Refine
Has Fulltext
- yes (14)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (14)
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (14)
Language
- English (14)
Keywords
- Leistungsbewertung (12)
- Netzwerk (7)
- Performance Evaluation (5)
- Software Defined Networking (5)
- Optimierung (4)
- Quality of Experience (4)
- Telekommunikationsnetz (4)
- Optimization (3)
- Netzwerkmanagement (2)
- Routing (2)
Institute
This thesis contributes to several issues in the context of SDN and NFV, with an emphasis on performance and management.
The main contributions are guide lines for operators migrating to software-based networks, as well as an analytical model for the packet processing in a Linux system using the Kernel NAPI.
Computer systems have replaced human work-force in many parts of everyday life, but there still exists a large number of tasks that cannot be automated, yet. This also includes tasks, which we consider to be rather simple like the categorization of image content or subjective ratings. Traditionally, these tasks have been completed by designated employees or outsourced to specialized companies. However, recently the crowdsourcing paradigm is more and more applied to complete such human-labor intensive tasks. Crowdsourcing aims at leveraging the huge number of Internet users all around the globe, which form a potentially highly available, low-cost, and easy accessible work-force.
To enable the distribution of work on a global scale, new web-based services emerged, so called crowdsourcing platforms, that act as mediator between employers posting tasks and workers completing tasks. However, the crowdsourcing approach, especially the large anonymous worker crowd, results in two types of challenges. On the one hand, there are technical challenges like the dimensioning of crowdsourcing platform infrastructure or the interconnection of crowdsourcing platforms and machine clouds to build hybrid services. On the other hand, there are conceptual challenges like identifying reliable workers or migrating traditional off-line work to the crowdsourcing environment. To tackle these challenges, this monograph analyzes and models current crowdsourcing systems to optimize crowdsourcing workflows and the underlying infrastructure. First, a categorization of crowdsourcing tasks and platforms is developed to derive generalizable properties. Based on this categorization and an exemplary analysis of a commercial crowdsourcing platform, models for different aspects of crowdsourcing platforms and crowdsourcing mechanisms are developed. A special focus is put on quality assurance mechanisms for crowdsourcing tasks, where the models are used to assess the suitability and costs of existing approaches for different types of tasks. Further, a novel quality assurance mechanism solely based on user-interactions is proposed and its feasibility is shown. The findings from the analysis of existing platforms, the derived models, and the developed quality assurance mechanisms are finally used to derive best practices for two crowdsourcing use-cases, crowdsourcing-based network measurements and crowdsourcing-based subjective user studies. These two exemplary use-cases cover aspects typical for a large range of crowdsourcing tasks and illustrated the potential benefits, but also resulting challenges when using crowdsourcing.
With the ongoing digitalization and globalization of the labor markets, the crowdsourcing paradigm is expected to gain even more importance in the next years. This is already evident in the currently new emerging fields of crowdsourcing, like enterprise crowdsourcing or mobile crowdsourcing. The models developed in the monograph enable platform providers to optimize their current systems and employers to optimize their workflows to increase their commercial success. Moreover, the results help to improve the general understanding of crowdsourcing systems, a key for identifying necessary adaptions and future improvements.
Performance Assessment of Resource Management Strategies for Cellular and Wireless Mesh Networks
(2015)
The rapid growth in the field of communication networks has been truly amazing in the last decades. We are currently experiencing a continuation thereof with an increase in traffic and the emergence of new fields of application. In particular, the latter is interesting since due to advances in the networks and new devices, such as smartphones, tablet PCs, and all kinds of Internet-connected devices, new additional applications arise from different areas. What applies for all these services is that they come from very different directions and belong to different user groups. This results in a very heterogeneous application mix with different requirements and needs on the access networks.
The applications within these networks typically use the network technology as a matter of course, and expect that it works in all situations and for all sorts of purposes without any further intervention. Mobile TV, for example, assumes that the cellular networks support the streaming of video data. Likewise, mobile-connected electricity meters rely on the timely transmission of accounting data for electricity billing. From the perspective of the communication networks, this requires not only the technical realization for the individual case, but a broad consideration of all circumstances and all requirements of special devices and applications of the users.
Such a comprehensive consideration of all eventualities can only be achieved by a dynamic, customized, and intelligent management of the transmission resources. This management requires to exploit the theoretical capacity as much as possible while also taking system and network architecture as well as user and application demands into account. Hence, for a high level of customer satisfaction, all requirements of the customers and the applications need to be considered, which requires a multi-faceted resource management.
The prerequisite for supporting all devices and applications is consequently a holistic resource management at different levels. At the physical level, the technical possibilities provided by different access technologies, e.g., more transmission antennas, modulation and coding of data, possible cooperation between network elements, etc., need to be exploited on the one hand. On the other hand, interference and changing network conditions have to be counteracted at physical level. On the application and user level, the focus should be on the customer demands due to the currently increasing amount of different devices and diverse applications (medical, hobby, entertainment, business, civil protection, etc.).
The intention of this thesis is the development, investigation, and evaluation of a holistic resource management with respect to new application use cases and requirements for the networks. Therefore, different communication layers are investigated and corresponding approaches are developed using simulative methods as well as practical emulation in testbeds. The new approaches are designed with respect to different complexity and implementation levels in order to cover the design space of resource management in a systematic way. Since the approaches cannot be evaluated generally for all types of access networks, network-specific use cases and evaluations are finally carried out in addition to the conceptual design and the modeling of the scenario.
The first part is concerned with management of resources at physical layer. We study distributed resource allocation approaches under different settings. Due to the ambiguous performance objectives, a high spectrum reuse is conducted in current cellular networks. This results in possible interference between cells that transmit on the same frequencies. The focus is on the identification of approaches that are able to mitigate such interference.
Due to the heterogeneity of the applications in the networks, increasingly different application-specific requirements are experienced by the networks. Consequently, the focus is shifted in the second part from optimization of network parameters to consideration and integration of the application and user needs by adjusting network parameters. Therefore, application-aware resource management is introduced to enable efficient and customized access networks.
As indicated before, approaches cannot be evaluated generally for all types of access networks. Consequently, the third contribution is the definition and realization of the application-aware paradigm in different access networks. First, we address multi-hop wireless mesh networks. Finally, we focus with the fourth contribution on cellular networks. Application-aware resource management is applied here to the air interface between user device and the base station. Especially in cellular networks, the intensive cost-driven competition among the different operators facilitates the usage of such a resource management to provide cost-efficient and customized networks with respect to the running applications.
Today's Internet is no longer only controlled by a single stakeholder, e.g. a standard body or a telecommunications company.
Rather, the interests of a multitude of stakeholders, e.g. application developers, hardware vendors, cloud operators, and network operators, collide during the development and operation of applications in the Internet.
Each of these stakeholders considers different KPIs to be important and attempts to optimise scenarios in its favour.
This results in different, often opposing views and can cause problems for the complete network ecosystem.
One example of such a scenario are Signalling Storms in the mobile Internet, with one of the largest occurring in Japan in 2012 due to the release and high popularity of a free instant messaging application.
The network traffic generated by the application caused a high number of connections to the Internet being established and terminated.
This resulted in a similarly high number of signalling messages in the mobile network, causing overload and a loss of service for 2.5 million users over 4 hours.
While the network operator suffers the largest impact of this signalling overload, it does not control the application.
Thus, the network operator can not change the application traffic characteristics to generate less network signalling traffic.
The stakeholders who could prevent, or at least reduce, such behaviour, i.e. application developers or hardware vendors, have no direct benefit from modifying their products in such a way.
This results in a clash of interests which negatively impacts the network performance for all participants.
The goal of this monograph is to provide an overview over the complex structures of stakeholder relationships in today's Internet applications in mobile networks.
To this end, we study different scenarios where such interests clash and suggest methods where tradeoffs can be optimised for all participants.
If such an optimisation is not possible or attempts at it might lead to adverse effects, we discuss the reasons.
At the center of the Internet’s protocol stack stands the Internet Protocol (IP) as a common denominator that enables all communication. To make routing efficient, resilient, and scalable, several aspects must be considered. Care must be taken that traffic is well balanced to make efficient use of the existing network resources, both in failure free operation and in failure scenarios.
Finding the optimal routing in a network is an NP-complete problem. Therefore, routing optimization is usually performed using heuristics. This dissertation shows that a routing optimized with one objective function is often not good when looking at other objective functions. It can even be worse than unoptimized routing with respect to that objective function. After looking at failure-free routing and traffic distribution in different failure scenarios, the analysis is extended to include the loop-free alternate (LFA) IP fast reroute mechanism. Different application scenarios of LFAs are examined and a special focus is set on the fact that LFAs usually cannot protect all traffic in a network even against single link failures. Thus, the routing optimization for LFAs is targeted on both link utilization and failure coverage. Finally, the pre-congestion notification mechanism PCN for network admission control and overload protection is analyzed and optimized. Different design options for implementing the protocol are compared, before algorithms are developed for the calculation and optimization of protocol parameters and PCN-based routing.
The second part of the thesis tackles a routing problem that can only be resolved on a global scale. The scalability of the Internet is at risk since a major and intensifying growth of the interdomain routing tables has been observed. Several protocols and architectures are analyzed that can be used to make interdomain routing more scalable. The most promising approach is the locator/identifier (Loc/ID) split architecture which separates routing from host identification. This way, changes in connectivity, mobility of end hosts, or traffic-engineering activities are hidden from the routing in the core of the Internet and the routing tables can be kept much smaller. All of the currently proposed Loc/ID split approaches have their downsides. In particular, the fact that most architectures use the ID for routing outside the Internet’s core is a poor design, which inhibits many of the possible features of a new routing architecture. To better understand the problems and to provide a solution for a scalable routing design that implements a true Loc/ID split, the new GLI-Split protocol is developed in this thesis, which provides separation of global and local routing and uses an ID that is independent from any routing decisions.
Besides GLI-Split, several other new routing architectures implementing Loc/ID split have been proposed for the Internet. Most of them assume that a mapping system is queried for EID-to-RLOC mappings by an intermediate node at the border of an edge network. When the mapping system is queried by an intermediate node, packets are already on their way towards their destination, and therefore, the mapping system must be fast, scalable, secure, resilient, and should be able to relay packets without locators to nodes that can forward them to the correct destination. The dissertation develops a classification for all proposed mapping system architectures and shows their similarities and differences. Finally, the fast two-level mapping system FIRMS is developed. It includes security and resilience features as well as a relay service for initial packets of a flow when intermediate nodes encounter a cache miss for the EID-to-RLOC mapping.
Today’s Internet architecture was not designed from scratch but was driven by new services that emerged during its development. Hence, it is often described as patchwork where additional patches are applied in case new services require modifications to the existing architecture. This process however is rather slow and hinders the development of innovative network services with certain architecture or network requirements. Currently discussed technologies like Software-Defined Networking (SDN) or Network Virtualization (NV) are seen as key enabling technologies to overcome this rigid best effort legacy of the Internet. Both technologies offer the possibility to create virtual networks that accommodate the specific needs of certain services. These logical networks are operated on top of a physical substrate and facilitate flexible network resource allocation as physical resources can be added and removed depending on the current network and load situation. In addition, the clear separation and isolation of networks foster the development of application-aware networks that fulfill the special requirements of emerging applications. A prominent use case that benefits from these extended capabilities of the network is denoted with service component mobility. Services hosted on Virtual Machines (VMs) follow their consuming mobile endpoints, so that access latency as well as consumed network resources are reduced. Especially for applications like video streaming, which consume a large fraction of the available resources, is this an important means to relieve the resource constraints and eventually provide better service quality. Service and endpoint mobility both allow an adaptation of the used paths between an offered service, i.e., video streaming and the consuming users in case the service quality drops due to network problems. To make evidence-based adaptations in case of quality drops, a scalable monitoring component is required that is able to monitor the service quality for video streaming applications with reliable accuracy. This monograph details challenges that arise when deploying a certain service, i.e., video streaming, in a future virtualized network architecture and discusses possible solutions. In particular, this work evaluates the performance of mechanisms enabling service mobility and presents an optimized architecture for service mobility. Concerning endpoint mobility, improvements are developed that reduce the latency between endpoints and consumed services and ensure connectivity regardless of the used mobile access network. In the last part, a network-based video quality monitoring solution is developed and its accuracy is evaluated.
With the introduction of OpenFlow by the Stanford University in 2008, a process began in the area of network research, which questions the predominant approach of fully distributed network control. OpenFlow is a communication protocol that allows the externalization of the network control plane from the network devices, such as a router, and to realize it as a logically-centralized entity in software. For this concept, the term "Software Defined Networking" (SDN) was coined during scientific discourse.
For the network operators, this concept has several advantages. The two most important can be summarized under the points cost savings and flexibility. Firstly, it is possible through the uniform interface for network hardware ("Southbound API"), as implemented by OpenFlow, to combine devices and software from different manufacturers, which increases the innovation and price pressure on them. Secondly, the realization of the network control plane as a freely programmable software with open interfaces ("Northbound API") provides the opportunity to adapt it to the individual circumstances of the operator's network and to exchange information with the applications it serves. This allows the network to be more flexible and to react more quickly to changing circumstances as well as transport the traffic more effectively and tailored to the user’s "Quality of Experience" (QoE).
The approach of a separate network control layer for packet-based networks is not new and has already been proposed several times in the past. Therefore, the SDN approach has raised many questions about its feasibility in terms of efficiency and applicability. These questions are caused to some extent by the fact that there is no generally accepted definition of the SDN concept to date. It is therefore a part of this thesis to derive such a definition. In addition, several of the open issues are investigated. This Investigations follow the three aspects: Performance Evaluation of Software Defined Networking, applications on the SDN control layer, and the usability of SDN Northbound-API for creation application-awareness in network operation.
Performance Evaluation of Software Defined Networking: The question of the efficiency of an SDN-based system was from the beginning one of the most important. In this thesis, experimental measurements of the performance of OpenFlow-enabled switch hardware and control software were conducted for the purpose of answering this question. The results of these measurements were used as input parameters for establishing an analytical model of the reactive SDN approach. Through the model it could be determined that the performance of the software control layer, often called "Controller", is crucial for the overall performance of the system, but that the approach is generally viable. Based on this finding a software for analyzing the performance of SDN controllers was developed. This software allows the emulation of the forwarding layer of an SDN network towards the control software and can thus determine its performance in different situations and configurations. The measurements with this software showed that there are quite significant differences in the behavior of different control software implementations. Among other things it has been shown that some show different characteristics for various switches, in particular in terms of message processing speed. Under certain circumstances this can lead to network failures.
Applications on the SDN control layer: The core piece of software defined networking are the intelligent network applications that operate on the control layer. However, their development is still in its infancy and little is known about the technical possibilities and their limitations. Therefore, the relationship between an SDN-based and classical implementation of a network function is investigated in this thesis. This function is the monitoring of network links and the traffic they carry. A typical approach for this task has been built based on Wiretapping and specialized measurement hardware and compared with an implementation based on OpenFlow switches and a special SDN control application. The results of the comparison show that the SDN version can compete in terms of measurement accuracy for bandwidth and delay estimation with the traditional measurement set-up. However, a compromise has to be found for measurements below the millisecond range.
Another question regarding the SDN control applications is whether and how well they can solve existing problems in networks. Two programs have been developed based on SDN in this thesis to solve two typical network issues. Firstly, the tool "IPOM", which enables considerably more flexibility in the study of effects of network structures for a researcher, who is confined to a fixed physical test network topology.
The second software provides an interface between the Cloud Orchestration Software "OpenNebula" and an OpenFlow controller. The purpose of this software was to investigate experimentally whether a pre-notification of the network of an impending relocation of a virtual service in a data center is sufficient to ensure the continuous operation of that service. This was demonstrated on the example of a video service.
Usability of the SDN Northbound API for creating application-awareness in network operation: Currently, the fact that the network and the applications that run on it are developed and operated separately leads to problems in network operation. SDN offers with the Northbound-API an open interface that enables the exchange between information of both worlds during operation. One aim of this thesis was to investigate whether this interface can be exploited so that the QoE experienced by the user can be maintained on high level. For this purpose, the QoE influence factors were determined on a challenging application by means of a subjective survey study. The application is cloud gaming, in which the calculation of video game environments takes place in the cloud and is transported via video over the network to the user. It was shown that apart from the most important factor influencing QoS, i.e., packet loss on the downlink, also the type of game type and its speed play a role. This demonstrates that in addition to QoS the application state is important and should be communicated to the network. Since an implementation of such a state conscious SDN for the example of Cloud Gaming was not possible due to its proprietary implementation, in this thesis the application “YouTube video streaming” was chosen as an alternative. For this application, status information is retrievable via the "Yomo" tool and can be used for network control. It was shown that an SDN-based implementation of an application-aware network has distinct advantages over traditional network management methods and the user quality can be obtained in spite of disturbances.
Routing is one of the most important issues in any communication network. It defines on which path packets are transmitted from the source of a connection to the destination. It allows to control the distribution of flows between different locations in the network and thereby is a means to influence the load distribution or to reach certain constraints imposed by particular applications. As failures in communication networks appear regularly and cannot be completely avoided, routing is required to be resilient against such outages, i.e., routing still has to be able to forward packets on backup paths even if primary paths are not working any more.
Throughout the years, various routing technologies have been introduced that are very different in their control structure, in their way of working, and in their ability to handle certain failure cases. Each of the different routing approaches opens up their own specific questions regarding configuration, optimization, and inclusion of resilience issues. This monograph investigates, with the example of three particular routing technologies, some concrete issues regarding the analysis and optimization of resilience. It thereby contributes to a better general, technology-independent understanding of these approaches and of their diverse potential for the use in future network architectures.
The first considered routing type, is decentralized intra-domain routing based on administrative IP link costs and the shortest path principle. Typical examples are common today's intra-domain routing protocols OSPF and IS-IS. This type of routing includes automatic restoration abilities in case of failures what makes it in general very robust even in the case of severe network outages including several failed components. Furthermore, special IP-Fast Reroute mechanisms allow for a faster reaction on outages. For routing based on link costs, traffic engineering, e.g. the optimization of the maximum relative link load in the network, can be done indirectly by changing the administrative link costs to adequate values.
The second considered routing type, MPLS-based routing, is based on the a priori configuration of primary and backup paths, so-called Label Switched Paths. The routing layout of MPLS paths offers more freedom compared to IP-based routing as it is not restricted by any shortest path constraints but any paths can be setup. However, this in general involves a higher configuration effort.
Finally, in the third considered routing type, typically centralized routing using a Software Defined Networking (SDN) architecture, simple switches only forward packets according to routing decisions made by centralized controller units. SDN-based routing layouts offer the same freedom as for explicit paths configured using MPLS. In case of a failure, new rules can be setup by the controllers to continue the routing in the reduced topology. However, new resilience issues arise caused by the centralized architecture. If controllers are not reachable anymore, the forwarding rules in the single nodes cannot be adapted anymore. This might render a rerouting in case of connection problems in severe failure scenarios infeasible.
This dissertation focuses on the performance evaluation of all components of Software Defined Networking (SDN) networks and covers whole their architecture. First, the isolation between virtual networks sharing the same physical resources is investigated with SDN switches of several vendors. Then, influence factors on the isolation are identified and evaluated. Second, the impact of control mechanisms on the performance of the data plane is examined through the flow rule installation time of SDN switches with different controllers. It is shown that both hardware-specific and controller instance have a specific influence on the installation time. Finally, several traffic flow monitoring methods of an SDN controller are investigated and a new monitoring approach is developed and evaluated. It is confirmed that the proposed method allows monitoring of particular flows as well as consumes fewer resources than the standard approach. Based on findings in this thesis, on the one hand, controller developers can refer to the work related to the control plane, such as flow monitoring or flow rule installation, to improve the performance of their applications. On the other hand, network administrators can apply the presented methods to select a suitable combination of controller and switches in their SDN networks, based on their performance requirements
The thesis focuses on Quality of Experience (QoE) of HTTP adaptive video streaming (HAS) and traffic management in access networks to improve the QoE of HAS. First, the QoE impact of adaptation parameters and time on layer was investigated with subjective crowdsourcing studies. The results were used to compute a QoE-optimal adaptation strategy for given video and network conditions. This allows video service providers to develop and benchmark improved adaptation logics for HAS. Furthermore, the thesis investigated concepts to monitor video QoE on application and network layer, which can be used by network providers in the QoE-aware traffic management cycle. Moreover, an analytic and simulative performance evaluation of QoE-aware traffic management on a bottleneck link was conducted. Finally, the thesis investigated socially-aware traffic management for HAS via Wi-Fi offloading of mobile HAS flows. A model for the distribution of public Wi-Fi hotspots and a platform for socially-aware traffic management on private home routers was presented. A simulative performance evaluation investigated the impact of Wi-Fi offloading on the QoE and energy consumption of mobile HAS.