Refine
Has Fulltext
- yes (28)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (28)
Year of publication
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (24)
- Journal article (3)
- Master Thesis (1)
Keywords
- Biene (28) (remove)
Institute
- Theodor-Boveri-Institut für Biowissenschaften (28) (remove)
Sonstige beteiligte Institutionen
The ability to perceive the number of objects has been known to exist in vertebrates for a few decades, but recent behavioral investigations have demonstrated that several invertebrate species can also be placed on the continuum of numerical abilities shared with birds, mammals, and reptiles. In this review article, we present the main experimental studies that have examined the ability of insects to use numerical information. These studies have made use of a wide range of methodologies, and for this reason it is striking that a common finding is the inability of the tested animals to discriminate numerical quantities greater than four. Furthermore, the finding that bees can not only transfer learnt numerical discrimination to novel objects, but also to novel numerosities, is strongly suggestive of a true, albeit limited, ability to count. Later in the review, we evaluate the available evidence to narrow down the possible mechanisms that the animals might be using to solve the number-based experimental tasks presented to them. We conclude by suggesting avenues of further research that take into account variables such as the animals’ age and experience, as well as complementary cognitive systems such as attention and the time sense.
Honeybees (Apis mellifera) forage on a great variety of plant species, navigate over large distances to crucial resources, and return to communicate the locations of food sources and potential new nest sites to nest mates using a symbolic dance language. In order to achieve this, honeybees have evolved a rich repertoire of adaptive behaviours, some of which were earlier believed to be restricted to vertebrates. In this thesis, I explore the mechanisms involved in honeybee learning, memory, numerical competence and navigation. The findings acquired in this thesis show that honeybees are not the simple reflex automats they were once believed to be. The level of sophistication I found in the bees’ memory, their learning ability, their time sense, their numerical competence and their navigational abilities are surprisingly similar to the results obtained in comparable experiments with vertebrates. Thus, we should reconsider the notion that a bigger brain automatically indicates higher intelligence.
I. Timing is a crucial feature in organisms that live within a variable and changing environment. Complex mechanisms to measure time are wide-spread and were shown to exist in many taxa. These mechanisms are expected to provide fitness benefits by enabling organisms to anticipate environmental changes and adapt accordingly. However, very few studies have addressed the adaptive value of proper timing. The objective of this PhD-project was to investigate mechanisms and fitness consequences of timing decisions concerning colony phenology and foraging activity in the honey bee (Apis mellifera), a social insect species with a high degree of social organization and one of the most important pollinators of wild plants and crops. In chapter II, a study is presented that aimed to identify the consequences of disrupted synchrony between colony phenology and the local environment by manipulating the timing of brood onset after hibernation. In a follow-up experiment, the importance of environmental factors for the timing of brood onset was investigated to assess the potential of climate change to disrupt synchronization of colony phenology (Chapter III). Chapter IV aimed to prove for the first time that honey bees can use interval time-place learning to improve foraging activity in a variable environment. Chapter V investigates the fitness benefits of information exchange between nest mates via waggle dance communication about a resource environment that is heterogeneous in space and time.
II. In the study presented in chapter II, the importance of the timing of brood onset after hibernation as critical point in honey bee colony phenology in temperate zones was investigated. Honey bee colonies were overwintered at two climatically different sites. By translocating colonies from each site to the other in late winter, timing of brood onset was manipulated and consequently colony phenology was desynchronized with the local environment. Delaying colony phenology in respect to the local environment decreased the capability of colonies to exploit the abundant spring bloom. Early brood onset, on the other hand, increased the loads of the brood parasite Varroa destructor later in the season with negative impact on colony worker population size. This indicates a timing related trade-off and illustrates the importance of investigating effects of climate change on complex multi-trophic systems. It can be concluded that timing of brood onset in honey bees is an important fitness relevant step for colony phenology that is highly sensitive to climatic conditions in late winter. Further, phenology shifts and mismatches driven by climate change can have severe fitness consequences.
III. In chapter III, I assess the importance of the environmental factors ambient temperature and photoperiod as well as elapsed time on the timing of brood onset. Twenty-four hibernating honey bee colonies were placed into environmental chambers and allocated to different combinations of two temperature regimes and three different light regimes. Brood onset was identified non-invasively by tracking comb temperature within the winter cluster. The experiment revealed that ambient temperature plays a major role in the timing of brood onset, but the response of honey bee colonies to temperature increases is modified by photoperiod. Further, the data indicate the involvement of an internal clock. I conclude that the timing of brood onset is complex but probably highly susceptible to climate change and especially spells of warm weather in winter.
IV. In chapter IV, it was examined if honey bees are capable of interval time-place learning and if this ability improves foraging efficiency in a dynamic resource environment. In a field experiment with artificial feeders, foragers were able to learn time intervals and use this ability to anticipate time periods during which feeders were active. Further, interval time-place learning enabled foragers to increase nectar uptake rates. It was concluded that interval time-place learning can help honey bee foragers to adapt to the complex and variable temporal patterns of floral resource environments.
V. The study presented in chapter V identified the importance of the honey bee waggle dance communication for the spatiotemporal coordination of honey bee foraging activity in resource environments that can vary from day to day. Consequences of disrupting the instructional component of honey bee dance communication were investigated in eight temperate zone landscapes with different levels of spatiotemporal complexity. While nectar uptake of colonies was not affected, waggle dance communication significantly benefitted pollen harvest irrespective of landscape complexity. I suggest that this is explained by the fact that honey bees prefer to forage pollen in semi-natural habitats, which provide diverse resource species but are sparse and presumably hard to find in intensively managed agricultural landscapes. I conclude that waggle dance communication helps to ensure a sufficient and diverse pollen diet which is crucial for honey bee colony health.
VI. In my PhD-project, I could show that honey bee colonies are able to adapt their activities to a seasonally and daily changing environment, which affects resource uptake, colony development, colony health and ultimately colony fitness. Ongoing global change, however, puts timing in honey bee colonies at risk. Climate change has the potential to cause mismatches with the local resource environment. Intensivation of agricultural management with decreased resource diversity and short resource peaks in spring followed by distinctive gaps increases the probability of mismatches. Even the highly efficient foraging system of honey bees might not ensure a sufficiently diverse and healthy diet in such an environment. The global introduction of the parasitic mite V. destructor and the increased exposure to pesticides in intensively managed landscapes further degrades honey bee colony health. This might lead to reduced cognitive capabilities in workers and impact the communication and social organization in colonies, thereby undermining the ability of honey bee colonies to adapt to their environment.
Division of labor represents a major advantage of social insect communities that accounts for their enormous ecological success. In colonies of the honeybee, Apis mellifera, division of labor comprises different tasks of fertile queens and drones (males) and, in general, sterile female workers. Division of labor also occurs among workers in form of an age-related polyethism. This helps them to deal with the great variety of tasks within the colony. After adult eclosion, workers spend around three weeks with various duties inside the hive such as tending the brood or cleaning and building cells. After this period workers switch to outdoor tasks and become foragers collecting nectar, pollen and water. With this behavioral transition, workers face tremendous changes in their sensory environment. In particular, visual sensory stimuli become important, but also the olfactory world changes. Foragers have to perform a completely new behavioral repertoire ranging from long distance navigation based on landmark orientation and polarized-skylight information to learning and memory tasks associated with finding profitable food sources. However, behavioral maturation is not a purely age-related internal program associated with a change, for example, in juvenile hormone titers. External factors such as primer pheromones like the brood pheromone or queen mandibular pheromone can modulate the timing of this transition. In this way colonies are able to flexibly adjust their work force distribution between indoor and outdoor tasks depending on the actual needs of the colony. Besides certain physiological changes, mainly affecting glandular tissue, the transition from indoor to outdoor tasks requires significant adaptations in sensory and higher-order integration centers of the brain.
The mushroom bodies integrate olfactory, visual, gustatory and mechanosensory information. Furthermore, they play important roles in learning and memory processes. It is therefore not surprising that the mushroom bodies, in particular their main input region, the calyx, undergo volumetric neuronal plasticity. Similar to behavioral maturation, plastic changes of the mushroom bodies are associated with age, but are also to be affected by modulating factors such as task and experience.
In my thesis, I analyzed in detail the neuronal processes underlying volumetric plasticity in the mushroom body. Immunohistochemical labeling of synaptic proteins combined with quantitative 3D confocal imaging revealed that the volume increase of the mushroom body calyx is largely caused by the growth of the Kenyon cell dendritic network. This outgrowth is accompanied by changes in the synaptic architecture of the mushroom body calyx, which is organized in a distinct pattern of synaptic complexes, so called microglomeruli. During the first week of natural adult maturation microglomeruli remain constant in total number. With subsequent behavioral transition from indoor duties to foraging, microglomeruli are pruned while the Kenyon cell dendritic network is still growing. As a result of these processes, the mushroom body calyx neuropil volume enlarges while the total number of microgloumeruli becomes reduced in foragers compared to indoor workers. In the visual subcompartments (calyx collar) this process is induced by visual sensory stimuli as the beginning of pruning correlates with the time window when workers start their first orientation flights. The high level of analysis of cellular and subcellular process underlying structural plasticity of the mushroom body calyx during natural maturation will serve as a framework for future investigations of behavioral plasticity in the honeybee.
The transition to foraging is not purely age-dependent, but gets modulated, for example, by the presence of foragers. Ethyl oleate, a primer pheromone that is present only in foragers, was shown to delay the onset of foraging in nurse bees. Using artificial application of additional ethyl oleate in triple cohort colonies, I tested whether it directly affects adult neuronal plasticity in the visual input region of the mushroom body calyx. As the pheromonal treatment failed to induce a clear behavioral phenotype (delayed onset of foraging) it was not possible to show a direct link between the exposure to additional ethyl oleate and neuronal plasticity in mushroom body calyx. However, the general results on synaptic maturation confirmed my data of natural maturation processes in the mushroom body calyx.
Given the result that dendritic plasticity is a major contributor to neuronal plasticity in the mushroom body calyx associated with division of labor, the question arose which proteins could be involved in mediating these effects. Calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII) especially in mammals, but also in insects (Drosophila, Cockroach), was shown to be involved in facilitating learning and memory processes like long-term synaptic potentiation. In addition to presynaptic effects, the protein was also revealed to directly interact with cytoskeleton elements in the postsynapse. It therefore is a likely candidate to mediate structural synaptic plasticity. As part of my thesis, the presence and distribution of CaMKII was analyzed, and the results showed that the protein is highly concentrated in a distinct subpopulation of the mushroom body intrinsic neurons, the noncompact Kenyon cells. The dendritic network of this population arborizes in two calyx subregions: one receiving mainly olfactory input – the lip – and the collar receiving visual input. This distribution pattern did not change with age or task. The high concentration of CaMKII in dendritic spines and its overlap with f-actin indicates that CaMKII could be a key player inducing structural neuronal plasticity associated with learning and memory formation and/or behavioral transitions related to division of labor. Interestingly CaMKII immunoreactivity was absent in the basal ring, another subregion of the mushroom body calyx formed almost exclusively by the inner compact Kenyon cells and known to receive combined visual and olfactory input. This indicates differences of this mushroom body subregion regarding the molecular mechanisms controlling plastic changes in corresponding Kenyon cells.
How is timing of behavioral and neuronal plasticity regulated? The primer pheromone ethyl oleate was found in high concentrations on foragers and was shown to influence behavioral maturation by delaying the onset of foraging when artificially applied in elevated concentrations. But how is ethyl oleate transferred and how does it shift the work force distribution between indoor and outdoor tasks? Previous work showed that ethyl oleate concentrations are highest in the honeycrop of foragers and suggested that it is transferred and communicated inside the colony via trophallaxis. The results of this thesis however clearly show, that ethyl oleate was not present inside the honey crop or the regurgitate, but rather in the surrounding tissue of the honey crop. As additionally the second highest concentration of ethyl oleate was measured on the surface of the cuticle of forgers, trophallaxis was ruled out as a mode of transmission. Neurophysiological measurements at the level of the antennae (electroantennogram recordings) and the first olfactory neuropil (calcium imaging of activity in the antennal lobe) revealed that the primer pheromone ethyl oleate is received and processed as an olfactory stimulus. Appetitive olfactory conditioning using the proboscis extension response as a behavioral paradigm showed that ethyl oleate can be associated with a sugar reward. This indicates that workers are able to perceive, learn and memorize the presence of this pheromone. As ethyl oleate had to be presented by a heated stimulation device at close range, it can be concluded that this primer pheromone acts via close range/contact chemoreception through the olfactory system. This is also supported by previous behavioral observations.
Taken together, the findings presented in this thesis revealed structural changes in the synaptic architecture of the mushroom body calyx associated with division of labor. For the primer pheromone ethyl oleate, which modulates the transition from nursing to foraging, the results clearly showed that it is received via the olfactory system and presumably acts via this pathway. However, manipulation experiments did not indicate a direct effect of ethyl oleate on synaptic plasticity. At the molecular level, CaMKII is a prime candidate to mediate structural synaptic plasticity in the mushroom body calyx. Future combined structural and functional experiments are needed to finally link the activity of primer pheromones like ethyl oleate to the molecular pathways mediating behavioral and synaptic plasticity associated with division of labor in Apis mellifera. The here identified underlying processes will serve as excellent models for a general understanding of fundamental mechanisms promoting behavioral plasticity.
The Dual Olfactory Pathway in the Honeybee Brain: Sensory Supply and Electrophysiological Properties
(2018)
The olfactory sense is of utmost importance for honeybees, Apis mellifera. Honeybees use olfaction for communication within the hive, for the identification of nest mates and non-nest mates, the localization of food sources, and in case of drones (males), for the detection of the queen and mating. Honeybees, therefore, can serve as excellent model systems for an integrative analysis of an elaborated olfactory system.
To efficiently filter odorants out of the air with their antennae, honeybees possess a multitude of sensilla that contain the olfactory sensory neurons (OSN). Three types of olfactory sensilla are known from honeybee worker antennae: Sensilla trichoidea, Sensilla basiconica and Sensilla placodea. In the sensilla, odorant receptors that are located in the dendritic arborizations of the OSNs transduce the odorant information into electrical information. Approximately 60.000 OSN axons project in two parallel bundles along the antenna into the brain. Before they enter the primary olfactory brain center, the antennal lobe (AL), they diverge into four distinct tracts (T1-T4). OSNs relay onto ~3.000-4.000 local interneurons (LN) and ~900 projection neurons (PN), the output neurons of the AL. The axons of the OSNs together with neurites from LNs and PNs form spheroidal neuropil units, the so-called glomeruli. OSN axons from the four AL input tracts (T1-T4) project into four glomerular clusters. LNs interconnect the AL glomeruli, whereas PNs relay the information to the next brain centers, the mushroom body (MB) - associated with sensory integration, learning and memory - and the lateral horn (LH). In honeybees, PNs project to the MBs and the LH via two separate tracts, the medial and the lateral antennal-lobe tract (m/lALT) which run in parallel in opposing directions. The mALT runs first to the MB and then to the LH, the lALT runs first to the LH and then to the MB. This dual olfactory pathway represents a feature unique to Hymenoptera. Interestingly, both tracts were shown to process information about similar sets of odorants by extracting different features. Individual mALT PNs are more odor specific than lALT PNs. On the other hand, lALT PNs have higher spontaneous and higher odor response action potential (AP) frequencies than mALT PNs. In the MBs, PNs form synapses with ~184.000 Kenyon cells (KC), which are the MB intrinsic neurons. KCs, in contrast to PNs, show almost no spontaneous activity and employ a spatially and temporally sparse code for odor coding.
In manuscript I of my thesis, I investigated whether the differences in specificity of odor responses between m- and lALT are due to differences in the synaptic input. Therefore, I investigated the axonal projection patterns of OSNs housed in S. basiconica in honeybee workers and compared them with S. trichoidea and S. placodea using selective anterograde labeling with fluorescent tracers and confocal- microscopy analyses of axonal projections in AL glomeruli. Axons of S. basiconica-associated OSNs preferentially projected into the T3 input-tract cluster in the AL, whereas the two other types of sensilla did not show a preference for a specific glomerular cluster. T3- associated glomeruli had previously been shown to be innervated by mALT PNs. Interestingly, S. basiconica as well as a number of T3 glomeruli lack in drones. Therefore I set out to determine whether this was associated with the reduction of glomeruli innervated by mALT PNs. Retrograde tracing of mALT PNs in drones and counting of innervated glomeruli showed that the number of mALT-associated glomeruli was strongly reduced in drones compared to workers. The preferential projections of S. basiconica-associated OSNs into T3 glomeruli in female workers together with the reduction of mALT-associated glomeruli in drones support the presence of a female-specific olfactory subsystem that is partly innervated by OSNs from S. basiconica and is associated with mALT projection neurons. As mALT PNs were shown to be more odor specific, I suppose that already the OSNs in this subsystem are more odor specific than lALT associated OSNs. I conclude that this female-specific subsystem allows the worker honeybees to respond adequately to the enormous variety of odorants they experience during their lifetime.
In manuscript II, I investigated the ion channel composition of mALT and lALT PNs and KCs in situ. This approach represents the first study dealing with the honeybee PN and KC ion channel composition under standard conditions in an intact brain preparation. With these recordings I set out to investigate the potential impact of intrinsic neuronal properties on the differences between m- and lALT PNs and on the sparse odor coding properties of KCs. In PNs, I identified a set of Na+ currents and diverse K+ currents depending on voltage and Na+ or Ca2+ that support relatively high spontaneous and odor response AP frequencies. This set of currents did not significantly differ between mALT and lALT PNs, but targets for potential modulation of currents leading to differences in AP frequencies were found between both types of PNs. In contrast to PNs, KCs have very prominent K+ currents, which are likely to contribute to the sparse response fashion observed in KCs. Furthermore, Ca2+ dependent K+ currents were found, which may be of importance for coincidence detection, learning and memory formation.
Finally, I conclude that the differences in odor specificity between m- and lALT PNs are due to their synaptic input from different sets of OSNs and potential processing by LNs. The differences in spontaneous activity between the two tracts may be caused by different neuronal modulation or, in addition, also by interaction with LNs. The temporally sparse representation of odors in KCs is very likely based on the intrinsic KC properties, whereas general excitability and spatial sparseness are likely to be regulated through GABAergic feedback neurons.
In dieser Arbeit untersuche ich das Verhalten von Arbeiterbienen beim Brutwärmen, die Wärmeübertragung von den Bienen auf die gedeckelte Brut, die thermophysikalischen Eigenschaften des Brutnests und spezielle Aspekte des Brutnestaufbaus, die für dieses Thema relevant sind und bisher nicht untersucht wurden. Meine Arbeit umfasst Verhaltensbeobachtungen und thermografische Messungen an individuellen Bienen, die Simulation des Heizverhaltens von Arbeiterinnen und das Messen der Temperaturänderungen in der Wabe, die Messung der thermophysikalischen Eigenschaften der Brutwabe und der Zellwände (Wärmeleitfähigkeit und Durchlässigkeit für Wärmestrahlung), die Auswertung von Brutzelltemperaturen als Ergebnis des Verhaltens von Arbeiterbienen, die Analyse der Anzahl und der räumlichen Verteilung von Brutlücken (Auswertung in 2-D und 3-D bezüglich beider Wabenseiten) und die Entwicklung spezifischer Computersoftware, die zur Erarbeitung dieser Ergebnisse unverzichtbar ist. Ein wichtiges Ergebnis dieser Arbeit ist die Entdeckung und Beschreibung eines bemerkenswerten, bislang unbekannten Verhaltens der Honigbiene: Die Aufrechterhaltung hoher Thoraxtemperaturen (TTh) bei Langzeitbesuchen in offenen Zellen („Lücken“) die verstreut in der gedeckelten Brutfläche vorkommen. Hier zeige ich, dass die Aufrechterhaltung der hohen TTh nicht auf den Zellinhalt (z. B. offene Brut) bezogen ist - in den meisten Fällen waren die besuchten Zellen ohnehin leer - sondern auf die direkt benachbarte gedeckelte Brut, mit der diese Zellen über gemeinsame Zellwände in Kontakt stehen. Dieses Verhalten liefert eine Erklärung für Langzeitzellbesuche von sehr langer Dauer ohne erkennbare Aktivität, die in früheren Arbeiten beschrieben aber nicht völlig verstanden wurden, und es rehabilitiert die scheinbar „faulen“ Bienen im Zellinnern. Diesem Verhalten kommt eine große Bedeutung für das Brutwärmen zu, da sich der aufgeheizte Thorax tief in der Wabe (fast an der Mittelwand) befindet wo der Wärmeverlust an die Luft minimiert ist und von wo bis zu 6 umliegende Puppenzellen gleichzeitig gewärmt werden können. Im Vergleich zum Brutwärmeverhalten an der Wabenoberfläche (Andrücken des Thorax an die Brutdeckel), wo nur 1 oder Teile von 3 Brutdeckeln mit dem Thorax in Berührung stehen, ist das Wärmen im Zellinnern mit derselben TTh bis zu 2,6-fach effizienter. Die Messung der thermophysikalischen Eigenschaften der Brutwabe und die Simulation des Brutwärmeverhaltens unter kontrollierten Bedingungen zeigen, dass sich die Wabe langsam aufwärmt und eher ein lokal begrenztes Wärmen als eine rasche Wärmeausbreitung über eine große Fläche begünstigt. Der Einflussbereich eines einzelnen Zellbesuchers hängt von seiner TTh und der Dauer des Zellbesuchs ab. Anstiege der Bruttemperatur in bis zu 3 Zellen Abstand zum Zellbesucher sind nachweisbar. Das hier beschriebene Brutwärmeverhalten im Innern von Lücken (offenen Zellen) bietet nicht nur neue Einsichten in das Bienenverhalten. Es ermöglicht auch eine Neubewertung der Lücken und ihrer Nützlichkeit für die Bienen. Eine von mir entwickelte Computersoftware („CombUse 2.0“) ermöglicht es, das Vorkommen und die räumliche Verteilung von Lücken mit hoher Genauigkeit auf der Ebene einzelner Zellen zu erfassen und auszuwerten. Die räumliche Verteilung der Lücken in der gedeckelten Brutfläche zeigt, dass schon bei geringen Lückenhäufigkeiten von ca. 4 bis 10 %, die in gesunden Kolonien normal sind, eine überraschend große Zahl gedeckelter Brutzellen (88 % bis 99 %, wenn die dreidimensionale Verteilung berücksichtigt wird) im Einflussbereich von Brut wärmenden Zellbesuchern sind. Obwohl das Brutwärmeverhalten im Zellinnern schwer zu entdecken und zu beobachten ist, führen die in dieser Arbeit präsentierten Daten zu dem Schluss, dass es sich dabei um einen wichtigen Bestandteil der Nestklimatisierung bei Honigbienen handelt.
For all animals the cold represents a dreadful danger. In the event of severe heat loss, animals
fall into a chill coma. If this state persists, it is inevitably followed by death. In poikilotherms
(e.g. insects), the optimal temperature range is narrow compared to homeotherms
(e.g. mammals), resulting in a critical core temperature being reached more quickly. As a
consequence, poikilotherms either had to develop survival strategies, migrate or die. Unlike
the majority of insects, the Western honeybee (Apis mellifera) is able to organize itself into
a superorganism. In this process, worker bees warm and cool the colony by coordinated
use of their flight muscles. This enables precise control of the core temperature in the hive,
analogous to the core body temperature in homeothermic animals. However, to survive the
harsh temperatures in the northern hemisphere, the thermogenic mechanism of honeybees
must be in constant readiness. This mechanism is called shivering thermogenesis, in which
honeybees generate heat using their flight muscles.
My thesis presents the molecular and neurochemical background underlying shivering thermogenesis
in worker honeybees. In this context, I investigated biogenic amine signaling.
I found that the depletion of vesicular monoamines impairs thermogenesis, resulting in
a decrease in thoracic temperature. Subsequent investigations involving various biogenic
amines showed that octopamine can reverse this effect. This clearly indicates the involvement
of the octopaminergic system. Proceeding from these results, the next step was to elucidate
the honeybee thoracic octopaminergic system. This required a multidisciplinary approach to
ultimately provide profound insights into the function and action of octopamine at the flight
muscles. This led to the identification of octopaminergic flight muscle controlling neurons,
which presumably transport octopamine to the flight muscle release sites. These neurons
most likely innervate octopamine β receptors and their activation may stimulate intracellular
glycolytic pathways, which ensure sufficient energy supply to the muscles.
Next, I examined the response of the thoracic octopaminergic system to cold stress conditions.
I found that the thoracic octopaminergic system tends towards an equilibrium,
even though the initial stress response leads to fluctuations of octopamine signaling. My
results indicate the importance of the neuro-muscular octopaminergic system and thus the need for its robustness. Moreover, cold sensitivity was observed for the expression of one
transcript of the octopamine receptor gene AmOARβ2. Furthermore, I found that honeybees
without colony context show a physiological disruption within the octopaminergic system.
This disruption has profound effects on the honeybees protection against the cold.
I could show how important the neuro-muscular octopaminergic system is for thermogenesis
in honeybees. In this context, the previously unknown neurochemical modulation of the
honeybee thorax has now been revealed. I also provide a broad basis to conduct further
experiments regarding honeybee thermogenesis and muscle physiology.
Non-target effects of a multiple insect resistant Bt-maize on the honey bee (Apis mellifera L.)
(2011)
Honey bee pollination is an ecologically and economically important ecosystem service. New methodological developments are needed to research the underlying factors of globally observed bee losses. The honey bee (Apis mellifera) is a key non-target arthropod species for environmental risk assessment of genetically modified (GM) crops. For GM-crop risk assessments, mainly methods for monitoring adult honey bees under laboratory conditions are documented. However, protocols with robust methods for standardized colonies or in vitro reared honey bee larvae are currently lacking. Within the research, presented in this this dissertation, multiple methodological developments are achieved; a mortality trap (Chapter II), a ‘full life cycle test’ (III), a novel in vitro rearing methodology (IV), a standardized in vitro test for Bt-pollen (V), a mixed toxicity test for purified transgenic proteins (VI), and a bacterial flora test with pollen digestion rate monitoring (VII). Overall, the studies did not indicate a detrimental effect caused by Bt-maize pollen, or by purified Bt-proteins at worst case exposure levels. Considering the risk for honey bees and larvae, we conclude that the tested Bt-maize Mon89034xMon88017 is not likely to cause harm to honey bee colonies. The study methods presented are highly recommended for future environmental risk assessment studies testing GM-crop biosafety on honey bees.
Soziale Insekten wie die Honigbiene (Apis mellifera) besitzen ein breites Spektrum an Abwehrmechanismen gegen Pathogenbefall, sowohl auf der Ebene der Kolonie (soziale Immunität) als auch auf der Stufe des Individuums (angeborenes Immunsystem). Die Hauptaufgabe der relativ kurzlebigen Drohnen besteht in der Begattung von Jungköniginnen. Daher stellte sich die Frage, ob auch die Drohnen ähnlich den Arbeiterinnen mit energieaufwendigen Immunreaktionen auf Infektionen reagieren. Wie im Folgenden beschrieben, konnte ich nachweisen, dass Drohnen eine ausgeprägte Immunkompetenz besitzen. Das angeborene Immunsystem setzt sich aus humoralen und zellulären Abwehrreaktionen zusammen. Bei der humoralen Immunantwort werden bestimmte evolutionär konservierte Signalkaskaden aktiviert, an deren Ende die Expression einer Vielzahl von antimikrobiellen Peptiden (AMPs) und immunspezifischen Proteinen (IRPs) steht. Zur Analyse der humoralen Immunantwort wurden von mir zum einen Hemmhoftests durchgeführt, um die gesamte antimikrobielle Aktivität der Haemolymphe nach artifizieller Infektion zu ermitteln und zum anderen spezifische AMPs bzw. IRPs identifiziert. Hierzu wurden die Haemolymphproteine in ein- oder zwei-dimensionalen Polyacrylamidgelen aufgetrennt und ausgewählte Proteinbanden bzw. -spots mittels nano HPLC/Massenspektrometrie analysiert. Die Hauptkomponenten des zellulären Immunsystems sind Wundheilung, Phagozytose, Einkapselung und Nodulation. In meiner Arbeit habe ich zum ersten Mal Noduli bei infizierten Drohnen nachweisen können. Frisch geschlüpfte adulte Drohnen (1d) weisen ein breites Spektrum an Immunreaktionen auf, das sowohl humorale als auch zelluläre Immunantworten umfasst. Nach Infektion mit dem Gram-negativen Bakterium E.coli und verschiedenen bakteriellen Zellwandbestandteilen wie Lipopolysaccharid (LPS), Peptidoglycan (PGN) und 1,3ß-Glucan (Bestandteil von Pilzzellwänden), werden die AMPs Hymenoptaecin, Defensin 1 und Abaecin induziert. Desweiteren exprimieren junge adulte Drohnen eine Reihe hochmolekularer immunspezifischer Proteine (IRPs) wie z.B. Carboxylesterase (CE 1), eine Serinprotease, die möglicherweise an der Prozessierung der Prophenoloxidase beteiligt ist, ein Peptidoglycan-interagierendes Protein (PGRP-S2) und zwei Proteine unbekannter Funktion, IRp42 und IRp30. Parallel zu bekannten bienenspezifischen AMPs wurde ein animales Peptidtoxin (APT) in Drohnenlarven, adulten Drohnen und adulten Hummeln nach E.coli Infektion in der Haemolymphe nachgewiesen. Von dem als OCLP 1 (ω-conotoxin-like protein 1) benannten Peptid war bereits bekannt, dass es in Fischen paralytische und damit toxische Effekte auslöst. Meine Beobachtungen lassen vermuten, dass es sich bei OCLP 1 um ein Peptidtoxin mit antimikrobiellen Eigenschaften und damit um eine neue Klasse von AMPs handelt. Die allgemeine humorale Immunkompetenz scheint während der gesamten Lebensspanne adulter Drohnen (~ 7 Wochen) konstant zu bleiben, wie durch die gleichbleibende antimikrobielle Aktivität im Hemmhoftest gezeigt wurde. Junge Drohnen reagieren auf eine E.coli Infektion mit der Bildung zahlreicher Noduli (~1000 Noduli/Drohn), die vor allem entlang des Herzschlauches zu finden sind. Diese zelluläre Immunantwort nimmt mit dem Alter der Drohnen ab, so dass bei 18 d alten Drohnen nur noch rund 10 Noduli/Drohn gefunden werden. Auf der anderen Seite nimmt die phagozytotische Aktivität bei älteren Drohnen scheinbar zu. In einer Reihe von parallel laufenden Versuchsreihen konnte ich eindrucksvoll zeigen, dass zelluläre Immunreaktionen wie Phagozytose und Nodulation unmittelbar nach bakterieller Infektion einsetzen. Hierbei erreicht die Nodulibildung 8-10 h p.i. eine Plateauphase, wohingegen die humorale Immunantwort erst 6 h p.i. schwach einsetzt, danach stetig zunimmt und noch 72 h p.i. nachweisbar ist. Es ist mir gelungen, eine Methode zur künstlichen Aufzucht von Drohnenlarven zu etablieren. Diese ermöglichte konstante und sterile Versuchsbedingungen zur Untersuchung der Immunreaktionen von Larven. Nach Infektion mit E.coli reagieren Drohnenlarven mit einer starken Aktivierung ihrer humoralen Immunantwort durch die Expression von AMPs, jedoch werden keine hochmolekularen IRPs wie in adulten Drohnen hochreguliert. Zudem ist die Nodulibildung in Larven nur schwach ausgeprägt. Völlig unerwartete Beobachtungen wurden beim Studium der Immunkompetenz von Drohnenpuppen gemacht. Nach Injektion lebender E.coli Zellen in Drohnenpuppen stellte ich eine dramatische Veränderung im Aussehen der Puppen fest. Die Puppen verfärbten sich gräulich schwarz. Genauere Untersuchungen haben dann gezeigt, dass die Drohnenpuppen, wie auch die der Arbeiterinnen, offensichtlich keine zelluläre Abwehrreaktion aktivieren können und die humorale Immunantwort nur sehr schwach ausfällt und viel zu spät einsetzt.