Refine
Has Fulltext
- yes (5) (remove)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (5)
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (5) (remove)
Keywords
- Thermoregulation (5) (remove)
Institute
- Theodor-Boveri-Institut für Biowissenschaften (5) (remove)
Wasps of the genus Polistes comprise over 200 species and are nearly cosmopolitan. They show a lack of physiological caste differentiation and are therefore considered as primitively eusocial. Furthermore, paper wasps are placed between the solitary living Eumenidae and the highly social organized Vespinae. Hence, they are often called a “key genus” for understanding the evolution of sociality. Particularly, Polistes dominula, with its small easy manageable nests and its frequent occurrence and wide distribution range is often the subject of studies.
In Europe, the invasion of this species into northern regions is on the rise. Since little was known about the nesting behaviour of P. dominula in Central Europe, the basic principles about nesting were investigated in Würzburg, Germany (latitude 49°) by conducting a comprehensive field-study spanning three consecutive years. Furthermore, the thermoregulation of individual wasps in their natural habitat had not yet been investigated in detail. Therefore, their ability to respond to external hazards with elevated thorax temperatures was tested. In addition, different types of nest thermoregulation were investigated using modern methods such as infrared thermography and temperature data logger.
In the present work, the investigation of basic nesting principles revealed that foundress groups (1-4 foundresses) and nests are smaller and that the nesting season is shorter in the Würzburg area than in other regions. The mean size of newly founded nests was 83 cells and the average nesting season was around 4.6 months. The queens neither preferred single (54%) nor multiple founding (46%) in this study. The major benefit of multiple founding is an increased rate of survival. During the three years of observation, only 47% of single-foundress colonies survived, whereas 100% of colonies that were built by more than two queens, survived. However, an influence of the number of foundresses on the productivity of colonies in terms of number of cells and pupae per nest has not shown up. However, the length of the nesting season as well as the nest sizes varied strongly depending on the climatic conditions of the preceding winter during the three consecutive years.
In order to investigate the thermoregulatory mechanisms of individual adult P. dominula wasps, I presented artificial threats by applying smoke or carbon dioxide simulating fire and predator attacks, respectively, and monitored the thorax temperature of wasps on the nest using infrared thermography. The results clearly revealed that P. dominula workers recognized smoke and CO2 and reacted almost instantaneously and simultaneously with an increase of their thorax temperature. The maximal thorax temperature was reached about 65 s after the application of both stressors, but subsequently the wasps showed a different behaviour pattern. They responded to a longer application of smoke with moving to the exit and fled, whereas in case of CO2 the wasps started flying and circling the nest without trying to escape. No rise of the thorax temperature was detectable after an air blast was applied or in wasps resting on the nest. Additionally, the thorax temperatures of queens were investigated during dominance battles. I found that the thorax temperature of the dominant queens rose up to 5°C compared to that of subordinate queens that attacked the former.
The study of active mechanisms for nest thermoregulation revealed no brood incubation or clustering behaviour of P. dominula. Furthermore, I found out that wing fanning for cooling the nest was almost undetectable (4 documented cases). However, I could convincingly record that water evaporation is most effective for nest cooling. By the direct comparison of active (with brood and adults) and non-active (without brood and adults) nests, the start of cooling by water evaporation was detected above maximum outside temperatures of 25°C or at nest temperatures above 35°C. The powerful role of water in nest cooling was manifested by an average decrease of temperature of a single cell of about 8°C and a mean duration of 7 min until the cell reached again its initial temperature. The investigation of passive thermoregulatory mechanisms revealed that the nest site choice as well as nest orientation appears to be essential for P. dominula wasps. Furthermore, I was able to show that the architecture of the nests plays an important role. Based on the presented results, it can be assumed that the vertical orientation of cells helps maintaining the warmth of nests during the night, whereas the pedicel assists in cooling the nest during the day.
Like many other social insect societies, honeybees collectively share the resources they gather by feeding each other. These feeding contacts, known as trophallaxis, are regarded as the fundamental basis for social behavior in honeybees and other social insects for assuring the survival of the individual and the welfare of the group. In honeybees, where most of the trophallactic contacts are formed in the total darkness of the hive, the antennae play a decisive role in initiation and maintenance of the feeding contact, because they are sensitive to gustatory stimuli. The sequences of behaviors performed by the receiver bees at the beginning of a feeding contact includes the contact of one antenna with the mouthparts of a donor bee where the regurgitated food is located. The antennal motor action is characterized by behavioral asymmetry, which is novel among communicative motor actions in invertebrates. This preference of right over left antenna is without exception even after removal of the antennal flagellum. This case of laterality in basic social interaction might have its reason in the gustatory asymmetry in the antennae, because the right antenna turns out to be significantly more sensitive to stimulation with sugar water of various concentrations than the left one. Trophallactic contacts which guarantee a constant access to food for every individual in the hive are vitally important to the honeybee society, because honeybees are heterothermic insects which actively regulate their thoracic temperature. Even though the individual can regulate its body temperature, its heating performance is strictly limited by the amount of sugar ingested. The reason for this is that honeybees use mostly the glucose in their hemolymph as the energy substrate for muscular activity, and the heat producing flight muscles are among the metabolically most active tissues known. The fuel for their activity is honey; processed nectar with a sugar content of ~80% stored in the honeycomb. The results show that the sugar content of the ingested food correlates positively with the thoracic temperature of the honeybees even if they are caged and show no actual heating-related behavior as in brood warming or heating in the centre of the winter cluster. Honeybees actively regulate their brood temperature by heating to keep the temperature between 33 °C to 36 °C if ambient temperatures are lower. Heating rapidly depletes the worker’s internal energy; therefore the heating performance is limited by the honey that is ingested before the heating process. This study focused on the behavior and the thoracic temperature of the participants in trophallactic food exchanges on the brood comb. The brood area is the centre of heating activity in the hive, and therefore the region of highest energy demand. The results show that the recipients in a trophallactic food exchange have a higher thoracic temperature during feeding contacts than donors, and after the feeding contact the former engage in brood heating more often. The donor bees have lower thoracic temperature and shuttle constantly between honey stores and the brood comb, where they transfer the stored honey to heating bees. In addition, the results show a heat-triggered mechanism that enables donor and recipient to accomplish trophallactic contacts without delay in the total darkness of the hive in the brood area as the most energy consuming part of the hive. Providing heat-emitting workers with small doses of high performance fuel contributes to an economic distribution of resources consistent with the physiological conditions of the bees and the ecological requirements of the hive, resulting in a highly economical resource management system which might be one of the factors favouring the evolution of perennial bee colonies in temperate regions. The conclusion of these findings suggests a resource management strategy that has evolved from submissive placation behavior as it is seen in honeybees, bumblebees and other hymenopterans. The heat-triggered feedback mechanism behind the resource management of the honeybee´s thermoregulatory behavior reveals a new aspect of the division of labor and a new aspect of communication, and sheds new light on sociality in honeybees.
In dieser Arbeit untersuche ich das Verhalten von Arbeiterbienen beim Brutwärmen, die Wärmeübertragung von den Bienen auf die gedeckelte Brut, die thermophysikalischen Eigenschaften des Brutnests und spezielle Aspekte des Brutnestaufbaus, die für dieses Thema relevant sind und bisher nicht untersucht wurden. Meine Arbeit umfasst Verhaltensbeobachtungen und thermografische Messungen an individuellen Bienen, die Simulation des Heizverhaltens von Arbeiterinnen und das Messen der Temperaturänderungen in der Wabe, die Messung der thermophysikalischen Eigenschaften der Brutwabe und der Zellwände (Wärmeleitfähigkeit und Durchlässigkeit für Wärmestrahlung), die Auswertung von Brutzelltemperaturen als Ergebnis des Verhaltens von Arbeiterbienen, die Analyse der Anzahl und der räumlichen Verteilung von Brutlücken (Auswertung in 2-D und 3-D bezüglich beider Wabenseiten) und die Entwicklung spezifischer Computersoftware, die zur Erarbeitung dieser Ergebnisse unverzichtbar ist. Ein wichtiges Ergebnis dieser Arbeit ist die Entdeckung und Beschreibung eines bemerkenswerten, bislang unbekannten Verhaltens der Honigbiene: Die Aufrechterhaltung hoher Thoraxtemperaturen (TTh) bei Langzeitbesuchen in offenen Zellen („Lücken“) die verstreut in der gedeckelten Brutfläche vorkommen. Hier zeige ich, dass die Aufrechterhaltung der hohen TTh nicht auf den Zellinhalt (z. B. offene Brut) bezogen ist - in den meisten Fällen waren die besuchten Zellen ohnehin leer - sondern auf die direkt benachbarte gedeckelte Brut, mit der diese Zellen über gemeinsame Zellwände in Kontakt stehen. Dieses Verhalten liefert eine Erklärung für Langzeitzellbesuche von sehr langer Dauer ohne erkennbare Aktivität, die in früheren Arbeiten beschrieben aber nicht völlig verstanden wurden, und es rehabilitiert die scheinbar „faulen“ Bienen im Zellinnern. Diesem Verhalten kommt eine große Bedeutung für das Brutwärmen zu, da sich der aufgeheizte Thorax tief in der Wabe (fast an der Mittelwand) befindet wo der Wärmeverlust an die Luft minimiert ist und von wo bis zu 6 umliegende Puppenzellen gleichzeitig gewärmt werden können. Im Vergleich zum Brutwärmeverhalten an der Wabenoberfläche (Andrücken des Thorax an die Brutdeckel), wo nur 1 oder Teile von 3 Brutdeckeln mit dem Thorax in Berührung stehen, ist das Wärmen im Zellinnern mit derselben TTh bis zu 2,6-fach effizienter. Die Messung der thermophysikalischen Eigenschaften der Brutwabe und die Simulation des Brutwärmeverhaltens unter kontrollierten Bedingungen zeigen, dass sich die Wabe langsam aufwärmt und eher ein lokal begrenztes Wärmen als eine rasche Wärmeausbreitung über eine große Fläche begünstigt. Der Einflussbereich eines einzelnen Zellbesuchers hängt von seiner TTh und der Dauer des Zellbesuchs ab. Anstiege der Bruttemperatur in bis zu 3 Zellen Abstand zum Zellbesucher sind nachweisbar. Das hier beschriebene Brutwärmeverhalten im Innern von Lücken (offenen Zellen) bietet nicht nur neue Einsichten in das Bienenverhalten. Es ermöglicht auch eine Neubewertung der Lücken und ihrer Nützlichkeit für die Bienen. Eine von mir entwickelte Computersoftware („CombUse 2.0“) ermöglicht es, das Vorkommen und die räumliche Verteilung von Lücken mit hoher Genauigkeit auf der Ebene einzelner Zellen zu erfassen und auszuwerten. Die räumliche Verteilung der Lücken in der gedeckelten Brutfläche zeigt, dass schon bei geringen Lückenhäufigkeiten von ca. 4 bis 10 %, die in gesunden Kolonien normal sind, eine überraschend große Zahl gedeckelter Brutzellen (88 % bis 99 %, wenn die dreidimensionale Verteilung berücksichtigt wird) im Einflussbereich von Brut wärmenden Zellbesuchern sind. Obwohl das Brutwärmeverhalten im Zellinnern schwer zu entdecken und zu beobachten ist, führen die in dieser Arbeit präsentierten Daten zu dem Schluss, dass es sich dabei um einen wichtigen Bestandteil der Nestklimatisierung bei Honigbienen handelt.
Honigbienen (Apis mellifera carnica) regulieren die Temperatur ihrer Brut in einem sehr engen Temperaturfenster, da vor allem die gedeckelte Brut sehr temperaturempfindlich reagiert (Groh et al. 2004). Die Thermoregulation ist nicht – wie lange angenommen – Beiprodukt von alltäglichen Arbeiten der Bienen im Brutbereich, sondern eine aktive und Energie- und Zeitaufwändige eigene Tätigkeit. Arbeiterinnen ziehen sich mit ihren Beinen an die Brutoberfläche, drücken ihren warmen Thorax auf die Brutdeckel und verharren so für einige Minuten um mit der eigenen Körperwärme die Brut zu temperieren (Bujok et al. 2002). Wie erwartet korrelierte die Thoraxtemperatur einer Arbeiterin mit der Frequenz der abdominalen Atembewegungen, bei sehr hohen Thoraxtemperaturen (über 40°C) erreichten die Bienen Atemfrequenzen von über 8Hz. Eine weitere Methode die Brut effektiv zu wärmen übten Bienen aus, die leere Zellen im gedeckelten Brutbereich besuchen (Kleinhenz et al. 2003). Arbeiterinnen gingen dabei bevorzugt in Zellen, die von möglichst vielen gedeckelten Zellen umgeben waren. Sowohl die Dauer der Zellbesuche, als auch die mittlere Thoraxtemperatur bei Ein- und Austritt der Zelle korrelierten mit der Anzahl der benachbarten Brutzellen – je mehr Brutzellen eine leere Zelle in ihrer direkten Nachbarschaft hatte umso länger dauerte der Besuch einer Biene und umso höher ist die Ein- bzw. Austrittstemperatur der Biene. Mindestes 48 Stunden alte Bienen unterschieden sich signifikant in ihrem Wärmeverhalten von jüngeren Bienen. Tote gedeckelte Brut wurde in manchen Fällen über viele Tage (durchgehend bis 10 Tage) gewärmt, sie unterschied sich in ihrer Temperatur nicht von unbehandelter gedeckelter Brut. In weiteren Versuchen lag die Bruttemperatur von toter Brut zwar unter der eines Kontrollbereiches, die Temperatur lag aber weiterhin im optimalen Bereich von 33,5 bis 35°C (Groh et al. 2004). In diesen Versuchen wurde die tote Brut vor dem Einsetzen in den Beobachtungsstock wieder auf 35°C erwärmt. Wachskegel in gedeckelten Zellen wurden erkannt und ausgeräumt. Aktive Signale, die von der Brut ausgehen scheinen also nicht notwendig für die effektive Bruttemperaturregulierung zu sein. Untersuchungen mittels Laser-Doppler-Vibrometrie zeigten auch keine Hinweise auf eine mechanische Kommunikation zwischen den Puppen und den Arbeiterinnen. Das Brutwärmen scheint eine Aktion zu sein, die von den Bienen nur in Gemeinschaft sinnvoll durchgeführt werden kann. In einigen Fällen kam es während der Puppenphase zu unerklärlichen Abfällen in der Bruttemperatur, die nur durch einen positiven Rückkopplungseffekt seitens der Arbeiterinnen erklärt werden kann. Beim Brutwärmen spielen die Antennen der Arbeiterinnen wahrscheinlich eine wichtige Rolle. Während sich die Bienen beim aktiven Brutwärmen den Brutdeckel annähern sind die Antennenspitzen immer auf die Brutdeckel gerichtet. Fehlen den Arbeiterinnen die Antennen, dann ist die Thermoregulation eingeschränkt oder unzureichend. Die Bruttemperatur korreliert mit der Anzahl der abgetrennten Antennensegmente, je mehr Antennensegmente fehlen, desto weniger gut wird die Temperatur im Brutbereich hoch und konstant gehalten. Zusätzlich scheint es eine Lateralität in der Antennenfunktion zu geben, wurde die rechte Antenne gekürzt wärmten die Bienen die Brut signifikant schlechter, als beim Kürzen der linken Antenne. Durch das Kürzen der Antennen änderte sich auch das Verhalten der Tiere: Kontrollbienen verharrten ruhig im Brutbereich, während Bienen mit gekürzten Antennen teilweise ähnlich warm waren, aber nicht mehr das oben beschriebene aktive Brutwärmeverhalten zeigten.
The social organization of insect colonies has long fascinated naturalists. One of the main features of colony organization is division of labor, whereby each member of the colony specializes in a subset of all tasks required for successful group functioning. The most striking aspect of division of labor is its plasticity: workers switch between tasks in response to external challenges and internal perturbations. The mechanisms underlying flexible division of labor are far from being understood. In order to comprehend how the behavior of individuals gives rise to flexible collective behavior, several questions need to be addressed: We need to know how individuals acquire information about their colony's current demand situation; how they then adjust their behavior according; and which mechanisms integrate dozens or thousands of insect into a higher-order unit. With these questions in mind I have examined two examples of collective and flexible behavior in social bees. First, I addressed the question how a honey bee colony controls its pollen collection. Pollen foraging in honey bees is precisely organized and carefully regulated according to the colony's needs. How this is achieved is unclear. I investigated how foragers acquire information about their colony's pollen need and how they then adjust their behavior. A detailed documentation of pollen foragers in the hive under different pollen need conditions revealed that individual foragers modulate their in-hive working tempo according to the actual pollen need of the colony: Pollen foragers slowed down and stayed in the hive longer when pollen need was low and spent less time in the hive between foraging trips when pollen need of their colony was high. The number of cells inspected before foragers unloaded their pollen load did not change and thus presumably did not serve as cue to pollen need. In contrast, the trophallactic experience of pollen foragers changed with pollen need conditions: trophallactic contacts were shorter when pollen need was high and the number and probability of having short trophallactic contacts increased when pollen need increased. Thus, my results have provided support for the hypothesis that trophallactic experience is one of the various information pathways used by pollen foragers to assess their colony's pollen need. The second example of collective behavior I have examined in this thesis is the control of nest climate in bumble bee colonies, a system differing from pollen collection in honey bees in that information about task need (nest climate parameters) is directly available to all workers. I have shown that an increase in CO2 concentration and temperature level elicits a fanning response whereas an increase in relative humidity does not. The fanning response to temperature and CO2 was graded; the number of fanning bees increased with stimulus intensity. Thus, my study has evidenced flexible colony level control of temperature and CO2. Further, I have shown that the proportion of total work force a colony invests into nest ventilation does not change with colony size. However, the dynamic of the colony response changes: larger colonies show a faster response to perturbations of their colony environment than smaller colonies. Thus, my study has revealed a size-dependent change in the flexible colony behavior underlying homeostasis. I have shown that the colony response to perturbations in nest climate is constituted by workers who differ in responsiveness. Following a brief review of current ideas and models of self-organization and response thresholds in insect colonies, I have presented the first detailed investigation of interindividual variability in the responsiveness of all workers involved in a collective behavior. My study has revealed that bumble bee workers evidence consistent responses to certain stimulus levels and differ in their response thresholds. Some consistently respond to low stimulus intensities, others consistently respond to high stimulus intensities. Workers are stimulus specialists rather than task specialists. Further, I have demonstrated that workers of a colony differ in two other parameters of responsiveness: response probability and fanning activity. Response threshold, response probability and fanning activity are independent parameters of individual behavior. Besides demonstrating and quantifying interindividual variability, my study has provided empirical support for the idea of specialization through reinforcement. Response thresholds of fanning bees decreased over successive trials. I have discussed the importance of interindividual variability for specialization and the collective control of nest climate and present a general discussion of self-organization and selection. This study contributes to our understanding of individual behavior and collective structure in social insects. A fascinating picture of social organization is beginning to emerge. In place of centralized systems of communication and information transmission, insect societies frequently employ mechanisms based upon self-organization. Self-organization promises to be an important and unifying principle in physical, chemical and biological systems.