Refine
Has Fulltext
- yes (6)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (6)
Year of publication
- 2012 (6) (remove)
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (6) (remove)
Language
- English (6) (remove)
Keywords
- Optische Spektroskopie (2)
- Angeregter Zustand (1)
- Basin-Hopping (1)
- CC2 (1)
- Coherent 2D Spectroscopy (1)
- Computational chemistry (1)
- Dimermethode (1)
- Dissipatives System (1)
- Energielandschaft (1)
- Exziton (1)
Institute
- Institut für Physikalische und Theoretische Chemie (6) (remove)
In this thesis, the influence of an environment on molecules and, in particular, on the quantum control of such systems is investigated. Different approaches to describe system-bath dynamics are implemented and applied. The inclusion of a dissipation term in the system Hamiltonian leads to energy loss and relaxation to the ground state. As a first application, the isomerisation reaction in an aromatic complex is treated. It is shown that this simple model is able to reproduce results of time-resolved spectroscopic measurements. Next, the influence of noise is investigated. The incorporation of fluctuations reveals that energy is not conserved and coherences are destroyed. As an example, the quantum control of a population transfer in Na2 is examined. The efficiency of control processes is studied in dependence on the strength of the noise and different system-bath couplings. Starting with the unperturbed system, Local Control Theory is applied to construct a field which selectively transfers population into a single excited electronic state. The coupling to the bath is then switched on to monitor the dependence of the coupling strength on the transfer efficiency. The perturbation of the bath effects the Na2 molecule in such a way that potential energy curves and transition dipole moments are distorted. An important result is that already elastic collisions lead to a substantial loss of control efficiency. The most promising approach used in this thesis is the stochastic Schrödinger equation. It is equivalent to the commonly employed descriptions of system-bath dynamics within the reduced density matrix formalism. It includes decoherences and dissipation caused by elastic and inelastic collisions. Our contribution is the incorporation of laser excitation into the kinetic Monte-Carlo scheme. Thus we are able to apply this stochastic approach to the quantum control of population transfer in the sodium dimer. Because within our description it is possible to separate pure dephasing, inelastic transitions, and coherent time-evolution, we can identify the relative influence of these processes on the control efficiency. This leads to a far more physical picture of the basic processes underlying the perturbations of an environment then what a reduced density matrix description can provide. In utilising the stochastic wave function approach instead of the density matrix formalism, the computations are quite efficient. The stochastic Schrödinger equation is realised by N independent runs, where, in our case, an ensemble size of N = 1000 gives converged results. The efficiency of the laser control process is studied as a function of temperature and collision rates. A rise in temperature (or collision rate) reeffects a stronger fluctuation and thus results in a less efficient transfer by the control field. Though the Gaussian fluctuations used here do not strictly represent 'white'- noise, since a deterministic machine is not able to produce uncorrelated random numbers, an acceptable distribution is achieved by simple procedures. An improvement of the here applied algorithms would, for instance, include a more sophisticated sampling of the dephasing rates. Only one example of a control process is studied here and an application of the developed approach to other problems of quantum control is to be performed. This thesis established a systematic approach to understand quantum control in the presence of an environment.
In the context of this dissertation very long ranged exciton diffusion lengths (LD) were simulated for perylene-based materials under ideal conditions. This leads to the conclusion that the short LD values in existing materials result from an extrinsic and intrinsic immobilization. The latter, which is a specific material property, is based on a relaxation of the exciton into self-trapping states. An in-depth understanding of the atomistic processes defining self-trapping is essential to developing materials with long LD in the future, in which intrinsic immobilization is prevented. For the development of such a mechanistic understanding it is crucial that a clear relationship between molecular structure and LD is available. This is given by single crystals of diindeno perylene (DIP) and α-perylene tetracarboxylic anhydride (α-PTCDA). An extraordinary large LD of 90 nm was measured for the first one, while the latter possesses only 22 nm. Part of this thesis was to deliver reasons for this discrepancy. Only self-trapping comes into question to explain the different LD values. One reason for the different self-trapping in DIP and α-PTCDA could lie in the electronic structure. However, it was possible to demonstrate that a wide range of perylene-based materials possess no significant differences in their electronic structures. Consequently, such differences can be neglected for the explanation of immobilization mechanisms for the exciton. A further possible explanation could be polarization effects in the crystal, which influences the electronic structure of perylene based materials differently. Especially their influence on charge transfer (CT) states, which are located above the optically bright Frenkel state, was in question because such states could be stabilized by a polarizable surrounding. A significant influence of polarization effects on all considered states were excluded by using a polarizable continuum model. Hence, the small LD values in α-PTCDA are an evidence for self-trapping, which produces a crystal structure built up by π-stacks, while the one of DIP is of herringbone type. Since polarization effects can be neglected, is the dimer only via steric restrictions influenced by the crystal. Hence, a method describing self-trapping has to consider such effects, so that a mechanical embedding QM/MM approach is sufficient. Now, potential energy surfaces were calculated, on which wave packet dynamics were subsequently performed. In this way, atomistic mechanisms for the immobilization of excitons were described for the first time in organic materials. Self-trapping was studied in crystals of α-PTCDA by potential energy surfaces, which map an intermolecular shift motion of the dimer in the crystal. An immobilization of excitons occurs within 500 fs, which results from an irreversible energy loss together with a local deformation of the crystal lattice. This prevents a further transport of the exciton. In the case of DIP, this immobilization does not proceed due to high barriers. These barriers result from the herringbone type packing motif in the DIP crystal. This discrepancy in the dynamics explains the different LD values in DIP and α-PTCDA. In a further example, an exciton immobilization was found in helical π-aggregates of perylene tetracarboxylic bisimide (PBI) molecules. Self-trapping is caused by a relaxation mechanism, in which the exciton is transferred by asymmetric vibrations of the aggregate from the bright to a dark Frenkel state within 200 fs, whereby the transition is mediated by a CT state. However, the CT state is almost non-populated during the whole mechanism so that its participation could not yet be proven experimentally. This entire procedure is solely possible in helical aggregates, because only for such structures is there a CT state located next to the bright Frenkel state. At the final Frenkel state a torsional motion around the π-stacking axis is possible so that the loss in energy and the local rearrangement of the aggregate structure occurs, which means a self-trapping of the exciton. This mechanism is in perfect agreement with all available experimental data. These insights allow the conclusion that in future materials for organic solar cells an irreversible and ultrafast deformation of aggregates after photo-absorption must be avoided. Only in this way long LD values can be achieved and exciton self-trapping can be prevented. However, small LD values are always predicted in helical aggregates of perylene-based materials, because exciton immobilization occurs already due to small molecular motions. For this reason such aggregates are inappropriate for the use in organic solar cells. Long LD values are expected for aggregate structures with long intermolecular shifts or molecules with bulky substituents.
The visualization of energy functions is based on the possibility of separating different degrees of freedom. The most important one is the Born-Oppenheimer-approximation, which separates nucleus and electron movements. This allows the illustration of the potential energy as a function of the nuclei coordinates. Minima of the surface correspond to stable points like isomers or conformers. They are important for predicting the stability or thermodynamical of a system. Stationary points of first order correspond to transition points. They describe phase transitions, chemical reaction, or conformational changes. Furthermore, the partition function connects the potential hypersurface to the free energy of the system. The aim of the present work is the development and application of new approaches for the efficient exploration of multidimensional hypersurfaces. Initially, the Conformational Analysis and Search Tool (CAST) program was developed to create a basis for the new methods and algorithms. The development of CAST in object oriented C++ included, among other things, the implementation of a force field, different interfaces to external programs, analysis tools, and optimization libraries. Descriptions of an energy landscape require knowledge about the most stable minima. The Gradient Only Tabu Search (GOTS) has been shown to be very efficient in the optimization of mathematical test functions. Therefore, GOTS was taken as a starting point. Tabu-Search is based on the steepest descent - modest ascent strategy. The steepest descent is used for finding local minima, while the modest ascent is taken for leaving a minimum quickly. Furthermore, Tabu-Search is combined with an adaptive memory design to avoid cycling or returning. The highly accurate exploration of the phase space by Tabu-Search is often too expensive for complex optimization problems. Therefore, an algorithm for diversification of the search is required. After exploration of the proximity of the search space, the algorithm would guide the search to new and hopefully promising parts of the phase space. First application of GOTS to conformational search revealed weaknesses in the diversification search and the modest ascent part. On the one hand, the original methodology for diversification is insufficiently diverse. The algorithm is considerably improved by combining the more local GOTS with the wider searching Basin Hopping (BH) approach. The second weak point is a too inaccurate and inefficient modest ascent strategy. Analysis of common transition state search algorithms lead to the adaption of the Dimer-method to the Tabu-Search approach. The Dimer-method only requires the first derivatives for locating the closest transition state. For conformational search, dihedral angles are usually the most flexible degrees of freedom. Therefore, only those are used in the Dimer-method for leaving a local minimum. Furthermore, the exact localization of the reaction pathway and the transition state is not necessary as the local minimum position should only be departed as fast as possible. This allows for larger step sizes during the Dimer-search. In the following optimization step, all coordinates are relaxed to remove possible strains in the system. The new Tabu-Search method with Dimer-search delivers more and improved minima. Furthermore, the approach is faster for larger systems. For a system with approximately 1200 atoms, an acceleration of 40 was measured. The new approach was compared to Molecular Dynamics with optimization (MD), Simulated Annealing (SA), and BH with the help of conformational search problems of bio-organic systems. In all cases, a better performance was found. A comparison to the Monte Carlo Multiple Minima/Low Mode Sampling (MCMM/LM) method proved the outstanding performance of the new Tabu-Search approach. The solvation of the chignolin protein further revealed the possibility of uncovering discrepancies between the employed theoretical model and the experimental starting structure. Ligand optimization for improvement of x-ray structures was one further new application field. Besides the global optimization, the search for transition states and reaction pathways is also of paramount importance. These points describe different transitions of stable states. Therefore, a new approach for the exploration of such cases was developed. The new approach is based on a global minimization of a hyperplane being perpendicular to the reaction coordinate. Minima of this reduced phase space belong to traces of transition states between reactant and product states on the unchanged hypersurface. Optimization to the closest transition state using the Dimer-method delivers paths lying between the initial and the final state. An iterative approach finally yields complex reaction pathways with many intermediate local minima. The PathOpt algorithm was tested by means of rearrangements of argon clusters showing very promising results.
Time-resolved spectroscopic studies of energy transfer between molecules in solution form a basis for both, our understanding of fundamental natural processes like photosynthesis as well as directed synthetic approaches to optimize organic opto-electronic devices. Here, coherent two-dimensional (2D) spectroscopy opens up new possibilities, as it reveals the correlation between absorption and emission frequency and hence the full cause-and-effect chain. In this thesis two optical setups were developed and implemented, permitting the recording of electronic 2D spectra in the visible and in the hitherto unexplored ultraviolet spectral range. Both designs rely on the exclusive manipulation of beam pairs, which reduces the signal modulation to the difference between the transition frequency of the system and the laser frequency. Thus - as has been shown experimentally and theoretically - the timing precision as well as mechanical stability requirements are greatly reduced, from fractions of the oscillation period of the exciting light wave to fractions of the pulse duration. Two-dimensional spectroscopy and femtosecond transient absorption (TA) as well as different theoretical approaches and simulation models were then applied to coupled multichromophore systems of increasing complexity. Perylene bisimide-perylene monoimide dyads were investigated in cooperation with Prof. Dr. Frank Würthner and Prof. Dr. Bernd Engels at the University of Würzburg. In these simplest systems studied, global analysis of six different TA experiments unequivocally revealed an ultrafast interchromophoric energy transfer in the 100 fs range. Comparison between the obtained transfer rates and the predictions of Förster theory suggest a breakdown of this point-transition-dipole-based picture at the donor-acceptor distances realized in our compounds. Furthermore, a model including conformational changes and an interchromophoric charge transfer has been derived to consistently describe the observed pico- to nanosecond dynamics and fluorescence quantum yields. A second collaboration with Prof. Dr. Gregory Scholes (University of Toronto, Canada) and Prof. Dr. Paul Burn (University of Queensland, Australia) addressed the photophysics of a series of uorene-carbazole dendrimers. Here, a combination of 2D-UV spectroscopy and femtosecond ansiotropy decay experiments revealed the initial delocalization of the excited state wave function that saturates with the second generation. In room temperature solution, disorder-induced localization takes place on the time scales comparable to our instrument response, i.e. 100 fs, followed by energy transfer via incoherent hopping processes. Lastly, in tubular zinc chlorin aggregates, semi-synthetic analogues of natural lightharvesting antennae that had again been synthesized in the group of Prof. Dr. Frank Würthner, the interchromophoric coupling is so strong that coherently coupled domains prevail even at room temperature. From an analysis of intensity-dependent TA measurements the dimensions of these domains, the exciton delocalization length, could be determined to span 5-20 monomers. In addition, 2D spectra uncovered efficient energy transfer between neighboring domains, i.e. ultrafast exciton diffusion.
Time-resolved optical spectroscopy has become an important tool to investigate the dynamics of quantum mechanical processes in matter. In typical applications, a first “pump” pulse excites the system under investigation from the thermal equilibrium to an excited state, and a second variable time-delayed “probe” pulse then maps the dynamics of the excited system. Although advanced nonlinear techniques have been developed to investigate, e.g., coherent quantum effects, all of these techniques are limited in their spatial resolution. The laser focus diameter has a lower bound given by Abbe’s diffraction limit, which is roughly half the optical excitation wavelength—corresponding to about 400nm in the presented experiments. In the time-resolved experiments that have been suggested so far, averaging over the sample volume within this focus cannot be avoided. In this thesis, two approaches were developed to overcome the diffraction limit in optical spectroscopy and to enable the investigation of coherent processes on the nanoscale. In the first approach, analytic solutions were found to calculate optimal polarizationshaped laser pulses that provide optical near-field pump–probe pulse sequences in the vicinity of a nanostructure. These near-field pulse sequences were designed to allow excitation of a quantum system at one specific position at a certain time and probing at a different position at a later time. In the second approach, the concept of coherent two-dimensional (2D) spectroscopy, which has had great impact on the investigation of coherent quantum effects in recent years, was combined with photoemission electron microscopy, which yields a spatial resolution well below the optical diffraction limit. Using the analytic solutions, optical near fields were investigated in terms of spectroscopic applications. Near fields that are excited with polarization-shaped femtosecond laser pulses in the vicinity of appropriate nanostructures feature two properties that are especially interesting in the view of spectroscopic applications: On the one hand, control of the spatial distribution of the optical fields is achieved on the order of nanometers. On the other hand, the temporal evolution of these fields can be adjusted on the order of femtoseconds. In this thesis, solutions were found to calculate the optimal polarizationshaped laser pulses that control the near field in a general manner. The main idea to achieve this deterministic control was to disentangle the spatial and temporal near-field control. First, the spatial distribution of the optical near field was controlled by assigning the correct state of polarization for each frequency within the polarization-shaped laser pulse independently. The remaining total phase—not employed for spatial control—was then used for temporal near-field compression, which, in experimental applications, would lead to an enhancement of the nonlinear signal at the respective location. In contrast to the use of optical near fields, where pump–probe sequences themselves are localized below the diffraction limit and the detection does not have to provide the spatial resolution, a different approach was suggested in this thesis to gain spectroscopic information on the nanoscale. The new method was termed “Coherent two-dimensional (2D) nanoscopy” and transfers the concept of “conventional” coherent 2D spectroscopy to photoemission electron microscopy. The pulse sequences used for the investigation of quantum systems in this method are still limited by diffraction. However, the new key concept is to detect locally generated photoelectrons instead of optical signals. This yields a spatial resolution that is well below the optical diffraction limit. In “conventional” 2D spectroscopy a triple-pulse sequence initiates a four wave mixing process that creates a coherence. In a quantum mechanical process, this coherence is converted into a population by emission of an electric field, which is measured in the experiment. Contrarily, in the developed 2D nanoscopy, four-wave mixing is initiated by a quadruple-pulse sequence, which leaves the quantum system in an electronic population. This electronic population carries coherent information about the investigated quantum system and can be mapped with a spatial resolution down to a few nanometers given by the spatial resolution of the photoemission electron microscope. Hence, 2D nanoscopy can be considered a generalization of time-resolved photoemission experiments. In the future, it may be of similar beneficial value for the field of photoemission research as “conventional” 2D spectroscopy has proven to be for optical spectroscopy and nuclear magnetic resonance experiments. In a first experimental implementation of coherent 2D nanoscopy coherent processes on a corrugated silver surface were measured and unexpected long coherence lifetimes could be determined.