Refine
Has Fulltext
- yes (3)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (3)
Document Type
- Journal article (2)
- Doctoral Thesis (1)
Language
- English (3)
Keywords
- Hyaliner Knorpel (1)
- MSC (1)
- Test system (1)
- cartilage defectex vivo model (1)
- cartilage regeneration (1)
- cartilage repair (1)
- cartilage test system (1)
- chondrocytes (1)
- collagen type I hydrogel (1)
- critical size defect (1)
- ex vivo model (1)
- hyaline cartilage (1)
- osteochondral biopsy (1)
- replacement (1)
Institute
EU-Project number / Contract (GA) number
- 309962 (2)
Objective
Cartilage defect treatment strategies are dependent on the lesion size and severity. Osteochondral explant models are a platform to test cartilage repair strategies ex vivo. Current models lack in mimicking the variety of clinically relevant defect scenarios. In this controlled laboratory study, an automated device (artificial tissue cutter, ARTcut®) was implemented to reproducibly create cartilage defects with controlled depth. In a pilot study, the effect of cartilage defect depth and oxygen tension on cartilage repair was investigated.
Design
Osteochondral explants were isolated from porcine condyles. 4 mm chondral and full thickness defects were treated with either porcine chondrocytes (CHON) or co-culture of 20% CHON and 80% MSCs (MIX) embedded in collagen hydrogel. Explants were cultured with tissue specific media (without TGF-β) under normoxia (20% O\(_2\)) and physiological hypoxia (2% O\(_2\)). After 28 days, immune-histological stainings (collagen II and X, aggrecan) were scored (modified Bern score, 3 independent scorer) to quantitatively compare treatment outcome.
Results
ARTcut® represents a software-controlled device for creation of uniform cartilage defects. Comparing the scoring results of the MIX and the CHON treatment, a positive relation between oxygen tension and defect depth was observed. Low oxygen tension stimulated cartilaginous matrix deposition in MIX group in chondral defects and CHON treatment in full thickness defects.
Conclusion
ARTcut® has proved a powerful tool to create cartilage defects and thus opens a wide range of novel applications of the osteochondral model, including the relation between oxygen tension and defect depth on cartilage repair.
There is a great need for valuable ex vivo models that allow for assessment of cartilage repair strategies to reduce the high number of animal experiments. In this paper we present three studies with our novel ex vivo osteochondral culture platform. It consists of two separated media compartments for cartilage and bone, which better represents the in vivo situation and enables supply of factors pecific to the different needs of bone and cartilage. We investigated whether separation of the cartilage and bone compartments and/or culture media results in the maintenance of viability, structural and functional properties of cartilage tissue. Next, we valuated for how long we can preserve cartilage matrix stability of osteochondral explants during long-term culture over 84 days. Finally, we determined the optimal defect size that does not show spontaneous self-healing in this culture system. It was demonstrated that separated compartments for cartilage and bone in combination with tissue-specific medium allow for long-term culture of osteochondral explants while maintaining cartilage viability, atrix tissue content, structure and mechanical properties for at least 56 days. Furthermore, we could create critical size cartilage defects of different sizes in the model. The osteochondral model represents a valuable preclinical ex vivo tool for studying clinically relevant cartilage therapies, such as cartilage biomaterials, for their regenerative potential, for evaluation of drug and cell therapies, or to study mechanisms of cartilage regeneration. It will undoubtedly reduce the number of animals needed for in vivotesting.
The limited intrinsic self-healing capability of articular cartilage requires treatment of
cartilage defects. Material assisted and cell based therapies are in clinical practice but
tend to result in formation of mechanical inferior fibro-cartilage in long term follow up. If
a lesion has not been properly restored degenerative diseases are diagnosed as late sequela
causing pain and loss in morbidity. Complex three dimensional tissue models mimicking
physiological situation allow investigation of cartilage metabolism and mechanisms involved
in repair. A standardized and reproducible model cultured under controllable conditions
ex vivo to maintain tissue properties is of relevance for comparable studies.
Topic of this thesis was the establishment of an cartilage defect model that allows for
testing novel biomaterials and investigate the effect of defined defect depths on formation
of repair tissue.
In part I an ex vivo osteochondral defect model was established based on isolation of
porcine osteochondral explants (OCE) from medial condyles, 8 mm in diameter and 5 mm
in height. Full thickness cartilage defects with 1 mm to 4 mm in diameter were created
to define ex vivo cartilage critical size after 28 days culture with custom developed static
culture device. In part II of this thesis hydrogel materials, namely collagen I isolated from
rat tail, commercially available fibrin glue, matrix-metalloproteinase clevable poly(ethylene
glycol) polymerized with heparin (starPEGh), methacrylated poly(N-(2-hydroxypropyl)
methacrylamide mono-dilactate-poly(ethylene glycol) triblock copolymer/methacrylated
hyaluronic acid (MP/HA), thiol functionalized HA/allyl functionalized poly(glycidol)
(P(AGE/G)-HA-SH), were tested cell free and chondrocyte loaded (20 mio/ml) as implant
in 4 mm cartilage defects to investigate cartilage regeneration. Reproducible chondral
defects, 8 mm in diameter and 1 mm in height, were generated with an artificial tissue
cutter (ARTcut®) to investigate effect of defect depth on defect regeneration in part III.
In all approaches OCE were analyzed by Safranin-O staining to visualize proteoglycans
in cartilage and/or hydrogels. Immuno-histological and -fluorescent stainings (aggrecan,
collagen II, VI and X, proCollagen I, SOX9, RUNX2), gene expression analysis (aggrecan,
collagen II and X, SOX9, RUNX2) of chondrocyte loaded hydrogels (part II) and proteoglycan
and DNA content (Part I & II) were performed for detailed analysis of cartilage
regeneration.
Part I: The development of custom made static culture device, consisting of inserts in which OCE is fixed and deep well plate, allowed tissue specific media supply without
supplementation of TGF . Critical size diameter was defined to be 4 mm.
Part II: Biomaterials revealed differences in cartilage regeneration. Collagen I and fibrin
glue showed presence of cells migrated from OCE into cell free hydrogels with indication
of fibrous tissue formation by presence of proCollagen I. In chondrocyte loaded study
cartilage matrix proteins aggrecan, collagen II and VI and transcription factor SOX9 were
detected after ex vivo culture throughout the two natural hydrogels collagen I and fibrin
glue whereas markers were localized in pericellular matrix in starPEGh. Weak stainings resulted
for MP/HA and P(AGE/G)-HA-SH in some cell clusters. Gene expression data and
proteoglycan quantification supported histological findings with tendency of hypertrophy
indicated by upregulation of collagen X and RunX2 in MP/HA and P(AGE/G)-HA-SH.
Part III: In life-dead stainings recruitment of cells from OCE into empty or cell free
collagen I treated chondral defects was seen.
Separated and tissue specific media supply is critical to maintain ECM composition in
cartilage. Presence of OCE stimulates cartilage matrix synthesis in chondrocyte loaded
collagen I hydrogel and reduces hypertrophy compared to free swelling conditions and
pellet cultures. Differences in cartilage repair tissue formation resulted in preference of
natural derived polymers compared to synthetic based materials. The ex vivo cartilage
defect model represents a platform for testing novel hydrogels as cartilage materials, but
also to investigate the effect of cell seeding densities, cell gradients, cell co-cultures on
defect regeneration dependent on defect depth. The separated media compartments allow
for systematic analysis of pharmaceutics, media components or inflammatory cytokines on
bone and cartilage metabolism and matrix stability.