Refine
Has Fulltext
- yes (10)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (10)
Year of publication
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (9)
- Working Paper (1)
Keywords
- Geldpolitik (10) (remove)
Institute
The necessary adjustments to prominent measures of the neutral rate of interest following the COVID pandemic sparked a wide-ranging debate on the measurement and usefulness of r-star. Due to high uncertainty about relevant determinants, trend patterns and the correct estimation method, we propose in this paper a simple alternative approach derived from a standard macro model. Starting from a loss function, neutral periods can be determined in which a neutral real interest rate is observable. Using these values, a medium-term trend for a neutral interest rate can be determined. An application to the USA shows that our simple calculation of a neutral interest rate delivers comparable results to existing studies. A Taylor rule based on our neutral interest rate also does a fairly good job of explaining US monetary policy over the past 60 years.
Since the beginning, central banks have used a wide range of instruments to achieve their ultimate purpose of price stability. One measure in the authorities toolbox is a foreign exchange market intervention. The discussion about this instrument has come a long way. So far, the discussion relied mainly on industrialized countries' experiences. The negative outcomes of most studies with respect to the effectiveness of the intervention tool, opened up a discussion, whether interventions should be used by the authorities to manage exchange rate aspects. Consequently, the question about the dynamics of foreign exchange market interventions is now open to the subject-matter of developing and emerging market countries. Monetary policy in those countries often constitutes an active management of exchange rates. However, the basic discussions about intervention dynamics have had one essential drawback. Neither the primary literature of industrialized countries nor studies dealing with developing countries have considered the fact that intervention purposes and the corresponding effects are likely to vary over time. This thesis is designed to provide the reader with essential issues of central bank interventions, and aims to give further, as well as new contributions, in terms of empirical research on interventions in emerging markets. The main objectives of this study are the analysis of central bank intervention motives, and the corresponding effects on exchange rates in emerging markets. The time dependency of both issues is explicitly considered, which states a novelty in academic research of central bank interventions. Additionally, the outcomes are discussed against the background of underlying economic and monetary policy fundamentals. This could well serve as a starting point for further research.
This dissertation provides both empirically and theoretically new insights into the economic effects of housing and housing finance within NK DSGE models. Chapter 1 studies the drivers of the recent housing cycle in Ireland by developing and estimating a two-country NK DSGE model of the European Economic and Monetary Union (EMU). It finds that housing preference (demand) and technology shocks are the most important drivers of real house prices and real residential investment. In particular, housing preference shocks account for about 87% of the variation in real house prices and explain about 60% of the variation in real residential investment. A robustness analysis finally shows that a good part of the variation of the estimated housing preference shocks can be explained by unmodeled demand factors that have been considered in the empirical literature as important determinants of Irish house prices. Chapter 2 deals with the implications of cross-country mortgage market heterogeneity for the EMU. The chapter shows that a change in cross-country institutional characteristics of mortgage markets, such as the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio, is likely to be an important driver of an asymmetric development in the housing market and real economic activity of member states. Chapter 3 asks whether monetary policy shocks can trigger boom-bust periods in house prices and create persistent business cycles. The chapter addresses this question by implementing behavioral expectations into an otherwise standard NK DSGE model with housing and a collateral constraint. Key to the approach in chapter 3 is that agents form heterogeneous and biased expectations on future real house prices. Model simulations and impulse response functions suggest that these assumptions have strong implications for the transmission of monetary policy shocks. It is shown that monetary policy shocks might trigger pronounced waves of optimism, respectively, pessimism that drive house prices and the broader economy, all in a self-reinforcing fashion. The chapter shows that in an environment in which behavioral mechanisms play a role an augmented Taylor rule that incorporates house prices is superior, because it limits the scope of self-fulfilling waves of optimism and pessimism to arise. Chapter 4 challenges the view that the observed negative correlation between the Federal Funds rate and the interest rate implied by consumption Euler equations is systematically linked to monetary policy. Using a Monte Carlo experiment based on an estimated NK DSGE model, this chapter shows that risk premium shocks have the capability to drive a wedge between the interest rate targeted by the central bank and the implied Euler equation interest rate, so that the correlation between actual and implied rates is negative. Chapter 4 concludes by arguing that the implementation of collateral constraints tied to housing values is a promising way to strengthen the empirical performance of consumption Euler equations.
China’s monetary policy aims to reach two final targets: a paramount economical target (i.e. price stability) and a less important political target (i.e. economic growth). The main actor of monetary policy is the central bank, the People’s Bank of China (PBC). But the PBC is a non-independent central bank. The State Council approves the goals of monetary policy. Very limited instrument independence means that interest rates cannot be set at the PBC’s discretion, and in-sufficient personal independence fails to insulate central bank officials from political influence. Monetary policy in China applies to two sets of monetary policy instruments: (i) instruments of the PBC; and (ii) non-central bank policy instruments. The instruments of the PBC include price-based indirect and quantity-based direct instruments. Non-central bank policy instruments include price and wage controls. The simultaneous usage of all these instruments leads to various distortions that ultimately prevent the interest rate channel of monetary transmission from functioning. Moreover, the strong influences of quantity-based direct instruments and non-central bank policy instruments bring into question the approach of indirect monetary policy in general. The PBC officially follows the monetary targeting approach with monetary aggregates as intermediate targets. Domestic loan growth and the exchange rate are defined as additional intermediate targets. In an in-depth analysis of the intermediate targets two main issues are primarily explored: (i) Are the intermediate targets of the Chinese monetary policy controllable? (ii) Is a sufficient relationship between these targets and the inflation rate observable? It is then shown that monetary aggregates are very difficult to control, but they have a satisfactory relationship with the inflation rate. Similarly, domestic loan growth is difficult to control – a fact largely attributed to the interest rate elasticity of loans – while there is a particularly close relationship between credit growth and the inflation rate. The exchange rate as an intermediate target can be controlled through foreign exchange market interventions; at the same time the exchange rate appears to have a significant relationship to the domestic inflation rate. Discussing the special issue of sterilizing foreign exchange inflows, the study concludes that between 2002 and 2008 not only no costs were incurred by sterilization operations, but that the central bank was actually able to realize a profit through foreign exchange market interventions. Based on this, it is concluded that the exchange rate target has not adversely affected the domestic orientation of monetary policy on the whole. The final part of the study examines whether there are any alternative monetary policy approaches that may be able to describe the policy approach in China; special focus is placed on nominal GDP targeting, the Taylor rule, and inflation targeting. A literature review reveals that the concept of nominal GDP targeting may be able to detect inflationary tendencies in the economy and, in combination with other indicators, it could be a suitable concept to assess the overall economic situation. The author calculates a Taylor rule for China from 1994 to 2008 and concludes that there is no close relationship between the PBC lending and the Taylor rate. The author then designs an augmented Taylor rule expanded to include a credit component (credit-augmented Taylor rule). The study shows that the augmented Taylor rule does not perform much better than the original one, but that it maps high inflationary periods relatively well. This is attributed to direct interventions into the credit markets, which have played a major role in combating inflationary cycles over the past decades. The analysis ends with an introduction of the concept of inflation targeting and an examination of whether this could describe monetary policy in China. It is clear that the PBC does not currently follow the inflation targeting approach, although the Chinese authorities could actually be able to influence inflation expectations effectively, not least through direct instruments such as price controls. The author notes that the PBC indeed had a good track record of fighting inflation between 1994 and 2008, and that this may now indicate a good time to think about introducing inflation targeting in China. The central conclusion of the study is that the proven gradual approach to economic and monetary reforms in China is reaching its limit. To break the vicious cycle that relies on the continuous use of quantity-based instruments to compensate for the ineffective price-based instruments – which in turn arises from the simultaneous use of both types of instruments – a complete shift away from quantity-based instruments is needed. Only then the approach of indirect monetary policy, which was officially introduced in 1998, could come into full play.
Die Arbeit setzt sich mit Unterschieden des geldpolitischen Transmissionsprozesses im Verarbeitenden Gewerbe der Bundesrepublik Deutschland auseinander. Dazu wird der Sektor nach der Systematik der BACH-Datenbank der europäischen Kommission in 10 Branchen eingeteilt. An eine kurze Betrachtung der Industrie aus makro- und mikroökonomischer Sicht schließt sich die Beantwortung der ersten Frage an: Reagieren die Industriebranchen unterschiedlich auf geldpolitische Impulse? Monetäre Innovationen werden mit Anstiegen der kurzfristigen Geldmarktzinsen abgebildet. Damit konzentriert sich die Analyse auf die Auswirkungen von restriktiven Maßnahmen. Als Referenzgrößen wurden die Produktion und die Erzeugerpreise ausgewählt. Die Analyse der Auswirkungen auf die Produktionsentwicklung zeigt, dass ein Großteil der Industriezweige erwartungsgemäß mit Rückführungen auf Zinserhöhungen reagiert. Die stärksten Produktionseinbußen ergeben sich hierbei in der Branche Herstellung elektrischer Geräte, in der Grundlegenden Metallverarbeitung und im Industriezweig Metallerzeugnisse mit Maschinenbau. Dagegen sind die in vielen Branchen entdeckten kurzfristigen Preisanstiege auf den ersten Blick ein Rätsel. Denn die Notenbank verfolgt ihre Absicht – nämlich die Stabilisierung der Verbraucherpreise – mit einer restriktiven Ausrichtung, wenn die Preise Gefahr laufen, stärker als zielkonform anzusteigen. Die vorliegenden Ergebnisse sprechen daher dafür, dass in der kurzen Frist jedoch zusätzlicher Preisdruck auf vorgelagerter Stufe erzeugt wird. Wie können die unterschiedlichen Auswirkungen auf die Branchen erklärt werden? Dieser Frage widmet sich der zweite Hauptblock der Arbeit. In einem ersten Schritt werden die relevanten Transmissionstheorien diskutiert. Die empirische Überprüfung ausgewählter Transmissionstheorien mit Branchendaten hat dabei einige grundlegende Einsichten ans Licht gebracht. Erstens korreliert die Stärke der Outputveränderung deutlich mit der Zinssensitivität der Nachfrage nach den produzierten Gütern der Branche. Zweitens können die beobachteten Preisanstiege vereinzelt mit einer Dominanz der Geldpolitik als Angebotsschock erklärt werden. Zu einem großen Teil bleibt die identifizierte Preisreaktion aber ein Rätsel. Und drittens scheint der Bilanzkanal – zumindest gemäß der hier gewählten Identifikationsstrategie – nicht grundsätzlich geeignet zu sein, die Anpassungsprozesse in den untersuchten Branchen zu erklären. Dies sollte daran liegen, dass dieser Transmissionskanal Bonitätscharakteristika und -veränderungen auf Unternehmensebene als Vehikel der Übertragung sieht.
This dissertation focuses on the drivers of international capital flows to emerging markets, as well as the determinants of crises in emerging markets. Particular emphasis is devoted to the role of U.S. monetary policy. The dissertation consists of three independent chapters.
Chapter 1 is a survey of the voluminous empirical literature on the drivers of capital flows to emerging markets. The contribution of the survey is to provide a comprehensive assessment of what we can say with relative confidence about the empirical drivers of EM capital flows. The evidence is structured based on the recognition that the drivers of capital flows vary over time and across different types of capital flows. The drivers are classified using the traditional framework for external and domestic factors (often referred to as “push versus pull” drivers), which is augmented by a distinction between cyclical and structural factors. Push factors are found to matter most for portfolio flows, somewhat less for banking flows, and least for foreign direct investment (FDI). Pull factors matter for all three components, but most for banking flows. A historical perspective suggests that the recent literature may have overemphasized the importance of cyclical factors at the expense of longer-term structural trends.
Chapter 2 undertakes an empirical analysis of the drivers of portfolio flows to emerging markets, focusing on the role of Fed policy. A time series model is estimated to analyze two different concepts of high frequency portfolio flows, including monthly data on flows into investment funds and a novel dataset on monthly portfolio flows obtained from individual national sources. The evidence presented in this chapter suggests a more nuanced interpretation of the role of U.S. monetary policy. In the existing literature, it is traditionally argued that Fed policy tightening is unambiguously negative for capital flows to emerging markets. By contrast, the findings presented in this dissertation suggest that it is the surprise element of monetary policy that affects EM portfolio inflows. A shift in market expectations towards easier future U.S. monetary policy leads to greater foreign portfolio inflows and vice versa. Given current market expectations of sustained increases in the federal funds rate in coming years, EM portfolio flows could be boosted by a slower pace of Fed tightening than currently expected or could be reduced by a faster pace of Fed tightening.
Chapter 3 examines the role of U.S. monetary policy in determining the incidence of emerging market crises. A negative binomial count model and a panel logit model are estimated to analyze the determinants of currency crises, banking crises, and sovereign defaults in a group of 27 emerging economies. The estimation results suggest that the probability of crises is substantially higher (1) when the federal funds rate is above its natural level, (2) during Fed policy tightening cycles, and (3) when market participants are surprised by signals that the Fed will tighten policy faster than previously expected. These findings contrast with the existing literature, which generally views domestic factors as the dominant determinants of emerging market crises. The findings also point to a heightened risk of emerging market crises in the coming years if the Fed continues to tighten monetary policy.
The main subject of this dissertation is the analysis of the impact of the creation of the Eurozone on its member countries. This analysis comprises two studies that analyze this research agenda from different perspectives.
The first study compares the monetary policy of the ECB with the respective monetary policy of selected central banks of the European Monetary System (EMS). More precisely, conditional on aggregate demand and supply shocks, are there differences in the systematic central bank reaction function of the ECB and the four most important central banks of the EMS (Germany, France, Italy and Spain).
The second study analyzes the built-up of internal and external imbalances in Spain, i.e., on the housing market and in the current account, during the run-up to the financial crisis in 2007/08. The analysis differentiates between domestic Spain-specific factors and foreign Eurozone-factors that led to the macroeconomic imbalances.
The third and last study develops a price-theoretic credit supply model. In order to validate the model empirically, a credit market is estimated on the basis of data from the German credit market for enterprises. Finally, the results from the empirical exercise are compared to the predictions of the theoretic model.
Methodologically, all studies draw heavily on time series methods such as (multi-country) vector autoregressions (VARs) and time series regressions.
Die Arbeit beschäftigt sich mit den speziellen Herausforderungen der Geld- und Wechselkurspolitik in rohstoffreichen Ländern. Die Auseinandersetzung mit der Thematik erfolgt dabei anhand einer empirischen Analyse der Wirtschaftsentwicklung Russlands im Zeitraum zwischen 2000 bis 2009. Diese Periode wurde durch eine hohe Volatilität des Ölpreises gekennzeichnet, die die Wirtschaftsentwicklung Russlands erheblich beeinflusste.
Die aus dem Anstieg des Ölpreises resultierenden Rohstoffeinnahmen entfalteten einerseits positive wirtschaftliche Effekte. Der im Jahr 1998 für zahlungsunfähig erklärte Staat konnte sich wenige Jahre später eine expansive Haushaltspolitik leisten. Andererseits entstanden durch die Rohstoffeinnahmen auch negative wirtschaftliche Folgen. Infolge der starken realen Aufwertung des Rubels wurde die Wettbewerbsfähigkeit des Industriesektors deutlich belastet. Die Import- und Rohstoffabhängigkeit des Landes nahm deutlich zu.
Unter der hohen Volatilität der Rohstoffpreise hat die Finanz- und Wirtschaftsstabilität stark gelitten. Die durch die Ölpreisschwankungen verursachten Wechselkursturbulenzen wurden zusätzlich durch spekulative Kapitalbewegungen verstärkt. Die realen Geldmarktzinssätze verliefen überwiegend in einem negativen Bereich. Die Inflationsrate konnte zwar reduziert werden, die angekündigten Inflationsziele konnten aber nicht eingehalten werden. Die unkontrollierte Geldbasisbildung kam durch die Devisenmarktinterventionen der Notenbank und eine stark expansiven Fiskalpolitik zustande. Auf dem Geldmarkt herrschte ein Angebotsüberhang. Darüber hinaus nutzten die Kreditinstitute die Verschuldung im Ausland als eine zusätzliche Quelle für ihre boomenden Kreditgeschäfte.
Die Handlungsoptionen der Notenbank waren zusätzlich durch die rohstofffinanzierte expansive Fiskalpolitik eingeschränkt. Die Spielräume der Notenbank waren umso geringer, je höher der Ölpreis anstieg und je mehr der Staat die Rohstoffeinnahmen ausgab. Die Ölpreisentwicklung und die sich selbst verstärkenden Kapitalflüsse hatten entscheidenden Einfluss auf die Zinssätze und den Wechselkurs.
Nach Meinung des Verfassers werden alle rohstoffreichen offenen Länder mit hohen Inflationsraten mit einer ähnlichen Problematik konfrontiert. Der Trade-off heißt: Entweder Wechselkursaufwertung oder Inflationsimport. Wie ist dieses Problem zu lösen? Welche Alternativen hatte die Notenbank Russlands? Nach dem IWF wäre ein Free Floating die beste Strategie. Demnach hätte eine hohe Wechselkursvolatilität den Kapitalanleger trotz der hohen Renditemöglichkeiten abgeschreckt. Der Verlauf des Wechselkurses hätte seinen Fundamentalfaktoren entsprochen. Dabei gilt nach dem IWF der volatile Ölpreis ebenfalls als ein fundamentaler Bestandteil des Gleichgewichtes.
Der Verfasser widerspricht der Auffassung der IWF-Experten. Das Hauptproblem in diesem Ansatz ist die hohe mittelfristige Volatilität der Rohstoffpreise. Der Ölpreis entwickelte sich bis 2004 weitgehend stabil rund um die Marke von 30 USD/Barrel. Nach 2004 verzeichnete der Ölpreis im Laufe der 55 Monate (oder 4,5 Jahre) einen erkennbar ansteigenden Trend auf etwa 140 USD/Barrel und schrumpfte anschließend innerhalb von weiteren 6 Monaten auf 35 USD/Barrel zurück. So eine Entwicklung des Ölpreises hätte beim Free Floating verheerende Auswirkungen gehabt. Die Währung hätte parallel zu jedem Ölpreisanstieg aufgewertet. Der Kapitalzufluss hätte die Aufwertung zusätzlich verstärkt. Die Abwertung des Rubels im August 2008 infolge des Ölpreisverfalls und der massiven Kapitalflucht wäre so stark gewesen, dass dadurch die Finanz-, Preis- und Wirtschaftsstabilität stark gefährdet worden wären.
Zur Lösung des Trade-offs zwischen Wechselkurs- und Geldpolitik bietet sich nach Meinung des Verfassers das Managed-Floating-Modell an. Das Modell widerspricht der bekannten „Unmöglichkeit“ des klassischen „Dreiecks“. Eine autonome Zins- und Wechselkurssteuerung in einer offenen Volkswirtschaft ist nicht nur möglich, sondern in den Fällen wie Russland die einzig richtige Lösung. Die Ausgangsgröße ist in diesem Modell der autonom zu steuernde Zinssatz, der im Fall Russland von der Notenbank hätte angehoben werden müssen, um die Inflationsrate möglichst schnell abzusenken. In der Wechselkurssteuerung wird auf den mittelfristig stabilen realeffektiven Wechselkurs abgestellt. Da die Inflationsrate in Russland deutlich höher war als im Ausland, wäre eine gesteuerte Abwertung des Rubels erforderlich gewesen. Dadurch wäre die Wettbewerbsfähigkeit der Industrie gefördert worden. Durch die Abwertung des Rubels wäre der Zufluss des kurz- und mittelfristigen Auslandskapitals selbst bei hohen Renditemöglichkeiten in Russland abgewendet worden.
Eine wesentliche Gefahr für den Erfolg des Managed-Floating-Modells stellt aber eine stark expansive, rohstofffinanzierte Fiskalpolitik dar. Eine strenge Fiskaldisziplin spielt daher eine entscheidende Rolle.
This dissertation studies the interrelations between housing markets and monetary policy from three different perspectives. First, it identifies housing finance specific shocks and analyzes their impact on the broader economy and, most importantly, the systematic monetary policy reaction to such mortgage sector disturbances. Second, it investigates the implications of the institutional arrangement of a currency union for the potential buildup of a housing bubble in a member country of the monetary union by, inter alia, fostering border-crossing capital flows and ultimately residential investment activity. This dissertation, third, quantifies the effects of autonomous monetary policy shifts on the macroeconomy and, in particular, on housing markets by conditioning on financial sector conditions. From a methodological perspective, the dissertation draws on time-series econometrics like vector autoregressions (VARs) or local projections models.
Within three self-contained studies, this dissertation studies the impact and interactions between different macroeconomic policy measures in the context of financial markets empirically and quantitatively. The first study of this dissertation sheds light on the financial market effects of unconventional central bank asset purchase programs in the Eurozone, in particular sovereign bond asset purchase programs. The second study quantifies the direct implications of unconventional monetary policy on decisions by German public debt management regarding the maturity structure of gross issuance. The third study provides novel evidence on the role of private credit markets in the propagation of public spending toward private consumption in the U.S. economy. Across these three studies a set of different time-series econometric methods is applied including error correction models and event study frameworks to analyze contemporaneous interactions in financial and macroeconomic data in the context of unconventional monetary policy, as well as vector auto regressions (VARs) and local projections to trace the dynamic consequences of macroeconomic policies over time.