TY - THES A1 - Rudloff, Jan Philipp T1 - Post-Truth Epistemic Beliefs Rooted in the Dark Factor of Personality Predict Irrational Cognition and Behavior T1 - Postfaktische epistemische Überzeugungen und der Dunkle Faktor der Persönlichkeit sagen irrationale Kognitionen und Verhaltensweisen vorher N2 - Conspiracy theories and fake news are receiving wide media coverage and their proliferation has motivated academic research on the driving factors irrational cognition and behavior. This dissertation focuses on individuals' beliefs about knowledge and knowing, which are commonly referred to as epistemic beliefs. The term post-truth epistemic beliefs is proposed and defined as a strong trust in one’s intuition, a low need to align opinions with evidence, and the strong conviction that truth is a matter of power. Across six online studies, a mediation model is proposed and tested. It includes the core of all dark traits, the Dark Factor of Personality (D), as an antecedent of post-truth epistemic beliefs, and irrational cognition and behavior as consequences. Manuscript #1 comprises four studies showing that post-truth epistemic beliefs are rooted in D and predict increased endorsement of COVID-19 conspiracy theories as well as less engagement in health-protective behavior against COVID-19. Manuscript #2 includes a US nationally representative study suggesting that post-truth epistemic beliefs and D predict a lower probability of having been vaccinated against COVID-19. Manuscript #3 presents a repeated measures experiment indicating that the nexus of D and post-truth epistemic beliefs also predicts less discernment between fake and accurate news. These findings highlight a major insight and a serious challenge for rational communication: Some individuals deliberately disregard (scientific) evidence and rational decision-making. Against this background, the need to foster the epistemological development of students and educators is emphasized. N2 - Verschwörungstheorien und Fake News werden in den Medien lebhaft diskutiert und haben zu einem verstärkten Interesse wissenschaftlicher Forschung an den Risikofaktoren für irrationale Überzeugungen und irrationales Verhalten beigetragen. Die vorliegende Dissertation konzentriert sich in diesem Zusammenhang auf individuelle Überzeugungen darüber, was Wissen ist und wie es entsteht, welche als epistemische Überzeugungen bezeichnet werden. In dieser Arbeit wird der Begriff der postfaktischen epistemischen Überzeugungen verwendet – für ein starkes Vertrauen in die eigene Intuition, ein geringes Bedürfnis, Meinungen mit Beweisen abzugleichen und die Überzeugung, dass Wahrheit eine Frage von Macht ist. Ein Mediationsmodell wird über sechs Online-Studien hinweg vorgeschlagen und getestet. Es enthält den Kern aller dunklen Persönlichkeitsmerkmale, den Dunklen Faktor der Persönlichkeit (D), als Prädiktor von postfaktischen epistemischen Überzeugungen und irrationale Überzeugungen und irrationales Verhalten als deren Folgen. Manuskript 1 umfasst vier Studien, die zeigen, dass postfaktische epistemische Überzeugungen mit D verbunden sind und eine verstärkte Befürwortung von COVID-19-Verschwörungstheorien sowie ein verringertes Schutzverhalten bezüglich COVID-19 vorhersagen. Manuskript 2 enthält eine für die USA repräsentative Studie, die zeigt, dass postfaktische epistemische Überzeugungen und D vorhersagen, dass mit geringerer Wahrscheinlichkeit eine COVID-19-Schutzimpfung in Anspruch genommen wurde. Manuskript 3 enthält ein Experiment mit Messwiederholung, das zeigt, dass der Nexus aus D und postfaktischen epistemischen Überzeugungen vorhersagt, dass Menschen weniger zwischen falschen und wahren Nachrichten unterscheiden. Diese Ergebnisse liefern eine wichtige Erkenntnis, die eine ernsthafte Herausforderung für rationale Kommunikation aufzeigt: Einige Menschen lehnen bewusst (wissenschaftliche) Beweise und rationale Entscheidungen ab. Vor diesem Hintergrund wird die Notwendigkeit verdeutlicht, die epistemologische Entwicklung von Lernenden und Lehrenden verstärkt zu fördern. KW - Verschwörungstheorie KW - Desinformation KW - Falschmeldung KW - Fake News KW - Epistemische Überzeugungen KW - Dunkle Persönlichkeitsmerkmale Y1 - 2023 U6 - http://nbn-resolving.de/urn/resolver.pl?urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-344782 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Rudloff, Jan Philipp A1 - Hutmacher, Fabian A1 - Appel, Markus T1 - Post-truth epistemic beliefs rooted in the Dark Factor of Personality are associated with higher COVID-19 vaccination refusal JF - Scientific Reports N2 - A substantial number of people refused to get vaccinated against COVID-19, which prompts the question as to why. We focus on the role of individual worldviews about the nature and generation of knowledge (epistemic beliefs). We propose a model that includes epistemic beliefs, their relationship to the Dark Factor of Personality (D), and their mutual effect on the probability of having been vaccinated against COVID-19. Based on a US nationally representative sample (N = 1268), we show that stronger endorsement of post-truth epistemic beliefs was associated with a lower probability of having been vaccinated against COVID-19. D was also linked to a lower probability of having been vaccinated against COVID-19, which can be explained by post-truth epistemic beliefs. Our results indicate that the more individuals deliberately refrain from adhering to the better argument, the less likely they are vaccinated. More generally, post-truth epistemic beliefs pose a challenge for rational communication. KW - diseases KW - psychology Y1 - 2023 U6 - http://nbn-resolving.de/urn/resolver.pl?urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-357619 VL - 13 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Rudloff, Jan Philipp A1 - Hutmacher, Fabian A1 - Appel, Markus T1 - Beliefs about the nature of knowledge shape responses to the pandemic: Epistemic beliefs, the Dark Factor of Personality, and COVID‐19–related conspiracy ideation and behavior JF - Journal of Personality N2 - Objective Global challenges such as climate change or the COVID‐19 pandemic have drawn public attention to conspiracy theories and citizens' non‐compliance to science‐based behavioral guidelines. We focus on individuals' worldviews about how one can and should construct reality (epistemic beliefs) to explain the endorsement of conspiracy theories and behavior during the COVID‐19 pandemic and propose the Dark Factor of Personality (D) as an antecedent of post‐truth epistemic beliefs. Method and Results This model is tested in four pre‐registered studies. In Study 1 (N = 321), we found first evidence for a positive association between D and post‐truth epistemic beliefs (Faith in Intuition for Facts, Need for Evidence, Truth is Political). In Study 2 (N = 453), we tested the model proper by further showing that post‐truth epistemic beliefs predict the endorsement of COVID‐19 conspiracies and disregarding COVID‐19 behavioral guidelines. Study 3 (N = 923) largely replicated these results at a later stage of the pandemic. Finally, in Study 4 (N = 513), we replicated the results in a German sample, corroborating their cross‐cultural validity. Interactions with political orientation were observed. Conclusion Our research highlights that epistemic beliefs need to be taken into account when addressing major challenges to humankind. KW - conspiracy theories KW - COVID‐19 KW - Dark Factor of Personality KW - epistemic beliefs KW - post‐truth Y1 - 2022 U6 - http://nbn-resolving.de/urn/resolver.pl?urn:nbn:de:bvb:20-opus-293793 VL - 90 IS - 6 SP - 937 EP - 955 ER -