Refine
Has Fulltext
- yes (7)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (7)
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (7) (remove)
Language
- English (7) (remove)
Keywords
- Hyaluronsäure (3)
- Bioprinting (2)
- Cartilage Tissue Engineering (2)
- Extrazelluläre Matrix (2)
- Gelenkknorpel (2)
- Hydrogel (2)
- Tissue Engineering (2)
- 3D spheroid culture (1)
- 3D-Druck (1)
- AMPK (1)
Institute
- Klinik und Poliklinik für Unfall-, Hand-, Plastische und Wiederherstellungschirurgie (Chirurgische Klinik II) (7) (remove)
Articular cartilage is a highly specialized tissue which provides a lubricated gliding surface in joints and thereby enables low-friction movement. If damaged once it has a very low intrinsic healing capacity and there is still no treatment in the clinic which can restore healthy cartilage tissue. 3D biofabrication presents a promising perspective in the field by combining healthy cells and bioactive ink materials. Thereby, the composition of the applied bioink is crucial for defect restoration, as it needs to have the physical properties for the fabrication process and also suitable chemical cues to provide a supportive environment for embedded cells. In the last years, ink compositions with high polymer contents and crosslink densities were frequently used to provide 3D printability and construct stability. But these dense polymeric networks were often associated with restricted bioactivity and impaired cell processes like differentiation and the distribution of newly produced extracellular matrix (ECM), which is especially important in the field of cartilage engineering. Therefore, the aim of this thesis was the development of hyaluronic acid (HA)-based bioinks with a reduced polymer content which are 3D printable and additionally facilitate chondrogenic differentiation of mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) and the homogeneous distribution of newly produced ECM. Starting from not-printable hydrogels with high polymer contents and restricted bioactivity, distinct stepwise improvements were achieved regarding stand-alone 3D printability as well as MSC differentiation and homogeneous ECM distribution. All newly developed inks in this thesis made a valuable contribution in the field of cartilage regeneration and represent promising approaches for potential clinical applications. The underlying mechanisms and established ink design criteria can further be applied to other biofabricated tissues, emphasizing their importance also in a more general research setting.
The use of human adipose-derived mesenchymal stem cells (ASCs) for cell-based therapeutic approaches, in terms of repair and regeneration of various tissues and organs, offers an alternative therapeutic tool in the field of regenerative medicine. The ability of ASCs to differentiate along mesenchymal lineages is not the only property that makes these cells particularly attractive for therapeutic purposes. Their promising functions in promoting angiogenesis, reducing inflammation as well as in functional tissue restoration are largely related to the trophic effects of a broad panel of secreted cytokines and growth factors. However, in cell-based approaches, the cell-loaded construct often is exposed to an ischemic microenvironment characterized by severe oxidative and nutritional stress after transplantation due to the initial lack of vascular connection, resulting in reduced cell viability and altered cell behaviour. Therefore, the effective use of ASCs in regenerative medicine first requires a comprehensive characterization of the cells in terms of their viability, differentiation capacity and especially their secretory capabilities under ischemia-mimicking conditions in order to better understand their beneficial role. Accordingly, in the first part of this work, ASCs were investigated under different ischemic conditions, in which cells were exposed to both glucose and oxygen deprivation, with respect to viability and secretory function. Using mRNA gene expression analysis, significantly higher expression of selected angiogenic, anti-apoptotic and immunomodulatory factors (IL-6, VEGF, STC-1) could be demonstrated under harsh ischemic conditions. These results were reflected at the protein expression level by a significantly increased secretion of these factors. For stanniocalcin-1 (STC-1), a factor not yet described in ASCs, a particularly high expression with significant secreted amounts of the protein could be demonstrated under harsh ischemic conditions. Thus, the first part of this work, in addition to the characterization of the viability, provided first insights into the secretory response of ASCs under ischemic conditions.
The response of ASCs to glucose deficiency in combination with severe hypoxia has been little explored to date. Thus, the focus of the second part of this work was on a more detailed investigation of the secretory response of ASCs under glucose and oxygen deprivation. For a more comprehensive analysis of the secretion profile, a cytokine antibody array was performed, which allowed the detection of a broad panel of secreted angiogenic factors
(IL-8, ANG), matrix-regulating proteins (TIMP-1, TIMP-2), chemokines (MCP-1/CCL2,
IP-10/CXCL 10) and other factors under ischemic conditions. To verify these results, selected factors were examined using ELISA. The analysis revealed that the secretion of individual factors (e.g., STC-1, VEGF) was significantly upregulated by the combination of glucose and oxygen deprivation compared to oxygen deprivation alone.
In order to investigate the impact of the secretome of ischemic ASCs on cell types involved in tissue regeneration, the effect of conditioned medium of ischemia-challenged ASCs on both endothelial cells and fibroblasts was investigated in subsequent experiments. Significantly increased viability and tube formation of endothelial cells as well as activated migration of fibroblasts by the secreted factors of ischemic ASCs could be demonstrated. A direct correlation of these effects to STC-1, which was significantly upregulated under ischemic conditions and has been described as a regulator of key cellular functions, could not be verified.
The particular secretory capacity of ASCs provides a valuable tool for cell-based therapies, such as cell-assisted lipotransfer (CAL), where by enriching fat grafts with isolated ASCs, a significantly improved survival rate of the transplanted construct is achieved with less resorption of the fat tissue as well as a reduction in adverse implications, such as fibrosis and cyst formation. In order to better understand the function of ASCs in CAL, an autologous transwell-based lipograft-ASC co-culture was established in the last part of this work, in which first investigations showed a markedly increased secretion of VEGF compared to lipografts without added ASCs. As the stability rate of the fat tissue and thus the success of CAL is presumably also dependent on the preparation of the tissue before transplantation, the conventional preparation method of fat tissue for vocal fold augmentation in laryngoplasty was additionally evaluated in vitro in a pilot experiment. By analyzing the viability and tissue structure of the clinically prepared injection material, a large number of dead cells and a clearly damaged tissue structure with necrotic areas could be demonstrated. In comparison, the preparation method of the fat tissue established in this work as small tissue fragments was able to provide a clearly intact, vital, and vascularized tissue structure. This type of adipose tissue preparation represents a promising alternative for clinical vocal fold augmentation.
In conclusion, the results of this work contribute to a comprehensive characterization of ASCs under ischemic conditions, such as those prevalent at the transplantation site or in tissue regeneration. The results obtained, especially on the secretory capacity of ASCs, provide new insights into how ASCs mediate regenerative effects in an ischemic milieu and why their use for therapeutic purposes is highly attractive and promising.
Articular cartilage damage caused by sports accidents, trauma or gradual wear and tear can lead to degeneration and the development of osteoarthritis because cartilage tissue has only limited capacity for intrinsic healing. Osteoarthritis causes reduction of mobility and chronic pain and is one of the leading causes of disability in the elderly population. Current clinical treatment options can reduce pain and restore mobility for some time, but the formed repair tissue has mostly inferior functionality compared to healthy articular cartilage and does not last long-term. Articular cartilage tissue engineering is a promising approach for the improvement of the quality of cartilage repair tissue and regeneration. In this thesis, a promising new cell type for articular cartilage tissue engineering, the so-called articular cartilage progenitor cell (ACPC), was investigated for the first time in the two different hydrogels agarose and HA-SH/P(AGE-co-G) in comparison to mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs). In agarose, ACPCs´ and MSCs´ chondrogenic capacity was investigated under normoxic (21 % oxygen) and hypoxic (2 % oxygen) conditions in monoculture constructs and in zonally layered co-culture constructs with ACPCs in the upper layer and MSCs in the lower layer. In the newly developed hyaluronic acid (HA)-based hydrogel HA-SH/P(AGE-co-G), chondrogenesis of ACPCs and MSCs was also evaluated in monoculture constructs and in zonally layered co-culture constructs like in agarose hydrogel. Additionally, the contribution of the bioactive molecule hyaluronic acid to chondrogenic gene expression of MSCs was investigated in 2D monolayer, 3D pellet and HA-SH hydrogel culture. It was shown that both ACPCs and MSCs could chondrogenically differentiate in agarose and HA-SH/P(AGE-co-G) hydrogels. In agarose hydrogel, ACPCs produced a more articular cartilage-like tissue than MSCs that contained more glycosaminoglycan (GAG), less type I collagen and only little alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity. Hypoxic conditions did not increase extracellular matrix (ECM) production of ACPCs and MSCs significantly but improved the quality of the neo-cartilage tissue produced by MSCs. The creation of zonal agarose constructs with ACPCs in the upper layer and MSCs in the lower layer led to an ECM production in zonal hydrogels that lay in general in between the ECM production of non-zonal ACPC and MSC hydrogels. Even though zonal co-culture of ACPCs and MSCs did not increase ECM production, the two cell types influenced each other and, for example, modulated the staining intensities of type II and type I collagen in comparison to non-zonal constructs under normoxic and hypoxic conditions. In HA-SH/P(AGE-co-G) hydrogel, MSCs produced more ECM than ACPCs, but the ECM was limited to the pericellular region for both cell types. Zonal HASH/P(AGE-co-G) hydrogels resulted in a native-like zonal distribution of ECM as MSCs in the lower zone produced more ECM than ACPCs in the upper zone. It appeared that chondrogenesis of ACPCs was supported by hydrogels without biological attachment sites such as agarose, and that chondrogenesis of MSCs benefited from hydrogels with biological cues like HA. As HA is an attractive material for cartilage tissue engineering, and the HA-based hydrogel HA-SH/P(AGE-co-G) appeared to be beneficial for MSC chondrogenic differentiation, the contribution of HA to chondrogenic gene expression of MSCs was investigated. An upregulation of chondrogenic gene expression was found in 2D monolayer and 3D pellet culture of MSCs in response to HA supplementation, while gene expression of osteogenic and adipogenic transcription factors was not upregulated. MSCs, encapsulated in a HA-based hydrogel, showed upregulation of gene expression for chondrogenic, osteogenic and adipogenic differentiation markers as well as for stemness markers. In a 3D bioprinting process, using the HA-based hydrogel, gene expression levels of MSCs mostly did not change. Nevertheless, expression of three tested genes (COL2A1, SOX2, CD168) was downregulated in printed in comparison to cast constructs, underscoring the importance of closely monitoring cellular behaviour during and after the printing process. In summary, it was confirmed that ACPCs are a promising cell source for articular cartilage engineering with advantages over MSCs when they were cultured in a suitable hydrogel like agarose. The performance of the cells was strongly dependent on the hydrogel environment they were cultured in. The different chondrogenic performance of ACPCs and MSCs in agarose and HA-SH/P(AGE-co-G) hydrogels highlighted the importance of choosing suitable hydrogels for the different cell types used in articular cartilage tissue engineering. Hydrogels with high polymer content, such as the investigated HA-SH/P(AGE-co-G) hydrogels, can limit ECM distribution to the pericellular area and should be developed further towards less polymer content, leading to more homogenous ECM distribution of the cultured cells. The influence of HA on chondrogenic gene expression and on the balance between differentiation and maintenance of stemness in MSCs was demonstrated. More studies should be performed in the future to further elucidate the signalling functions of HA and the effects of 3D bioprinting in HA-based hydrogels. Taken together, the results of this thesis expand the knowledge in the area of articular cartilage engineering with regard to the rational combination of cell types and hydrogel materials and open up new possible approaches to the regeneration of articular cartilage tissue.
Articular cartilage is an exceptional connective tissue which by a network of fibrillar collagen and glycosaminoglycan (GAG) molecules allows both low- friction articulation and distribution of loads to the subchondral bone (Armiento et al., 2018, Ulrich-Vinther et al., 2003). Because of its very limited ability to self-repair, chondral defects following traumatic injury increase the risk for secondary osteoarthritis (OA) (Muthuri et al., 2011). Still, current OA treatments such as common nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) and joint replacement primarily address end-stage symptoms (Tonge et al., 2014). As low-grade inflammation plays a pivotal role in the pathogenesis of OA (Robinson et al., 2016), there is a strong demand for novel therapeutic concepts, such as integrating application of anti-inflammatory agents into cartilage cell- based therapies in order to effectively treat OA affected joints in early disease stages. The polyphenolic phytoalexin resveratrol (RSV), found in the skin of red grapes, berries, and peanuts, has been shown to have effective anti-inflammatory properties (Shen et al., 2012). However, its long-term effects on 3D chondrocyte constructs cultured in an inflammatory environment with regard to tissue quality have remained unexplored so far. Therefore, in this study, pellets made from expanded porcine articular chondrocytes were cultured for 14 days with either the pro-inflammatory cytokine interleukin-1β (IL-1β) (1 - 10 ng/ml) or RSV (50 μM) alone, or a co-treatment with both agents. Constructs treated with chondrocyte medium only served as control. Treatment with IL-1β at 10 ng/ml resulted in a significantly smaller pellet size and reduced DNA content. However, RSV counteracted the IL-1β-induced decrease and significantly enhanced diameter and DNA content. Also, in terms of GAG deposition, treatment with IL-1β at 10 ng/ml resulted in a tremendous depletion of absolute GAG content and GAG/DNA. Again, RSV co-treatment counteracted the inflammatory stimulus and led to a partial recovery of GAG content. Histological analysis utilizing safranin-O staining confirmed these findings. Marked expression of the cartilage-degrading enzyme matrix metalloproteinase 13 (MMP13) was detected in IL-1β-treated pellets, but none upon RSV co- treatment. Moreover, co-treatment of IL-1β-challenged constructs with RSV significantly increased absolute collagen content. However, under non- inflammatory conditions, RSV induced gene expression and protein accumulation of collagen type X, a marker for undesirable hypertrophy. Taken together, in the present thesis, RSV was demonstrated to elicit marked beneficial effects on the extracellular matrix composition of 3D cartilaginous constructs in long-term inflammatory culture in vitro, but also induced hypertrophy under non-inflammatory conditions. Based on these findings, further experiments examining multiple concentrations of RSV under various inflammatory conditions appear desirable concerning potential therapeutic applicability in OA.
Nicotinamide N-methyltransferase (NNMT) is a new regulator of energy homeostasis. Its expression is increased in models of obesity and diabetes. An enhanced NNMT level is also caused by an adipose tissue-specific knockout of glucose transporter type 4 (GLUT4) in mice, whereas the overexpression of this glucose transporter reduced the NNMT expression. Furthermore, the knockdown of the enzyme prevents mice from diet-induced obesity (DIO) and the recently developed small molecule inhibitors for NNMT reverses the DIO. These previous findings demonstrated the exclusive role of NNMT in adipose tissue and further make it to a promising target in obesity treatment. However, the regulation mechanism of this methyltransferase is not yet clarified.
The first part of the thesis focus on the investigation whether pro-inflammatory signals are responsible for the enhanced NNMT expression in obese adipose tissue because a hallmark of this tissue is a low-level chronic inflammation. Indeed, the NNMT mRNA in our study was elevated in obese patients compared with the control group, whereas the GLUT4 mRNA expression does not differ between lean and obese humans. To analyze whether pro inflammatory signals, like interleukin (IL 6) and tumor necrosis factor α (TNF-α), regulate NNMT expression 3T3-L1 adipocytes were treated with these cytokines. However, IL 6, TNF α, and leptin, which is an alternative activator of the JAK/STAT pathway, did not affect the NNMT protein or mRNA level in differentiated 3T3-L1 adipocytes. The mRNA and protein levels were measured by quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) and western blotting.
In the second part of this study, 3T3-L1 adipocytes were cultivated with varying glucose concentrations to show whether NNMT expression depends on glucose availability. Further studies with activators and inhibitors of AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) and mechanistic target of rapamycin (mTOR) signaling pathways were used to elucidate the regulation mechanism of the enzyme.
The glucose deprivation of differentiated 3T3-L1 adipocytes led to a 2-fold increase in NNMT expression. This effect was confirmed by the inhibition of the glucose transports with phloretin as well as the inhibition of glycolysis with 2-deoxyglucose (2-DG). AMPK serves as an intracellular energy sensor and the pharmacological activation of it enhanced the NNMT expression. This increase was also caused by the inhibition of mTOR. Conversely, the activation of mTOR using MHY1485 prevented the effect of glucose deprivation on NNMT. Furthermore, the NNMT up-regulation was also blocked by the different autophagy inhibitors.
Taken together, NNMT plays a critical role in autophagy in adipocytes, because an inhibition of this process prevented the augmented NNMT expression during glucose starvation. Moreover, the effect on NNMT protein and mRNA level depends on AMPK and mTOR. However, pro-inflammatory signals did not affect the expression. Further in vivo studies have to clarify whether AMPK activation and mTOR inhibition as well as autophagy are responsible for the increased NNMT levels in obese adipose tissue. In future this methyltransferase emerges as an awesome therapeutic target for obesity.
The ability to differentiate into mesenchymal lineages, as well as immunomodulatory, anti-inflammatory, anti-apoptotic, and angiogenic properties give ASCs great therapeutic potential. Through their culture as multicellular, three-dimensional spheroids this potential can even be enhanced. Accordingly, 3D spheroids are not only promising candidates for the application in regenerative medicine and inflammatory disease therapy, but also for the use as building blocks in tissue engineering approaches. Due to the resemblance to physiological cell-cell and cell-matrix interactions, 3D spheroids gain higher similarity to real tissues, what makes them a valuable tool in the development of bioactive constructs equivalent to native tissues in terms of its cellular and extracellular structure. Especially, to overcome the still tremendous clinical need for adequate implants to repair soft tissue defects, 3D spheroids consisting of ASCs are a promising approach in adipose tissue engineering. Nevertheless, studies on the use of ASC-based spheroids as building blocks for fat tissue reconstruction have so far been very rare. In order to optimally exploit their therapeutic potential to further their use in regenerative medicine, including adipose tissue engineering approaches, a 3D spheroid model consisting of ASCs was characterized extensively in this work. This included not only the elucidation of the structural features, but also the differentiation capacity, gene expression, and secretory properties. In addition, the elucidation of underlying mechanisms contributing to the improved therapeutic efficiency was addressed.
Improved treatment options for the degenerative joint disease osteoarthritis (OA) are of major interest, since OA is one of the main sources of disability, pain, and socioeconomic burden worldwide [202]. According to epidemiological data, already 27 million people suffer from OA in the US [23]. Moreover, the WHO expects OA to be the fourth most common cause of disability in 2020 [203], illustrating the need for effective and long-lasting therapy options of severe cartilage defects. Despite numerous clinically available products for the treatment of cartilage defects [62], the development of more cartilage-specific materials is still at the beginning.
Hyaluronic acid (HA) is a major component of the cartilaginous extracellular matrix (ECM) and inherently creates a cell-friendly niche by providing cell attachment and migration sites. Furthermore, it is known that the functional groups of HA are well suited for chemical modification. These characteristics render HA an attractive material for hydrogel-based tissue engineering approaches. Poly(glycidol) (PG) as chemical crosslinker basically features similar chemical characteristics as the widely used poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG), but provides additional side groups at each repeating unit that can be further chemically functionalized. With the introduction of PG as multifunctional crosslinker for HA gels, a higher cross-linking density and, accordingly, a greater potential for biomimetic functionalization may be achieved. However, despite the mentioned potential benefits, PG has not been used for cartilage regeneration approaches so far.
The initial aim of the study was to set up and optimize a HA-based hydrogel for the chondrogenic differentiation of mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs), using different amounts and variations of cross-linkers. Therefore, the hydrogel composition was optimized by the utilization of different PEG diacrylate (PEGDA) concentrations to cross-link thiol-modified HA (Glycosil, HA-SH) via Michael addition. We aimed to generate volumestable scaffolds that simultaneously enable a maximum of ECM deposition. Histological and biochemical analysis showed 0.4% PEGDA as the most suitable concentration for these requirements (Section 5.1.2).
In order to evaluate the impact of a differently designed cross-linker on MSC chondrogenesis, HA-SH was cross-linked with PEGTA (0.6%) and compared to PEGDA (0.4%) in a next step. Following this, acrylated PG (PG-Acr) as multifunctional cross-linker alternative to acrylated PEG was evaluated. It provides around five times more functional groups when utilized in PG-Acr (0.6%) HA-SH hydrogels compared to PEGTA (0.6%) HA-SH hydrogels, thus enabling higher degrees of biomimetic functionalization. Determination of cartilage-specific ECM components showed no substantial differences between both cross-linkers while the deposition of cartilaginous matrix appeared more homogeneous in HA-SH PG-Acr gels. Taken together, we were able to successfully increase the possibilities for biomimetic functionalization in the developed HA-SH hydrogel system by the introduction of PG-Acr as cross-linker without negatively affecting MSC chondrogenesis (Section 5.1.3).
The next part of this thesis focused extensively on the biomimetic functionalization of PG-Acr (0.6%) cross-linked HA-SH hydrogels. Here, either biomimetic peptides or a chondrogenic growth factor were covalently bound into the hydrogels.
Interestingly, the incorporation of a N-cadherin mimetic (HAV), a collagen type II binding (KLER), or a cell adhesion-mediating peptide (RGD) yielded no improvement of MSC chondrogenesis. For instance, the covalent binding of 2.5mM HAV changed morphology of cell nuclei and reduced GAG production while the incorporation of 1.0mM RGD impaired collagen production. These findings may be attributed to the already supportive conditions of the employed HA-based hydrogels for chondrogenic differentiation. Most of the previous studies reporting positive peptide effects on chondrogenesis have been carried out in less supportive PEG hydrogels or in significantly stiffer MeHA-based hydrogels [99, 101, 160]. Thus, the incorporation of peptides may be more important under unfavorable conditions while inert gel systems may be useful for studying single peptide effects (Section 5.2.1).
The chondrogenic factor transforming growth factor beta 1 (TGF-b1) served as an example for growth factor binding to PG-Acr. The utilization of covalently bound TGF-b1 may thereby help overcome the need for repeated administration of TGF-b1 in in vivo applications, which may be an advantage for potential clinical application. Thus, the effect of covalently incorporated TGF-b1 was compared to the effect of the same amount of TGF-b1 without covalent binding (100nM TGF-b1) on MSC chondrogenesis. It was successfully demonstrated that covalent incorporation of TGF-b1 had a significant positive effect in a dose-dependent manner. Chondrogenesis of MSCs in hydrogels with covalently bound TGF-b1 showed enhanced levels of chondrogenesis compared to hydrogels into which TGF-b1 was merely mixed, as shown by stronger staining for GAGs, total collagen, aggrecan and collagen type II. Biochemical evaluation of GAG and collagen amounts, as well as Western blot analysis confirmed the histological results. Furthermore, the positive effect of covalently bound TGF-b1 was shown by increased expression of chondrogenic marker genes COL2A1, ACAN and SOX9. In summary, covalent growth factor incorporation utilizing PG-Acr as cross-linker demonstrated significant positive effects on chondrogenic differentiation of MSCs (Section 5.2.2).
In general, PG-Acr cross-linked HA hydrogels generated by Michael addition represent a versatile hydrogel platform due to their high degree of acrylate functionality. These hydrogels may further offer the opportunity to combine several biological modifications, such as the incorporation of biomimetic peptides together with growth factors, within one cell carrier.
A proof-of-principle experiment demonstrated the suitability of pure PG gels for studying single peptide effects. Here, the hydrogels were generated by the utilization of thiol-ene-click reaction. In this setting, without the supportive background of hyaluronic acid, MSCs showed enhanced chondrogenic differentiation in response to the incorporation of 1.0mM HAV. This was demonstrated by staining for GAGs, the cartilage-specific ECM molecules aggrecan and type II collagen, and by increased GAG and total collagen amounts shown by biochemical analysis. Thus, pure PG gels exhibit the potential to study the effects and interplay of peptides and growth factors in a highly modifiable, bioinert hydrogel environment.
The last section of the thesis was carried out as part of the EU project HydroZONES that aims to develop and generate zonal constructs. The importance of zonal organization has attracted increased attention in the last years [127, 128], however, it is still underrepresented in tissue engineering approaches so far. Thus, the feasibility of zonal distribution of cells in a scaffold combining two differently composed hydrogels was investigated. A HA-SH(FMZ) containing bottom layer was generated and a pure PG top layer was subsequently cast on top of it, utilizing both times thiol-ene-click reaction. Indeed, stable, hierarchical constructs were generated that allowed encapsulated MSCs to differentiate chondrogenically in both zones as shown by staining for GAGs and collagen type II, and by quantification of GAG amount. Thus, the feasibility of differently composed zonal hydrogels utilizing PG as a main component was successfully demonstrated (Section 5.4).
With the first-time utilization and evaluation of PG-Acr as versatile multifunctional cross-linker for the preparation of Michael addition-generated HA-SH hydrogels in the context of cartilage tissue engineering, a highly modifiable HA-based hydrogel system was introduced. It may be used in future studies as an easily applicable and versatile toolbox for the generation of biomimetically functionalized hydrogels for cell-based cartilage regeneration. The introduction of reinforcement structures to enhance mechanical resistance may thereby further increase the potential of this system for clinical applications.
Additionally, it was also demonstrated that thiol-ene clickable hydrogels can be used for the generation of cell-laden, pure PG gels or for the generation of more complex, coherent zonal constructs. Furthermore, thiol-ene clickable PG hydrogels have already been further modified and successfully been used in 3D bioprinting experiments [204]. 3D bioprinting, as part of the evolving biofabrication field [205], offers the possibilities to generate complex and hierarchical structures, and to exactly position defined layers, yet at the same time alters the requirements for the utilized hydrogels [159, 206–209]. Since a robust chondrogenesis of MSCs was demonstrated in the thiol-ene clickable hydrogel systems, they may serve as a basis for the development of hydrogels as so called bioinks which may be utilized in more sophisticated biofabrication processes.