Refine
Has Fulltext
- yes (24)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (24)
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (24)
Keywords
- Vaccinia-Virus (24) (remove)
Institute
Sonstige beteiligte Institutionen
Biochemische und strukturelle Charakterisierung der Genexpressionsmaschinerie des Vaccinia Virus
(2018)
Die Familie der Pockenviren zeichnet sich durch ein komplexes DNA Genom aus und hat großes medizinisches Potential. Am eindrucksvollsten ist dies für das Vaccinia-Virus (VACV) belegt, welches nicht nur als Pocken-Impfstoff eingesetzt wird, sondern auch als onkolytisches Virus in der Tumorbiologie. VACV hat einen außergewöhnlichen Replikationszyklus, welcher ausschließlich im Zytoplasma der Wirtszelle stattfindet. Somit ist die gesamte virale Genexpressionsmaschinerie völlig unabhängig von kernvermittelten Reaktionen des Wirts und somit auch aus Sicht der Grundlagenforschung von größtem Interesse. Die Schlüsselkomponente der viralen Genexpression ist die makromolekulare DNA-abhängige RNA Polymerase (vvRPO), deren Untereinheiten allesamt Virus-kodiert sind. Zwar wurden in den letzten Jahren Protokolle zur biochemischen und funktionellen Charakterisierung der vvRPO etabliert, ein detailliertes Wissen über deren Zusammenlagerung in vivo und die räumlichen und zeitlichen Interaktionen mit den Transkriptions- bzw. Prozessierungsfaktoren sind aber weitgehend unbekannt.
Diese Arbeit umfasst Untersuchungen zur strukturellen und funktionellen Charakterisierung der vvRPO und seiner assoziierten Faktoren. Grundlage hierfür war die Etablierung eines Reinigungsprotokolls mithilfe eines neu konstruierten rekombinanten VACV (GLV-1h439). Diese Strategie erlaubte es hoch-molekulare native vvRPO Komplexe zu isolieren. Ein transkriptions-inaktiver Komplex (Komplex I) mit einer kalkulierten Masse von 575 kDa bestand aus den acht Untereinheiten des vvRPO Holoenzyms und den Polymerase-assoziierten Faktoren RAP94 und D6. Ein zweiter, transkriptionell aktiver Komplex (Komplex II) mit einer Masse von 803 kDa enthielt, neben dem Holoenzym der vvRPO, noch weitere Faktoren, die primär die Erkennung der DNA-Matrize und die Prozessierung der naszierenden RNA vermitteln. Hierbei handelt es sich um RAP94, das virale Capping Enzym bestehend aus den zwei Untereinheiten D1 und D12, A7 und dem Terminationsfaktor NPH I. Interessanterweise enthielt dieser Komplex zusätzlich mit E11 eine bislang unbekannte weitere Protein-Komponente, sowie tRNAGln und tRNAArg. Der isolierte Kompelx II ist daher ein Ribonukleoprotein (RNP).
Die Verfügbarkeit von hoch-reinen vvRPO Komplexen erlaubte es erstmals deren strukturelle Architektur zu untersuchen. Hierfür wurden drei experimentelle Ansätze, die klassische Röntgenstrukturanalyse, die Kryo-Elektronenmikroskopie (Kryo-EM) und Quervernetzungssstudien miteinander kombiniert. Die Strukturen der Komplexe I und II haben eine Auflösung von 11-12 Å, wobei auffällig war, dass beide eine markante strukturelle Ähnlichkeit zur eukaryotischen RNA Polymerase II aufwiesen. Darüber hinaus gelang es zusätzliche Bereiche im Komplex II zu definieren, welche die Polymerase-assoziierten Prozessierungsfaktoren beherbergen. Zudem konnte die atomare Struktur von E11, mittels Röntgenstrukturanalyse bei einer Auflösung von 1,9 Å, gelöst werden. Das E11 Protein besitzt ein neuartiges Faltungsmuster und weist einen intensiven Dimerisierungskontakt auf, welcher sich über vier ß-Faltblätter ausbildet.
Die im Rahmen dieser Arbeit erhaltenen Daten legen die Grundlage für ein detailliertes Verständnis der räumlichen Organisation der viralen Transkriptonsmaschinerie. Darüber hinaus werden sie funktionelle Studien ermöglichen, welche die Rolle der einzelnen Proteine, sowie der tRNAs bei der mRNA Synthese klären helfen.
Glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) is one of the most frequent and malignant forms of brain cancer in adults. The prognosis is poor with a median survival time of 12-15 months. There is a broad range of alternative treatment options studied in preclinical and clinical trials for GBM. One alternative treatment option is oncolytic virotherapy, defined as the use of replication‐competent viruses that selectively infect and destroy cancer cells while leaving, non‐transformed cells unharmed. Vaccinia virus (VACV) is one favorable candidate. Although oncolytic viruses can kill tumor cells grown in vitro with high efficiency, they often exhibit reduced replication capacity in vivo suggesting that physiological aspects of the tumor microenvironment decrease the virus’ therapeutic potential. The percentage and composition of immune cells varies between cancer types and patients and is investigated as a biomarker in several studies. Making oncolytic virotherapy successful for GBM, it is necessary to understand the individual tumor biology, the interaction with the microenvironment and immune system.
It was demonstrated that the attenuated VACV wild-type (wt) isolate LIVP 1.1.1 replicate and lyse the murine GL261 glioma cell line in vitro. In the following, the replication efficacy was characterized in a comparative approach in vivo. Immunocompetent C57BL/6 (wt) mice and immunodeficient mouse strains of different genetic background C57BL/6 athymic and Balb/c athymic mice were used. In addition, subcutaneous and intracranial locations were compared. The results revealed viral replication exclusively in Balb/c athymic mice with subcutaneous tumors but in none of the other models.
In the following, the tumor microenvironment of the subcutaneous tumor models at the time of infection was performed. The study showed that implantation of the same tumor cells in different mouse strains resulted in a different tumor microenvironment with a distinct composition of immune cells. Highest differences were detected between immunodeficient and immunocompetent mice. The study showed major differences in the expression of MHCII with strongest expression in C57BL/6 wt and weakest in Balb/c athymic tumors. In the following, the influence of the phenotypic change associated with the upregulation of MHCII on GL261 tumor cells on viral replication was analyzed. Comparison of C57BL/6 wt and C57BL/6 IFN-γ knockout mice revealed endogenous IFN-γ levels to upregulate MHCII on GL261 tumor cells and to reduce viral replication in C57BL/6 wt mice. Analysis of single cell suspensions of tumor homogenates of C57BL/6 and Balb/c athymic mice showed that the IFN-γ-mediated anti-tumor effect was a reversible effect. Furthermore, reasons for inhibition of virus replication in orthotopic glioma models were elucidated. By immunohistochemical analysis it was shown that intratumoral amounts of Iba1+ microglia and GFAP+ astrocytes in Gl261 gliomas was independent from intratumoral VACV injection. Based on these findings virus infection in glioma, microglia and astrocytes was compared and analyzed in cell culture. In contrast to the GL261 glioma cells, replication was barely detectable in BV-2 microglia and IMA2.1 astrocytic cells. Co-culture experiments revealed that microglia compete for virus uptake in cell culture. It was further shown that BV-2 cells showed apoptotic characteristics after VACV infection while GL261 cells showed signs of necrotic cell death. Additionally, in BV-2 cells with M1-phenotype a further reduction of viral replication and inhibition of cell lysis was detected. Infection of IMA 2.1 cells was independent of the M1/M2-phenotype. Application of BV-2 microglia with M1-phenotype onto organotypic slice cultures with implanted GL261 tumors resulted in reduced infection of BV-2 cells with LIVP 1.1.1, whereas GL261 cells were significantly infected.
Taken together, the analyzed GL261 tumors were imprinted by the immunologic and genetic background in which they grow. The experimental approach applied in this thesis can be used as suitable model which reflects the principles of personalized medicine
In an additional project, based on gene expression data and bioinformatic analyses, the biological role and function of the anti-apoptotic factor AVEN was analyzed with regard to oncolytic VACV therapy. Besides a comparison of the replication efficacy of GLV-1h68 and VACV-mediated cell killing of four human tumor cell lines, it was shown that AVEN was expressed in all analyzed cells. Further, shown for HT-29 and 1936-MEL, the knockdown of AVEN by siRNA in cell culture resulted in an increase of apoptotic characteristics and a decrease of VACV infection. These findings provide essential insights for future virus development.
Cancer is one of the leading causes of death. 90% of all deaths are caused by the effects of metastases. It is of major importance to successfully treat the primary tumor and metastases. Tumors and metastases often differ in their properties and therefore, treatment is not always successful. In contrast, those therapeutic agents can even promote formation and growth of metastases. Hence, it is indispensable to find treatment options for metastatic disease. One promising candidate represents the oncolytic virus therapy with vaccinia viruses.
The aim of this work was to analyze two cell lines regarding their metastatic abilities and to investigate whether oncolytic vaccinia viruses are useful therapy options. The cell lines used were the human cervical cancer cell line C33A implanted into immune-compromised mice and the murine melanoma cell line B16F10, implanted into immune-competent mice.
The initial point of the investigations was the observation of enlarged lumbar und renal lymph nodes in C33A tumor-bearing mice 35 days post implantation of C33A cells subcutaneously into immune-compromised nude mice. Subsequently, the presence of human cells in enlarged lymph nodes was demonstrated by RT-PCR. To facilitate the monitoring of cancer cell spreading, the gene encoding for RFP was inserted into the genome of C33A cells. In cell culture experiments, it was possible to demonstrate that this insertion did not negatively affect the susceptibility of the cells to virus infection, replication and virus-mediated cell lysis. The analysis of the metastatic process in a xenografted mouse model revealed the continuous progression of lumbar (LN) and renal (RN) lymph node metastasis after C33A-RFP tumor cell implantation. The lymph node volume and the amount of RFP-positive LNs and RNs was increasing from week to week in accordance with the gain of the primary tumor volume. Moreover, the metastatic spread of cancer cells in lymph vessels between lumbar and renal lymph nodes was visualized. Additionally, the haematogenous way of cancer cell migration was demonstrated by RFP positive cancer cells in blood vessels. The haematogenous route of spreading was confirmed by detecting micrometastases in lungs of tumor bearing mice.
The next step was to investigate whether the recombinant oncolytic vaccinia virus GLV-1h68 is a suitable candidate to cure the primary tumor and metastases. Therefore, GLV-1h68 was systemically injected into C33A-RFP tumor bearing mice 21 days after tumor cell implantation. It was demonstrated that the volume of the primary tumor was drastically reduced, and the volume and the amount of RFP positive lumbar and renal lymph nodes were significantly decreasing compared to the untreated control group. Subsequently, this process was analyzed further by investigating the colonization pattern in the C33A-RFP model. It was shown that first the primary tumor was colonized with highest detectable virus levels, followed by LN and RN lymph nodes. Histological analyses revealed the proliferative status of tumor cells in the tumor and lymph nodes, the amount of different immune cell populations and the vascular permeability in primary tumors and lymph nodes having an influence on the colonization pattern of the virus. Whereby, the vascular permeability seems to have a crucial impact on the preferential colonization of tumors compared to lymph node metastases in this tumor model.
C33A turned out to be a useful model to study the formation and therapy of metastases. However, a metastatic model in which the influence of the immune system on tumors and especially on tumor therapy can be analyzed would be preferable. Therefore, the aim of the second part was to establish a syngeneic metastatic mouse model.
Accordingly, the murine melanoma cell line B16F10 was analyzed in immunocompetent mice. First, the highly attenuated GLV 1h68 virus was compared to its parental strain LIVP 1.1.1 concerning infection, replication and cell lysis efficacy in cell culture. LIVP 1.1.1 was more efficient than GLV-1h68 and was subsequently used for following mouse studies. Comparative studies were performed, comparing two different implantation sites of the tumor cells, subcutaneously and footpad, and two different mouse strains, FoxN1 nude and C57BL/6 mice. Implantation into the footpad led to a higher metastatic burden in lymph nodes compared to the subcutaneous implantation site. Finally, the model of choice was the implantation of B16F10 into the footpad of immune-competent C57BL/6 mice. Furthermore, it was inevitable to deliver the virus as efficient as possible to the tumor and metastases. Comparison of two different injection routes, intravenously and intratumorally, revealed, that the optimal injection route was intratumorally. In summary, the murine B16F10 model is a promising model to study the effects of the immune system on vaccinia virus mediated therapy of primary tumors and metastases.
Tumor-induced angiogenesis is of major interest for oncology research. Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) is the most potent angiogenic factor characterized so far. VEGF blockade was shown to be sufficient for angiogenesis inhibition and subsequent tumor regression in several preclinical tumor models. Bevacizumab was the first treatment targeting specifically tumor-induced angiogenesis through VEGF blockade to be approved by the Food and Drugs Administration (FDA) for cancer treatment. However, after very promising results in preclinical evaluations, VEGF blockade did not show the expected success in patients. Some tumors became resistant to VEGF blockade. Several factors have been accounted responsible, the over-expression of other angiogenic factors, the noxious influence of VEFG blockade on normal tissues, the selection of hypoxia resistant neoplastic cells, the recruitment of hematopoietic progenitor cells and finally the transient nature of angiogenesis inhibition by VEGF blockade. The development of blocking agents against other angiogenic factors like placental growth factor (PlGF) and Angiopoietin-2 (Ang-2) allows the development of an anti-angiogenesis strategy adapted to the profile of the tumor.
Oncolytic virotherapy uses the natural propensity of viruses to colonize tumors to treat cancer. The recombinant vaccinia virus GLV-1h68 was shown to infect, colonize and lyse several tumor types. Its descendant GLV-1h108, expressing an anti-VEGF antibody, was proved in previous studies to inhibit efficiently tumor induced angiogenesis. Additional VACVs expressing single chain antibodies (scAb) antibodies against PlGF and Ang-2 alone or in combination with anti VEGF scAb were designed.
In this study, VACV-mediated anti-angiogenesis treatments have been evaluated in several preclinical tumor models. The efficiency of PlGF blockade, alone or in combination with VEGF, mediated by VACV has been established and confirmed. PlGF inhibition alone or with VEGF reduced tumor burden 5- and 2-folds more efficiently than the control virus, respectively.
Ang-2 blockade efficiency for cancer treatment gave controversial results when tested in different laboratories. Here we demonstrated that unlike VEGF, the success of Ang-2 blockade is not only correlated to the strength of the blockade. A particular balance between Ang-2, VEGF and Ang-1 needs to be induced by the treatment to see a regression of the tumor and an improved survival. We saw that Ang-2 inhibition delayed tumor growth up to 3-folds compared to the control virus. These same viruses induced statistically significant tumor growth delays. This study unveiled the need to establish an angiogenic profile of the tumor to be treated as well as the necessity to better understand the synergic effects of VEGF and Ang-2. In addition angiogenesis inhibition by VACV-mediated PlGF and Ang-2 blockade was able to reduce the number of metastases and migrating tumor cells (even more efficiently than VEGF blockade).
VACV colonization of tumor cells, in vitro, was limited by VEGF, when the use of the anti-VEGF VACV GLV-1h108 drastically improved the colonization efficiency up to 2-fold, 72 hours post-infection. These in vitro data were confirmed by in vivo analysis of tumors. Fourteen days post-treatment, the anti-VEGF virus GLV-1h108 was colonizing 78.8% of the tumors when GLV-1h68 colonization rate was 49.6%. These data confirmed the synergistic effect of VEGF blockade and VACV replication for tumor regression.
Three of the tumor cell lines used to assess VACV-mediated angiogenesis inhibition were found, in certain conditions, to mimic either endothelial cell or pericyte functions, and participate directly to the vascular structure. The expression by these tumor cells of e-selectin, p-selectin, ICAM-1 and VCAM-1, normally expressed on activated endothelial cells, corroborates our findings. These proteins play an important role in immune cell recruitment, and there amount vary in presence of VEGF, PlGF and Ang-2, confirming the involvement of angiogenic factors in the immuno-modulatory abilities of tumors.
In this study VACV-mediated angiogenesis blockade proved its potential as a therapeutic agent able to treat different tumor types and prevent resistance observed during bevacizumab treatment by acting on different factors. First, the expression of several antibodies by VACV would prevent another angiogenic factor to take over VEGF and stimulate angiogenesis. Then, the ability of VACV to infect tumor cells would prevent them to form blood vessel-like structures to sustain tumor growth, and the localized delivery of the antibody would decrease the risk of adverse effects. Next, the blockade of angiogenic factors would improve VACV replication and decrease the immune-modulatory effect of tumors. Finally the fact that angiogenesis blockade lasts until total regression of the tumor would prevent the recovery of the tumor-associated vasculature and the relapse of patients.
Oncolytic viral therapies have shown great promise pre-clinically and in human clinical trials for the treatment of various cancers. Oncolytic viruses selectively infect and replicate in cancer cells, destroying tumor tissue via cell lysis, while leaving noncancerous tissues unharmed. Vaccinia virus (VACV) is arguably one of the safest viruses, which has been intensively studied in molecular biology and pathogenesis as a vaccine for the eradication of smallpox in more than 200 million people. It has fast and efficient replication, and cytoplasmic replication of the virus lessens the chance of recombination or integration of viral DNA into the genome of host cells. Anti-tumor therapeutic efficacy of VACV has been demonstrated for human cancers in xenograft models with a variety of tumor types. In addition recombinant oncolytic VACVs carrying imaging genes represent an advance in treatment strategy that combines tumor-specific therapeutics as well as diagnostics.
As for other targeted therapies, a number of challenges remain for the clinical translation of oncolytic virotherapy. These challenges include the potential safety risk of replication of oncolytic virus in non-tumor tissue, the relatively poor virus spread throughout solid tumor tissue and the disadvantageous ratio between anti-viral and anti-tumoral immunity. However, manipulation of components of the tumor microenvironment may help oncolytic virus infection in killing the tumor tissue and thereby increasing the anti-tumor efficacy. Furthermore, dogs with natural cancer are considered as one of the best animal models to develop new drugs for cancer therapy. Traditionally, rodent cancer models have been used for development of cancer therapeutics. However, they do not adequately represent several features that define cancer in humans, including biology of initiation of tumor, the complexity of cancer recurrence and metastasis and outcomes to novel therapies. However, the tumor microenvironment, histopathology, molecular and genomics data from dog tumors has significant similarities with corresponding human tumors. These advantages of pet dog cancers provide a unique opportunity to integrate canine cancer patients in the studies designed for the development of new cancer drugs targeted against both human and canine cancers. This dissertation centers on the use of VACV strains in canine cancer xenografts with the aim of understanding the effects of modulation of tumor microenvironment on VACV-mediated tumor therapy.
In the first studies, wild-type VACV strain LIVP6.1.1 was tested for its oncolytic efficiency in canine soft tissue sarcoma (STSA-1) and canine prostate carcinoma (DT08/40) cells in culture and xenografts models. LIVP6.1.1 infected, replicated within, and killed both STSA-1 and DT08/40 cells in cell culture. The replication of virus was more efficient in STSA-1 cells compared to DT08/40 cells. In xenograft mouse models, LIVP6.1.1 was safe and effective in regressing both STSA-1 and DT08/40 xenografts. However, tumor regression was faster in STSA-1 xenografts compared to DT08/40 xenografts presumably due to more efficient replication of virus in STSA-1 cells. Biodistribution profiles revealed persistence of virus in tumors 5 and 7 weeks post virus injection in STSA-1 and DT08/40 xenografts, respectively, with the virus mainly cleared from all other major organs. Immunofluorescence staining detected successful colonization of VACV in the tumor. Consequently, LIVP6.1.1 colonization in the tumor showed infiltration of innate immune cells mainly granulocytes and macrophages in STSA-1 tumor xenografts. These findings suggest that virotherapy-mediated anti-tumor mechanism in xenografts could be a combination of direct viral oncolysis of tumor cells and virus-dependent infiltration of tumor-associated host immune cells.
In further studies, the effects of modulation of tumor angiogenesis of VACV therapy were analyzed in canine cancer xenografts. GLV-1h109 VACV strain (derived from prototype virus GLV-1h68) encoding the anti-VEGF single chain antibody GLAF-1 was characterized for its oncolytic efficacy in STSA-1 and DT08/40 cancer cells in culture and tumor xenografts. Concomitantly, the effects of locally expressed GLAF- 1 in tumors on virus replication, host immune infiltration, tumor vascularization and tumor growth were also evaluated.
GLV-1h109 was shown to be similar to the parental virus GLV-1h68 in expression of the two marker genes that both virus strains have in common (Ruc-GFP and gusA) in cell cultures. Additionally, the anti-VEGF single-chain antibody GLAF-1 was expressed by GLV-1h109 in both cell cultures and tumor xenografts. The insertion of GLAF-1 did not significantly affect the replication and cytotoxicity of GLV-1h109 in the STSA-1 and DT08/40 cell lines, although at early time points (24-48 hpi), the replication of GLV-1h109 was higher in STSA-1 cells compared to DT08/40 cells. In addition, STSA-1 cells were more susceptible to lysis with GLV-1h109 than DT08/40 cells. GLV-1h109 achieved a significant inhibition of tumor growth in both STSA-1 and DT08/40 canine xenografts models. Consequently, the significant regression of tumor growth was initiated earlier in STSA-1 tumor xenografts compared to regression in DT08/40 xenografts. The reason for the higher efficacy of GLV-1h109 in STSA-1 xenografts than DT08/40 xenografts was attributed to more efficient replication of virus in STSA-1 cells. In addition, tumor-specific virus infection led to a continued presence of GLAF-1 in peripheral blood, which could be useful as a pharmacokinetic marker to monitor virus colonization and persistence in GLV-1h109- injected xenograft mice. GLAF-1 is a single-chain antibody targeting human and murine VEGF. It was demonstrated that GLAF-1 was functional and recognized both canine and human VEGF with equal efficiency.
Histological analysis of tumor sections 7 days after GLV-1h109 injection confirmed that colonization of VACV and intratumoral expression of GLAF-1 translated into a significant decrease in blood vessel number compared to GLV-1h68 or PBS-treated control tumors. Subsequently, reduction in blood vessel density significantly improved the spread and replication of VACV as observed by FACS analysis and standard plaque assay, respectively. Inhibition of tumor angiogenesis and increased replication of virus further improved the infiltration of innate immune cells mainly granulocytes and macrophages in STSA-1 tumor xenografts. Both the results, i.e. improved virus spread and increased infiltration of innate immune cells in tumor, were explained by a phenomenon called “vascular normalization”, where anti-VEGF therapy normalizes the heterogeneous tumor vasculature thereby improving delivery and spread of VACV. In summary, the effects of inhibition of tumor angiogenesis on virus spread and replication were demonstrated using a vaccinia virus caring an anti- angiogenic payload targeting vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) in canine cancer xenografts.
In the final studies, the effects of VACV therapy on modulation of the immune system were analyzed in canine cancer patients enrolled in a phase I clinical trial. V-VET1 (clinical grade LIVP6.1.1 VACV) injection significantly increased the percentages of CD3+CD8+ T lymphocytes at 21 days after initiation of treatment. CD3+CD8+ T lymphocytes are mainly cytotoxic T lymphocytes that have potential to lyse cancer cells. Subsequently, the frequency of immune suppressor cells, mainly MDSCs and Treg was also analyzed in peripheral blood of canine cancer patients. Increase in the MDSC population and decreased CD8/Treg ratio is known to have inhibitory effects on the functions of cytotoxic T cells. We demonstrated that injection of V-VET1 in canine cancer patients significantly reduced the percentages of MDSCs at 21 days post initiation of treatment. Additionally, CD8/Treg ratio was increased 21 days after initiation of V-VET1 treatment. We also showed that changes in the frequency of immune cells neither depends on dose of virus nor depends on tumor type according to the data observed from this clinical trial with eleven analyzed patients.
This preclinical and clinical data have important clinical implications of how VACV therapy can be used for the treatment of canine cancers. Moreover, dogs with natural cancers can be used as an ideal animal model to improve the oncolytic virotherapy for human cancers. Furthermore, modulation of tumor microenvironment mainly tumor angiogenesis and tumor immunity has significant impact on the success of oncolytic virotherapy.
Using viruses to treat cancer is a novel approach to an age-old disease. Oncolytic viruses are native or recombinant viruses that have the innate or enhanced capability to infect tumour cells, replicate within the tumour microenvironment and subsequently lyse those cells. One representative, the vaccinia virus (VACV), belongs to the orthopoxvirus genus of the Poxviridae family. GLV-1h68, a recombinant and attenuated vaccinia virus devel- oped by the Genelux Corporation, is a member of this family currently being tested in various phase I/II clinical trials under the name GL-ONC1. It has been shown to specif- ically replicate in tumour cells while sparing healthy tissue and to metabolise prodrug at or transport immunological payloads to the site of affliction. Since imaging modalities offer little insight into viral replication deep within the body, and because oncolytic virotherapy is dependent on replication within the target tissue, the need for a monitoring system is evident. Pharmacokinetic analysis of this oncolytic agent was to give insight into the dynamics present in tumours during treatment. This, in turn, would give clinicians the opportunity to monitor the efficacy as early as possible after the onset of treatment, to observe treatment progression and possibly to gauge prognosis, without resorting to invasive procedures, e.g. biopsies. A criteria for viable biomarkers was that it had to be directly dependent on viral replica- tion. Ideally, a marker for treatment efficacy would be specific to the treatment modality, not necessarily the treatment type. Such a marker would be highly detectable (high sen- sitivity), specific for the treatment (high specificity), and present in an easily obtained specimen (blood). Taking this into consideration, the biomarkers were chosen for their potential to be indicators of viral replication. Thus, the biomarkers analysed in this thesis are: the native proteins expressed by the viral genes A27L and B5R, the virally encoded recombinant proteins β-galactosidase, β-glucuronidase, green fluorescent protein (GFP), carboxypeptidase G2 (CPG2) and carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA). Each marker is under the control of one of five different promoters present. All recombinant viruses used in this thesis express A27L, B5R, GFP and β-glucuronidase and all are derived from the parental virus GLV-1h68. In addition to these markers, GLV-1h68 expresses β-galactosidase; GLV-1h181 expresses CPG2. [...]
Over the past 30 years, much effort and financial support have been invested in the fight against cancer, yet cancer still represents the leading cause of death in the world. Conventional therapies for treatment of cancer are predominantly directed against tumor cells. Recently however, new treatments options have paid more attention to exploiting the advantage of targeting the tumor stroma instead.
Vaccinia virus (VACV) has played an important role in human medicine since the 18th century as a vaccination against smallpox. In our laboratory, the recombinant, replication-competent vaccinia virus, GLV-1h68, was shown to enter, colonize and destroy cancer cells both in cell culture, and in vivo, in xenograft models (Zhang, Yu et al. 2007). In addition, combined therapy of GLV-1h68 and anti-VEGF immunotherapy significantly enhanced antitumor therapy in vivo (Frentzen, Yu et al. 2009).
In this study, we constructed several new recombinant VACVs carrying genes encoding different antibodies against fibroblast activation protein (FAP) in stroma (GLV-1h282), nanobody against the extracellular domain of epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR, GLV-1h442) or antibodies targeting both vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and EGFR (GLV-1h444) or targeting both VEGF and FAP (GLV-1h446).
The expression of the recombinant proteins was first verified using protein analytical methods, SDS-gel electrophoresis, Western blot analysis, immunoprecipitation (IP) assays and ELISA assays. The proteins were detected after infection of the cells with the different VACVs and the recombinant proteins purified by affinity adsorption. The purified antibodies were shown to specifically bind to their respective antigens.
Secondly, the infection and replication capability of all the virus strains was analyzed in cell culture using several human tumor cell lines (A549, FaDu or DU145), revealing that all the new recombinant VACVs were able to infect cancer cells with comparable efficiency to the parental viruses from which they were derived.
Thirdly, the antitumor efficacy of the new recombinant VACVs was evaluated in vivo using several human cancer xenograft models in mice. In A549 and DU145 xenografts, the new recombinant VACVs exhibited an enhanced therapeutic efficacy compared to GLV-1h68 with no change in toxicity in mice. In the FaDu xenograft, treatment with GLV-1h282 (anti-FAP) significantly slowed down the speed of tumor growth compared to GLV-1h68. Additionally, treatment with the recombinant VACVs expressed the various antibodies achieved comparable or superior therapeutic effects compared to treatment with a combination of GLV-1h68 and the commercial therapeutic antibodies, Avastin, Erbitux or both.
Next, the virus distribution in tumors and organs of treated mice was evaluated. For most of the viruses, the virus titer in tumors was not signficantly diffferent than GLV-1h68. However, for animals treated with GLV-1h282, the virus titer in tumors was significantly higher than with GLV-1h68. This may be the reason for enhanced antitumor efficacy of GLV-1h282 in vivo.
Lastly, the underlying mechanisms of therapeutic antibody-enhanced antitumor effects were investigated by immunohistochemistry. Blood vessels density and cell proliferation in tumors were suppressed after treatment with the antibody-encoded VACVs. The results indicated that the suppression of angiogenesis or cell proliferation in tumors may cause the observed therapeutic effect.
In conclusion, the results of the studies presented here support the hypothesis that the treatment of solid tumors with a combination of oncolytic virotherapy and immunotherapy has an additive effect over each treatment alone. Moreover, expression of the immunotherapeutic antibody by the oncolytic VACV locally in the tumor enhances the antitumor effect over systemic treatment with the same antibody. Combined, these results indicate that therapy with oncolytic VACVs expressing-therapeutic antibodies may be a promising approach for the treatment of cancer.
Nach Einschätzung der Weltgesundheitsorganisation WHO wird Krebs im Jahr 2013 die weltweit häufigste Todesursache bei Menschen und Haustieren sein. Diese Situation erfordert die Entwicklung neuer therapeutischer Ansätze. Hauptziel einer Tumortherapie ist es, sowohl den Primärtumor als auch die Metastasen möglichst vollständig zu entfernen. Dabei wird nach Methoden gesucht, die im Gegensatz zu den meisten gegenwärtigen therapeutischen Einsätzen, wie der chirurgischen Entfernung bösartiger Neubildungen, Chemotherapie und Strahlentherapie, selektiv die bösartigen Zellen erkennen und zerstören können. Eine faszinierende Möglichkeit in dieser Hinsicht ist die Verwendung von onkolytischen Viren, die die Fähigkeit besitzen, sich selektiv sowohl in Primärtumoren als auch in Metastasen anzusiedeln und die Krebszellen dort zu zerstören. Das Konzept, dass Viren nützlich für die Bekämpfung von Krebs sein könnten, ist nicht neu. Allerdings konnte erst in den letzten Jahren durch zahlreiche Studien bestätigt werden, dass verschiedene Viren in der Lage sind, eine signifikante Antitumorwirkung in vivo auszuüben. Zu den erfolgversprechenden onkolytischen Viren zählen insbesondere Adenovirus, Herpes simplex Virus, Reovirus und Vaccinia-Virus, die sich bereits in Phase III der klinischen Studien befinden oder kurz davor sind. Die therapeutische Nutzung von tumorspezifischen onkolytischen Viren beim Menschen hat bereits begonnen. Im Rahmen der vorliegenden Doktorarbeit wurden verschiedene Aspekte der Wirkungsweise von Vaccinia-Virus-Stämmen bei der Therapie verschiedener Tumore aus Mensch und Hund im Xenotransplantat-Mausmodell bearbeitet: die Onkolyse der Krebszellen und Inhibition des Tumorwachstums sowie die Effekte der Virusinfektion auf das Tumormikromilieu und die Mitwirkung des angeborenen Immunsystems bei der Virotherapie. Das Tumormikromilieu (Stroma) setzt sich aus einer Vielzahl verschiedener Zellen und Komponenten der extrazellulären Matrix zusammen. Die Krebszellen bilden unter anderem mit Endothelzellen des Blut- und Lymphsystems und verschiedenen Immunzellen eine komplexe Organ-ähnliche Struktur. Weitere wichtige Bestandteile des Stromas sind Wachstumsfaktoren, Chemokine und Zytokine und die Tumorvaskulatur. Diese ist durch zahlreiche strukturelle und funktionelle Abnormalitäten charakterisiert, wodurch die Effektivität von Strahlen- und Chemotherapie herabgesetzt wird. Weiterhin ist das Tumormikromilieu durch seine Ähnlichkeit mit einer chronischen Entzündungsreaktion gekennzeichnet und wirkt immunsupprimierend auf rekrutierte Leukozyten, die wiederum die Inflammation verstärken und die Angiogenese und das Tumorwachstum weiter fördern. Aufgrund dieser vielen Komponenten ist die Zusammensetzung jedes Tumors einzigartig, weswegen Standardtherapien häufig nicht zu einer Heilung führen. Die Wirkung der Viren bei der Virotherapie beruht vermutlich auf 4 Mechanismen, die einzeln oder in Kombination auftreten können: die direkte Onkolyse der Krebszellen, die Zerstörung des Tumorblutgefäßsystems, die Aktivierung des Immunsystems des Wirts und die Suppression der microRNA-Expression des Wirtes. Zusätzlich kann die Expression therapeutischer Gene die onkolytische Wirkung verstärken. Zum Nachweis der Onkolyse der Krebszellen und Inhibition des Tumorwachstums wurde zuerst das Virus GLV-1h68 in einem autologen humanen Melanomzellpaar, 888-MEL und 1936-MEL, eingesetzt. Das GLV-1h68-Virus wurde auf Basis des Wildtyp Vaccinia-Virus LIVP durch die Insertion von 3 Expressionskassetten in den drei Genloci F14.5L, J2R und A56 genetisch konstruiert. 888-MEL, eine zu einem frühen Zeitpunkt der Krebserkrankung aus einer Metastase isolierte Zelllinie, zeigt nach Infektion mit GLV-1h68 im Mausmodell Tumornekrose („Responder“), während 1936-MEL aus einer späten Metastasierungsphase kaum mit Onkolyse auf eine Virusinfektion reagiert („Poor-Responder“). Die onkolytische Wirkung konnte mittels Durchflusszytometrie in Tumoren beider Zelllinien zu einem frühen Zeitpunkt nach Virusinfektion nachgewiesen werden. In 888-MEL-Tumoren wurde hierbei eine große Zahl infizierter und toter Zellen nach Virusinfektion gefunden. Gleichzeitig wurde eine hohe Zahl an Immunzellen detektiert, die nach Virusinfektion reduziert war. In den schwächer reagierenden 1936-MEL-Tumoren konnte eine Onkolyse bei Infektion mit höherer Virusmenge und zu einem früheren Zeitpunkt demonstriert werden, wodurch mehr Zellen infiziert wurden. Zusätzlich wurde eine Steigerung der nur in geringer Zahl vorhandenen Immunzellen nachgewiesen. Trotz des unterschiedlichen Tumormikromilieus konnte somit ein onkolytischer Effekt in beiden Tumormodellen erzielt werden. ...
Oncolytic virotherapy represents a promising approach to revolutionize cancer therapy. Several preclinical and clinical trials display the safety of oncolytic viruses as wells as their efficiency against solid tumors. The development of complementary diagnosis and monitoring concepts as well as the optimization of anti-tumor activity are key points of current virotherapy research. Within the framework of this thesis, the diagnostic and therapeutic prospects of beta-glucuronidase expressed by the oncolytic vaccinia virus strain GLV-1h68 were evaluated. In this regard, a beta-glucuronidase-based, therapy-accompanying biomarker test was established which is currently under clinical validation. By using fluorescent substrates, the activity of virally expressed beta-glucuronidase could be detected and quantified. Thereby conclusions about the replication kinetics of oncolytic viruses in animal models and virus-induced cancer cell lysis could be drawn. These findings finally led to the elaboration and establishment of a versatile biomarker assay which allows statements regarding the replication of oncolytic viruses in mice based on serum samples. Besides the analysis of retrospective conditions, this test is able to serve as therapy-accompanying monitoring tool for virotherapy approaches with beta-glucuronidase-expressing viruses. The newly developed assay also served as complement to routinely used plaque assays as well as reference for virally expressed anti-angiogenic antibodies in additional preclinical studies. Further validation of this biomarker test is currently taking place in the context of clinical trials with GL-ONC1 (clinical grade GLV-1h68) and has already shown promising preliminary results. It was furthermore demonstrated that fluorogenic substrates in combination with beta-glucuronidase expressed by oncolytic viruses facilitated the optical detection of solid tumors in preclinical models. In addition to diagnostic purposes, virus-encoded enzymes could also be combined with prodrugs resulting in an improved therapeutic outcome of oncolytic virotherapy. In further studies, the visualization of virus-induced immune reactions as well as the establishment of innovative concepts to improve the therapeutic outcome of oncolytic virotherapy could be accomplished. In conclusion, the results of this thesis provide crucial findings about the influence of virally expressed beta-glucuronidase on various diagnostic concepts in the context of oncolytic virotherapy. In addition, innovative monitoring and therapeutic strategies could be established. Our preclinical findings have important clinical influence, particularly by the development of a therapy-associated biomarker assay which is currently used in different clinical trials.
In initial experiments, the well characterized VACV strain GLV-1h68 and three wild-type LIVP isolates were utilized to analyze gene expression in a pair of autologous human melanoma cell lines (888-MEL and 1936 MEL) after infection. Microarray analyses, followed by sequential statistical approaches, characterized human genes whose transcription is affected specifically by VACV infection. In accordance with the literature, those genes were involved in broad cellular functions, such as cell death, protein synthesis and folding, as well as DNA replication, recombination, and repair. In parallel to host gene expression, viral gene expression was evaluated with help of customized VACV array platforms to get better insight over the interplay between VACV and its host. Our main focus was to compare host and viral early events, since virus genome replication occurs early after infection. We observed that viral transcripts segregated in a characteristic time-specific pattern, consistent with the three temporal expression classes of VACV genes, including a group of genes which could be classified as early-stage genes. In this work, comparison of VACV early replication and respective early gene transcription led to the identification of seven viral genes whose expression correlated strictly with replication. We considered the early expression of those seven genes to be representative for VACV replication and we therefore referred to them as viral replication indicators (VRIs). To explore the relationship between host cell transcription and viral replication, we correlated viral (VRI) and human early gene expression. Correlation analysis revealed a subset of 114 human transcripts whose early expression tightly correlated with early VRI expression and thus early viral replication. These 114 human molecules represented an involvement in broad cellular functions. We found at least six out of 114 correlates to be involved in protein ubiquitination or proteasomal function. Another molecule of interest was the serine-threonine protein kinase WNK lysine-deficient protein kinase 1 (WNK1). We discovered that WNK1 features differences on several molecular biological levels associated with permissiveness to VACV infection. In addition to that, a set of human genes was identified with possible predictive value for viral replication in an independent dataset. A further objective of this work was to explore baseline molecular biological variances associated with permissiveness which could help identifying cellular components that contribute to the formation of a permissive phenotype. Therefore, in a subsequent approach, we screened a set of 15 melanoma cell lines (15-MEL) regarding their permissiveness to GLV-1h68, evaluated by GFP expression levels, and classified the top four and lowest four cell lines into high and low permissive group, respectively. Baseline gene transcriptional data, comparing low and highly permissive group, suggest that differences between the two groups are at least in part due to variances in global cellular functions, such as cell cycle, cell growth and proliferation, as well as cell death and survival. We also observed differences in the ubiquitination pathway, which is consistent with our previous results and underlines the importance of this pathway in VACV replication and permissiveness. Moreover, baseline microRNA (miRNA) expression between low and highly permissive group was considered to provide valuable information regarding virus-host co-existence. In our data set, we identified six miRNAs that featured varying baseline expression between low and highly permissive group. Finally, copy number variations (CNVs) between low and highly permissive group were evaluated. In this study, when investigating differences in the chromosomal aberration patterns between low and highly permissive group, we observed frequent segmental amplifications within the low permissive group, whereas the same regions were mostly unchanged in the high group. Taken together, our results highlight a probable correlation between viral replication, early gene expression, and the respective host response and thus a possible involvement of human host factors in viral early replication. Furthermore, we revealed the importance of cellular baseline composition for permissiveness to VACV infection on different molecular biological levels, including mRNA expression, miRNA expression, as well as copy number variations. The characterization of human target genes that influence viral replication could help answering the question of host cell response to oncolytic virotherapy and provide important information for the development of novel recombinant vaccinia viruses with improved features to enhance replication rate and hence trigger therapeutic outcome.