339 Makroökonomie und verwandte Themen
Refine
Has Fulltext
- yes (12)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (12)
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (8)
- Working Paper (2)
- Journal article (1)
- Report (1)
Keywords
- Geldpolitik (4)
- Makroökonomie (3)
- Wirtschaftswachstum (3)
- Einkommensverteilung (2)
- Industriepolitik (2)
- Notenbank (2)
- Ungleichheit (2)
- Wirtschaftsentwicklung (2)
- Außenwirtschaftspolitik (1)
- Bank credit (1)
Institute
The Macroeconomic Dimensions of Credit: A Comprehensive Analysis of Finance, Inequality and Growth
(2024)
Schumpeter's monetary growth theory is particularly influential for the modern understanding of the macroeconomic role of banks and credit. Based on this theory, this dissertation examines the macroeconomic role of the financial system, especially credit, in (1) generating economic growth, (2) directing economic resources and (3) distributing wealth.
Chapter 3 first shows empirically that 1) there is a positive correlation between the growth of credit and economic growth, even for developed countries, 2) no empirical correlation between household saving and economic growth can be established, and 3) there are both positive, negative and insignificant effects of credit on economic growth at country-specific level. Thus, there is broad empirical support for Schumpeter's monetary hypotheses.
A particularly interesting application of Schumpeter's growth theory can be seen in China. The results of the empirical study suggest that there is generally a positive correlation between credit and economic growth in China, that is, however, not linear in terms of regions, time and size of the financial system. Furthermore, the results in Chapter 4 suggest that credit-financed industrial policy in China may have contributed to more investment and GDP growth, although there are non-linearities between individual industries and types of companies.
Finally, Chapter 5 raises the question of the role of the financial system in the distribution of wealth. While credit to households and companies, together with indicators of working and saving behavior and the age structure of the population, are the most important determinants of wealth inequality, there are also various non-linearities in the relationship between credit and wealth inequality, including in relation to the level of development of financial systems and home ownership ratios.
We study nominal exchange rate dynamics in the aftermath of U.S. monetary policy announcements. Using high-frequency interest rate and stock price movements around FOMC announcements, we distinguish between pure monetary policy shocks and information shocks, which are associated with new information contained in the announcements. Contractionary pure policy shocks give rise to a strong, but transitory, appreciation on impact. Information shocks also appreciate the exchange rate, but the effect builds up only slowly over time and is highly persistent. Thus, we conclude that although the short-run effects on the exchange rate are primarily due to pure policy shocks, the medium-run response is driven by information effects.
This paper examines the potential reinforcement of motivated beliefs when individuals with identical biases communicate. We propose a controlled online experiment that allows to manipulate belief biases and the communication environment. We find that communication, even among like-minded individuals, diminishes motivated beliefs if it takes place in an environment without previously declared external opinions. In the presence of external plural opinions, however, communication does not reduce but rather aggravates motivated beliefs. Our results indicate a potential drawback of the plurality of opinions - it may create communication environments wherein motivated beliefs not only persist but also become contagious within social networks.
This study describes the Chinese growth model over the past 40 years. We show that China's growth model, with its dominant role of the banking system and "the banker", is a perfect illustration of the necessity and power of Schumpeter's "monetary analysis". This approach has allowed us to elaborate theoretically and empirically the uniqueness of the Chinese model. In our empirical analysis, we use a new dataset of Chinese provincial data to analyze the impact of the financial system, especially banks, on Chinese economic development. We also empirically assess the role of the financial system in Chinese industrial policy and provide case studies of the effects of industrial policy in specific sectors. Finally, we also discuss macroeconomic dimensions of the Chinese growth process and lessons that can be drawn from the Chinese experience for other countries.
The necessary adjustments to prominent measures of the neutral rate of interest following the COVID pandemic sparked a wide-ranging debate on the measurement and usefulness of r-star. Due to high uncertainty about relevant determinants, trend patterns and the correct estimation method, we propose in this paper a simple alternative approach derived from a standard macro model. Starting from a loss function, neutral periods can be determined in which a neutral real interest rate is observable. Using these values, a medium-term trend for a neutral interest rate can be determined. An application to the USA shows that our simple calculation of a neutral interest rate delivers comparable results to existing studies. A Taylor rule based on our neutral interest rate also does a fairly good job of explaining US monetary policy over the past 60 years.
Within three self-contained studies, this dissertation studies the impact and interactions between different macroeconomic policy measures in the context of financial markets empirically and quantitatively. The first study of this dissertation sheds light on the financial market effects of unconventional central bank asset purchase programs in the Eurozone, in particular sovereign bond asset purchase programs. The second study quantifies the direct implications of unconventional monetary policy on decisions by German public debt management regarding the maturity structure of gross issuance. The third study provides novel evidence on the role of private credit markets in the propagation of public spending toward private consumption in the U.S. economy. Across these three studies a set of different time-series econometric methods is applied including error correction models and event study frameworks to analyze contemporaneous interactions in financial and macroeconomic data in the context of unconventional monetary policy, as well as vector auto regressions (VARs) and local projections to trace the dynamic consequences of macroeconomic policies over time.
The contribution of this dissertation is to empirically analyze the link between income distribution, sectoral financial balances, and the current account. Firstly, it examines the relationship between the personal and the functional income distribution which may have rather different implications for aggregate demand and the current account. Secondly, it analyzes the importance of different sectors of the economy for current account balances and tests whether households are able to fully pierce the institutional veils of the corporate and the government sector. Thirdly, it investigates how changes in the personal and the functional income distribution affect the saving and investment decisions of the household and the corporate sector, and hence the current account. Finally, it shows how different growth regimes are linked to different patterns of personal and functional income distribution, and how differences in wage bargaining institutions contribute to explaining these different patterns of income distribution.
As a consequence of the financial crisis in 2008/09, some economists have expressed doubts about the adequacy of theoretical models, especially those that claim to model financial markets and banks. Because of these doubts, some economists are following a new paradigm based on a monetary theory rather than a commodity theory. The main difference between these two views is that in the commodity theory money does not play an essential role, whereas in a money economy every transaction is settled with money. It is therefore essential to clarify whether a theory that includes money comes to other conclusions than a theory that leaves money out.
Based on this problem, the second chapter compares the conclusions from the commodity logic of the financial system - modeled by the loanable funds theory - with the monetary logic. Following the review of the conclusions, I describe three theories about banks. The so-called endogenous money creation theory, in which the central banks control the lending of banks through prices, describes our world best.
In the third chapter, I use the endogenous money creation theory for modelling the bank credit market. In this model, banks act according to profit maximization, whereby income from lending business is generated and the costs of credit default risk and refinancing costs (including regulatory requirements) are incurred. These are the determinants of the supply of credit, which meets the demand for credit on the credit market. Credit demand is determined by borrowers who borrow from banks for consumption or investment purposes. The interplay between loan supply and demand for credit results in the equilibrium loan interest rate and the equilibrium loan volume that banks grant to non-banks. The supply and demand sides interacting on the credit market are empirically estimated for Germany over the period 1999-2014 based on the theoretical model using a disequilibirum framework, showing that the determinants from the theoretical model are statistically significant.
Building on the theoretical banking model, the fourth chapter extends the model to include the bond market. In contrast to the description in the commodity theory, the bank loan market and the bond market are fundamentally different. On the one hand, banks create money according to the endogenous money creation theory. Once the money is in circulation, non-banks can redistribute it by either using it for the purchase of goods or borrowing it for longer periods. Due to the focus on the financial system in this dissertation, the case is considered in which money is lent over the longer term. The motive of the suppliers in the bond market, i.e. those who want to lend money, is similar to that of banks, driven by profit maximization. Suppliers can generate income from interest on bonds. Costs arise from the opportunity costs of holding money as deposits, the credit default of the debtor and price losses due to changes in interest rates. The logic described is based on the idea that banks create money, i.e. they are originators of money, and the money is redistributed on the bond market and thus used several times. The two markets are linked on both the supply and demand sides. On the one hand, banks refinance themselves on the bond market in order to reduce the maturity transformation resulting from lending. In addition, consumers of credit have the option of requesting either bank loans or loans on the bond market.
After the description of the theoretical framework of the financial system consisting of the banking and bond market, the fifth chapter follows the application of the model for Quantitative Easing. It should be noted here that Quantitative Easing already influences the behaviour of credit consumers and suppliers when the central bank announces it. The four major central banks (Bank of Japan, Bank of England, Federal Reserve Bank and European Central Bank) have used the unconventional instrument of buying up bonds due to the continuing recession and the already low short-term interest rates. In the theoretical model, the central bank already influences bond market rates through the announcement, resulting in decreasing risk premiums, as the central bank acts as a lender of confidence, decreasing interest expectations (at least in the short term) and decreasing long-term interest rates overall. These three hypotheses are tested using empirical methods for the Euro area.
This dissertation contributes to the empirical analysis of economic development. The continuing poverty in many Sub-Saharan-African countries as well as the declining trend in growth in the advanced economies that was initiated around the turn of the millennium raises a number of new questions which have received little attention in recent empirical studies. Is culture a decisive factor for economic development? Do larger financial markets trigger positive stimuli with regard to incomes, or is the recent increase in their size in advanced economies detrimental to economic growth? What causes secular stagnation, i.e. the reduction in growth rates of the advanced economies observable over the past 20 years? What is the role of inequality in the growth process, and how do governmental attempts to equalize the income distribution affect economic development? And finally: Is the process of democratization accompanied by an increase in living standards? These are the central questions of this doctoral thesis.
To facilitate the empirical analysis of the determinants of economic growth, this dissertation introduces a new method to compute classifications in the field of social sciences. The approach is based on mathematical algorithms of machine learning and pattern recognition. Whereas the construction of indices typically relies on arbitrary assumptions regarding the aggregation strategy of the underlying attributes, utilization of Support Vector Machines transfers the question of how to aggregate the individual components into a non-linear optimization problem.
Following a brief overview of the theoretical models of economic growth provided in the first chapter, the second chapter illustrates the importance of culture in explaining the differences in incomes across the globe. In particular, if inhabitants have a lower average degree of risk-aversion, the implementation of new technology proceeds much faster compared with countries with a lower tendency towards risk. However, this effect depends on the legal and political framework of the countries, their average level of education, and their stage of development.
The initial wealth of individuals is often not sufficient to cover the cost of investments in both education and new technologies. By providing loans, a developed financial sector may help to overcome this shortage. However, the investigations in the third chapter show that this mechanism is dependent on the development levels of the economies. In poor countries, growth of the financial sector leads to better education and higher investment levels. This effect diminishes along the development process, as intermediary activity is increasingly replaced by speculative transactions. Particularly in times of low technological innovation, an increasing financial sector has a negative impact on economic development. In fact, the world economy is currently in a phase of this kind. Since the turn of the millennium, growth rates in the advanced economies have experienced a multi-national decline, leading to an intense debate about "secular stagnation" initiated at the beginning of 2015. The fourth chapter deals with this phenomenon and shows that the growth potentials of new technologies have been gradually declining since the beginning of the 2000s.
If incomes are unequally distributed, some individuals can invest less in education and technological innovations, which is why the fifth chapter identifies an overall negative effect of inequality on growth. This influence, however, depends on the development level of countries. While the negative effect is strongly pronounced in poor economies with a low degree of equality of opportunity, this influence disappears during the development process. Accordingly, redistributive polices of governments exert a growth-promoting effect in developing countries, while in advanced economies, the fostering of equal opportunities is much more decisive.
The sixth chapter analyzes the growth effect of the political environment and shows that the ambiguity of earlier studies is mainly due to unsophisticated measurement of the degree of democratization. To solve this problem, the chapter introduces a new method based on mathematical algorithms of machine learning and pattern recognition. While the approach can be used for various classification problems in the field of social sciences, in this dissertation it is applied for the problem of democracy measurement. Based on different country examples, the chapter shows that the resulting SVMDI is superior to other indices in modeling the level of democracy. The subsequent empirical analysis emphasizes a significantly positive growth effect of democracy measured via SVMDI.
Within three self-contained chapters, this dissertation provides new insights into the macroeconomic consequences of income inequality from a global perspective. Following an introduction, which summarizes the main findings and offers a brief overview of trends in income distribution, Chapter 2 evaluates the relationship between the labor share of income and the evolution of aggregate demand. Chapter 3 analyzes the link between income inequality and aggregate saving; and Chapter 4 directly estimates the effect of inequality and public redistribution on economic growth.