TY - THES A1 - Pieger, Elisabeth T1 - Metacognition and Disfluency – The Effects of Disfluency on Monitoring and Performance T1 - Metakognition und Disfluency - Der Einfluss von Disfluency auf die Überwachung des Lernprozesses und auf die Leistung N2 - In this thesis, metacognition research is connected with fluency research. Thereby, the focus lies on how disfluency can be used to improve metacognitive monitoring (i.e., students` judgments during the learning process). Improving metacognitive monitoring is important in educational contexts in order to foster performance. Theories about metacognition and self-regulated learning suppose that monitoring affects control and performance. Accurate monitoring is necessary to initiate adequate control and better performance. However, previous research shows that students are often not able to accurately monitor their learning with meaningful text material. Inaccurate monitoring can result in inadequate control and low performance. One reason for inaccurate monitoring is that students use cues for their judgments that are not valid predictors of their performance. Because fluency might be such a cue, the first aim of this thesis is to investigate under which conditions fluency is used as a cue for judgments during the learning process. A fluent text is easy to process and, hence, it should be judged as easy to learn and as easy to remember. Inversely, a disfluent text is difficult to process, for example because of a disfluent font type (e.g., Mistral) or because of deleted letters (e.g., l_tt_rs). Hence, a disfluent text should be judged as difficult to learn and as difficult to remember. This assumption is confirmed when students learn with both fluent and disfluent material. When fluency is manipulated between persons, fluency seems to be less obvious as a cue for judgments. However, there are only a few studies that investigated the effects of fluency on judgments when fluency is manipulated between persons. Results from Experiment 1 (using deleted letters for disfluent text) and from Experiment 4 (using Mistral for disfluent text) in this thesis support the assumption that fluency is used as a cue for judgments in between-person designs. Thereby, however, the interplay with the type of judgment and the learning stage seems to matter. Another condition when fluency affects judgments was investigated in Experiment 2 and 3. The aim of these experiments was to investigate if disfluency leads to analytic monitoring and if analytic monitoring sustains for succeeding fluent material. If disfluency activates analytic monitoring that remains for succeeding fluent material, fluency should no longer be used as a cue for judgments. Results widely support this assumption for deleted letters (Experiment 2) as well as for the font type Mistral (Experiment 3). Thereby, again the interplay between the type of judgment and the learning stage matters. Besides the investigation of conditions when fluency is used as a cue for different types of judgments during the learning process, another aim of this thesis is to investigate if disfluency leads to accurate monitoring. Results from Experiment 3 and 4 support the assumption that Mistral can reduce overconfidence. This is the case when fluency is manipulated between persons or when students first learn with a fluent and then with a disfluent text. Dependent from the type of judgment and the learning stage, disfluency can lead even to underconfidence or to improved relative monitoring accuracy (Experiment 4). Improving monitoring accuracy is only useful when monitoring is implemented into better control and better performance. The effect of monitoring accuracy on control and performance was in the focus of Experiment 4. Results show that accurate monitoring does not result in improved control and performance. Thus, further research is required to develop interventions that do not only improve monitoring accuracy but that also help students to implement accurate monitoring into better control and performance. Summing up, the aim of this thesis is to investigate under which conditions fluency is used as a cue for judgments during the learning process, how disfluency can be used to improve monitoring accuracy, and if improved monitoring accuracy leads to improved performance. By connecting metacognition research and fluency research, further theories about metacognition and theories about fluency are specified. Results show that not only the type of fluency and the design, but also the type of judgment, the type of monitoring accuracy, and the learning stage should be taken into account. Understanding conditions that affect the interplay between metacognitive processes and performance as well as understanding the underlying mechanisms is necessary to enable systematic research and to apply findings into educational settings. N2 - Ziel dieser Dissertation ist es, den Einfluss von Disfluency auf metakognitive Einschätzungen sowie deren Genauigkeit und deren Einfluss auf die Leistung zu untersuchen. Dabei wird die Metakognitions- mit der Fluency-Forschung verbunden. Theorien der Metakognition und des Selbstregulierten Lernens postulieren, dass metakognitive Einschätzungen den Lernprozess sowie die Leistung beeinflussen. Genaue Einschätzungen der eigenen Leistung sind notwendig, um adäquate Lernprozesse zu initiieren und die Leistung zu verbessern. In der bisherigen Forschung zeigte sich allerdings, dass Personen ihre eigene Leistung häufig falsch einschätzen, v. a. beim Lernen mit Texten. Als Folge ungenauer Einschätzungen können dysfunktionale Lernprozesse sowie schlechtere Leistung resultieren. Ein möglicher Grund für ungenaue Einschätzungen ist die Verwendung von Cues (Hinweisreizen), die keine validen Prädiktoren für die Leistung sind. Ein solcher Cue könnte Fluency sein. Fluente Texte sind leicht zu verarbeiten und sollten deshalb auch als leicht zu lernen und als leicht zu erinnern eingeschätzt werden. Umgekehrt sollten Texte, deren Verarbeitungsflüssigkeit beispielsweise durch eine disfluente Schriftart (z. B. Mistral) oder durch Löschung von Buchstaben (z. B. B_chst_b_n) herabgesetzt ist, als schwerer zu lernen und zu erinnern eingeschätzt werden. Diese Annahme wurde bisher v. a. dann bestätigt, wenn Personen sowohl mit fluentem als auch disfluentem Material lernen. Wird Fluency zwischen Personen manipuliert, scheint Fluency ein weniger offensichtlicher Cue zu sein. Allerdings ist die Anzahl an Studien, die Fluency zwischen Personen manipuliert haben, begrenzt. In dieser Dissertation wurde sowohl in Experiment 1 für die Löschung von Buchstaben, als auch in Experiment 4 für die Schriftart Mistral bestätigt, dass auch eine Manipulation zwischen Personen Einschätzungen beeinflussen kann, wobei jeweils die Interaktion mit der Art der Einschätzung und dem Zeitpunkt im Lernprozess berücksichtigt werden müssen. Eine weitere Bedingung, unter der Fluency die Einschätzungen beeinflusst, wurde in Experiment 2 und 3 untersucht. Ziel dieser Experimente war es u. a. herauszufinden, ob Disfluency zu einer analytischeren Überwachung des eigenen Lernprozesses führt und ob diese auch für nachfolgendes fluentes Material anhält. Als Folge analytischer Überwachungsprozesse für disfluentes und fluentes Material sollte Fluency nicht länger als Cue für Einschätzungen verwendet werden. Die Ergebnisse bestätigen dies weitgehend sowohl für die Löschung von Buchstaben (Experiment 2) als auch für die Verwendung der Schriftart Mistral (Experiment 3). Auch hier gibt es allerdings Interaktionen mit der Art der Einschätzung und dem Zeitpunkt im Lernprozess. Neben der Untersuchung, unter welchen der genannten Bedingungen Fluency Effekte auf verschiedene Arten von Einschätzungen im Lernprozess gefunden werden, ist es ein weiteres Ziel dieser Dissertation zu untersuchen, ob Disfluency durch die Initiierung analytischer Überwachungsprozesse auch zu genaueren Einschätzungen führt. Die Befunde aus Experiment 3 und 4 zeigen, dass Mistral die oft gefundene Überschätzung reduziert, wenn die Fluency zwischen Personen manipuliert wird oder zuerst mit fluentem und anschließend mit disfluentem Text gelernt wird. Abhängig von der Art der Einschätzung und des Zeitpunkts im Lernprozess kann Mistral sogar zu Unterschätzung führen und auch die relative Genauigkeit verbessern (Experiment 4). Eine Verbesserung der Genauigkeit von Einschätzungen ist v. a. dann sinnvoll, wenn genauere Einschätzungen auch zu besseren Lernprozessen und zu besserer Leistung führen. Dies wurde in Experiment 4 untersucht. Hier zeigte sich allerdings, dass genauere Einschätzungen nicht zu einer besseren Leistung führen. Deshalb sollten in der weiteren Forschung Interventionen entwickelt werden, die nicht nur die Genauigkeit von Einschätzungen, sondern auch deren Transfer in bessere Lernprozesse und in bessere Leistung fördern. Insgesamt ist es also das Ziel dieser Dissertation zu untersuchen, wann Disfluency verschiedene Einschätzungen im Lernprozess beeinflusst, ob Disfluency zu analytischeren und genaueren Einschätzungen führt, und ob genauere Einschätzungen letztendlich in besserer Leistung resultieren. Die Verbindung der Metakognitions- mit der Fluency-Forschung ermöglicht dabei, nicht nur Theorien zur Metakognition sondern auch zur Fluency zu spezifizieren. Wie die Befunde zeigen, müssen nicht nur verschiedene Arten der Fluency und des Designs, sondern auch verschiedene Arten von Einschätzungen und deren Genauigkeit, sowie der Zeitpunkt der Einschätzung im Lernprozess berücksichtigt werden. Die Kenntnis von Zusammenhängen und Bedingungen sowie von zugrundeliegenden Mechanismen ist wichtig, um bisherige inkonsistente Befunde systematisieren zu können und schließlich lernförderliche Interventionen ableiten zu können. KW - Metakognition KW - Selbstgesteuertes Lernen KW - Textverstehen KW - Lernen KW - Verarbeitungsflüssigkeit KW - metacognition KW - metacomprehension KW - judgments KW - overconfidence KW - monitoring KW - control KW - fluency KW - disfluency KW - learning Y1 - 2017 U6 - http://nbn-resolving.de/urn/resolver.pl?urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-155362 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Arenas, Andrés A1 - Roces, Flavio T1 - Avoidance of plants unsuitable for the symbiotic fungus in leaf-cutting ants: Learning can take place entirely at the colony dump JF - PLoS ONE N2 - Plants initially accepted by foraging leaf-cutting ants are later avoided if they prove unsuitable for their symbiotic fungus. Plant avoidance is mediated by the waste produced in the fungus garden soon after the incorporation of the unsuitable leaves, as foragers can learn plant odors and cues from the damaged fungus that are both present in the recently produced waste particles. We asked whether avoidance learning of plants unsuitable for the symbiotic fungus can take place entirely at the colony dump. In order to investigate whether cues available in the waste chamber induce plant avoidance in naïve subcolonies, we exchanged the waste produced by subcolonies fed either fungicide-treated privet leaves or untreated leaves and measured the acceptance of untreated privet leaves before and after the exchange of waste. Second, we evaluated whether foragers could perceive the avoidance cues directly at the dump by quantifying the visits of labeled foragers to the waste chamber. Finally, we asked whether foragers learn to specifically avoid untreated leaves of a plant after a confinement over 3 hours in the dump of subcolonies that were previously fed fungicide-treated leaves of that species. After the exchange of the waste chambers, workers from subcolonies that had access to waste from fungicide-treated privet leaves learned to avoid that plant. One-third of the labeled foragers visited the dump. Furthermore, naïve foragers learned to avoid a specific, previously unsuitable plant if exposed solely to cues of the dump during confinement. We suggest that cues at the dump enable foragers to predict the unsuitable effects of plants even if they had never been experienced in the fungus garden. KW - leaves KW - ants KW - fungi KW - foraging KW - animal sociality KW - social systems KW - learning KW - symbiosis Y1 - 2017 U6 - http://nbn-resolving.de/urn/resolver.pl?urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-157559 VL - 12 IS - 3 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Hofmann, Lukas A1 - Karl, Franziska A1 - Sommer, Claudia A1 - Üçeyler, Nurcan T1 - Affective and cognitive behavior in the alpha-galactosidase A deficient mouse model of Fabry disease JF - PLoS ONE N2 - Fabry disease is an X-linked inherited lysosomal storage disorder with intracellular accumulation of globotriaosylceramide (Gb3) due to α-galactosidase A (α-Gal A) deficiency. Fabry patients frequently report of anxiety, depression, and impaired cognitive function. We characterized affective and cognitive phenotype of male mice with α-Gal A deficiency (Fabry KO) and compared results with those of age-matched male wildtype (WT) littermates. Young (3 months) and old (≥ 18 months) mice were tested in the naïve state and after i.pl. injection of complete Freund`s adjuvant (CFA) as an inflammatory pain model. We used the elevated plus maze (EPM), the light-dark box (LDB) and the open field test (OF) to investigate anxiety-like behavior. The forced swim test (FST) and Morris water maze (MWM) were applied to assess depressive-like and learning behavior. The EPM test revealed no intergroup difference for anxiety-like behavior in naïve young and old Fabry KO mice compared to WT littermates, except for longer time spent in open arms of the EPM for young WT mice compared to young Fabry KO mice (p<0.05). After CFA injection, young Fabry KO mice showed increased anxiety-like behavior compared to young WT littermates (p<0.05) and naïve young Fabry KO mice (p<0.05) in the EPM as reflected by shorter time spent in EPM open arms. There were no relevant differences in the LDB and the OF test, except for longer time spent in the center zone of the OF by young WT mice compared to young Fabry KO mice (p<0.05). Complementary to this, depression-like and learning behavior were not different between genotypes and age-groups, except for the expectedly lower memory performance in older age-groups compared to young mice. Our results indicate that genetic influences on affective and cognitive symptoms in FD may be of subordinate relevance, drawing attention to potential influences of environmental and epigenetic factors. KW - cognitive impairment KW - mouse models KW - depression KW - swimming KW - learning KW - Fabry disease KW - genetics Y1 - 2017 U6 - http://nbn-resolving.de/urn/resolver.pl?urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-170745 VL - 12 IS - 6 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Chen, Yi-chun A1 - Mishra, Dushyant A1 - Gläß, Sebastian A1 - Gerber, Bertram T1 - Behavioral Evidence for Enhanced Processing of the Minor Component of Binary Odor Mixtures in Larval Drosophila JF - Frontiers in Psychology N2 - A fundamental problem in deciding between mutually exclusive options is that the decision needs to be categorical although the properties of the options often differ but in grade. We developed an experimental handle to study this aspect of behavior organization. Larval Drosophila were trained such that in one set of animals odor A was rewarded, but odor B was not (A+/B), whereas a second set of animals was trained reciprocally (A/B+). We then measured the preference of the larvae either for A, or for B, or for “morphed” mixtures of A and B, that is for mixtures differing in the ratio of the two components. As expected, the larvae showed higher preference when only the previously rewarded odor was presented than when only the previously unrewarded odor was presented. For mixtures of A and B that differed in the ratio of the two components, the major component dominated preference behavior—but it dominated less than expected from a linear relationship between mixture ratio and preference behavior. This suggests that a minor component can have an enhanced impact in a mixture, relative to such a linear expectation. The current paradigm may prove useful in understanding how nervous systems generate discrete outputs in the face of inputs that differ only gradually. KW - learning KW - memory KW - perception KW - compound conditioning KW - decision-making KW - Drosophila Y1 - 2017 U6 - http://nbn-resolving.de/urn/resolver.pl?urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-170011 VL - 8 IS - 1923 ER -