currently not used. In addition, we tried to find further, non- 116 SUMMARY chromophoric impurities by means of the CAD. However, except for one counterion of an impurity, no further impurities were found. Also, the aforementioned new impurity could not be detected above the reporting threshold in the batches analyzed. As the only individually specified impurity A is also present at a low level, it can be concluded that the examined batches of baclofen are very pure. The use of universal detectors, such as the CAD can be particularly interesting for compounds with no chromophore or those with only a weak chromophore. Therefore, we decided to take a closer look at the impurity profile of acarbose. Currently, acarbose and its impurities are being studied by low wavelength UV detection at 210 nm. Therefore, the question arose whether there are no other impurities in the API that do not show absorption at this wavelength. CAD, which offers consistent detection properties for all non-volatile compounds, is ideally suited for this purpose. However, it was not so easy to use the CAD together with the UV detector, for example, as a hyphenated detection technique, because the Ph. Eur. method uses phosphate buffers. However, this is non-volatile and therefore inappropriate for the CAD. Therefore, an attempt was made to replace the buffer with a volatile one. However, since this did not lead to satisfactory results and rather the self-degradation process of the stationary phase used could be observed by means of the CAD, it was decided to switch to alternative stationary phases. A column screening also revealed further difficulties with acarbose and its impurities: they show an epimerization reaction at the end of the sugar chain. However, since one wanted to have uniform peaks in the corresponding chromatograms, one had to accelerate this reaction significantly to obtain only one peak for each component. This was best achieved by using two stationary phases: PGC and Amide-HILIC. Impurity-profiling methods could be developed on each of the two phases. In addition, as expected, new impurities could be detected, albeit at a low level. Two of them could even be identified by spiking experiments as the sugar fragments maltose and maltotriose. Taken together, it can be concluded, that this work has contributed significantly to the improvement of the quality analysis of monographed drugs. In addition to the presented general tool for the identification of potential impurities, one of the methods developed, had already been implemented to the Ph. Eur. In an effort to improve the CAD's universal detection capabilities, additional methods have also been developed. Further, new improved methods for the impurity profiling are ready to use.},
  subject      = {Instrumentelle Analytik},
  language  = {en}
}