Refine
Has Fulltext
- yes (8)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (8)
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (8)
Language
- English (8) (remove)
Keywords
- Adipogenesis (1)
- Adipose Tissue Engineering (1)
- Biomaterial (1)
- Bioreactor (1)
- Bone (1)
- Bone marrow stromal cell (BMSC) (1)
- Bone regeneration (1)
- Co-culture system (1)
- Differentiation (1)
- Fettgewebe (1)
Institute
Sonstige beteiligte Institutionen
Regulating and reverting the adipo-osteogenic lineage decision of trabecular human bone marrow stromal cells (hBMSCs) represents a promising approach for osteoporosis therapy and prevention. Fibroblast growth factor 1 (FGF1) and its subfamily member FGF2 were scored as lead candidates to exercise control over lineage switching processes (conversion) in favor of osteogenesis previously. However, their impact on differentiation events is controversially discussed in literature. Hence, the present study aimed to investigate the effects of these FGFs on the adipogenic and osteogenic differentiation and conversion of primary hBMSCs. Moreover, involved downstream signaling mechanisms should be elucidated and, finally, the results should be evaluated with regard to the possible therapeutic approach.
This study clearly revealed that culture in the presence of FGF1 strongly prevented the adipogenic differentiation of hBMSCs as well as the adipogenic conversion of pre-differentiated osteoblastic cells. Lipid droplet formation was completely inhibited by a concentration of 25 ng/µL. Meanwhile, the expression of genetic markers for adipogenic initiation, peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma 2 (PPARg2) and CCAAT/enhancer binding protein alpha (C/EBPa), as well as subsequent adipocyte maturation, fatty acid binding protein 4 (FABP4) and lipoprotein lipase (LPL), were significantly downregulated. Yet, the genetic markers of osteogenic commitment and differentiation were not upregulated during adipogenic differentiation and conversion under FGF supplementation, not supporting an event of osteogenic lineage switching.
Moreover, when examining the effects on the osteogenic differentiation of hBMSCs and the osteogenic conversion of pre-differentiated adipocytic cells, culture in the presence of FGF1 markedly decreased extracellular matrix (ECM) mineralization. Additionally, the gene expression of the osteogenic marker alkaline phosphatase (ALP) was significantly reduced and ALP enzyme activity was decreased. Furthermore, genetic markers of osteogenic commitment, like the master regulator runt-related transcription factor 2 (RUNX2) and bone morphogenetic protein 4 (BMP4), as well as markers of osteogenic differentiation and ECM formation, like collagen 1 A1 (COL1A1) and integrin-binding sialoprotein (IBSP), were downregulated. In contrast, genes known to inhibit ECM mineralization, like ANKH inorganic pyrophosphate transport regulator (ANKH) and osteopontin (OPN), were upregulated. ANKH inhibition revealed that its transcriptional elevation was not crucial for the reduced matrix mineralization, perhaps due to decreased expression of ectonucleotide pyrophosphatase/phosphodiesterase 1 (ENPP1) that likely annulled ANKH upregulation. Like FGF1, also the culture in the presence of FGF2 displayed a marked anti-adipogenic and anti-osteogenic effect.
The FGF receptor 1 (FGFR1) was found to be crucial for mediating the described FGF effects in adipogenic and osteogenic differentiation and conversion. Yet, adipogenic conversion displayed a lower involvement of the FGFR1. For adipogenic differentiation and osteogenic differentiation/conversion, downstream signal transduction involved the extracellular signal-regulated kinases 1 and 2 (ERK1/2) and the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK)/ERK kinases 1 and 2 (MEK1/2), probably via the phosphorylation of FGFR docking protein FGFR substrate 2a (FRS2a) and its effector Ras/MAPK. The c-Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK), p38-MAPK, and protein kinase C (PKC) were not crucial for the signal transduction, yet were in part responsible for the rate of adipogenic and/or osteogenic differentiation itself, in line with current literature.
Taken together, to the best of our knowledge, our study was the first to describe the strong impact of FGF1 and FGF2 on both the adipogenic and osteogenic differentiation and conversion processes of primary hBMSCs in parallel. It clearly revealed that although both FGFs were not able to promote the differentiation and lineage switching towards the osteogenic fate, they strongly prevented adipogenic differentiation and lineage switching, which seem to be elevated during osteoporosis. Our findings indicate that FGF1 and FGF2 entrapped hBMSCs in a pre-committed state. In conclusion, these agents could be applied to potently prevent unwanted adipogenesis in vitro. Moreover, our results might aid in unraveling a pharmacological control point to eliminate the increased adipogenic differentiation and conversion as potential cause of adipose tissue accumulation and decreased osteoblastogenesis in bone marrow during aging and especially in osteoporosis.
Critical size bone defects and nonunion fractures remain difficult to treat. Although cell‐loaded bone substitutes have improved bone ingrowth and formation, the lack of methods for achieving viability and the uniform distribution of cells in the scaffold limits their use as bone grafts. In addition, the predominant mechanical stimulus that drives early osteogenic cell maturation has not been clearly identified. Further, it is challenging to evaluate mechanical stimuli (i.e., deformation and fluid–flow-induced shear stress) because they are interdependent. This thesis compares different mechanical stimuli applied to cell-seeded scaffolds to develop bone grafts efficiently for the treatment of critical size bone defects. It also seeks to understand how deformation strain and interstitial fluid–flow-induced shear stress promote osteogenic lineage commitment. In this thesis, different scaffolds were seeded with primary human bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (BM-MSCs) from different donors and subjected to static and dynamic culture conditions. In contrast with the static culture conditions, homogenous cell distributions were accomplished under dynamic culture conditions. Additionally, the induction of osteogenic lineage commitment without the addition of soluble factors was observed in the bioreactor system after one week of cell culture. To determine the role of mechanical stimuli, a bioreactor was developed to apply mechanical deformation force to a mesenchymal stem sell (MSC) line (telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT)) expressing a strain-responsive AP-1 luciferase reporter construct on porous scaffolds. Increased luciferase expression was observed in the deformation strain compared with the shear stress strain. Furthermore, the expression of osteogenic lineage commitment markers such as osteonectin, osteocalcin (OC), osteopontin, runt-related transcription factor 2 (RUNX2), alkaline phosphate (AP), and collagen type 1 was significantly downregulated in the shear stress strain compared with the deformation strain. These findings establish that the deformation strain was the predominant stimulus causing skeletal precursors to undergo osteogenesis in earlier stages of osteogenic cell maturation. Finally, these findings were used to develop a bioreactor in vitro test system in which the effect of medication on osteoporosis could be tested. Primary human BM-MSCs from osteoporotic donors were subjected to strontium ranelate (an osteoporotic drug marketed as Protelos®). Increased expression of collagen type 1 and calcification was seen in the drugtreated osteoporotic stem cells compared with the nondrug-treated osteoporotic stem cells. Thus, this bioreactor technology can easily be adapted into an in vitro osteoporotic drug testing system.
Mesenchymal stem/stromal cells (MSCs) are a rare subpopulation of cells first identified in bone marrow with the potential to proliferate in plastic-adherent colonies and to generate de novo bone marrow stroma and its environment upon serial transplantation to heterotopic anatomical sites. Given their multipotency and self renewal competence, MSCs are prime prospective candidates for most modern musculoskeletal-tissue engineering and regenerative medicine approaches. Still, their envisioned therapeutic use is being questioned with concerns regarding their definition, characterization and integrative functions in vivo. It is well established that microenvironmental cues such as the extracellular matrix (ECM)-chemistry, the mechanical environment and local cellular and/or paracrine interactions critically control MSCs behavior. Yet, most of the scientific knowledge regarding the biology and therapeutic effect of MSCs originates from mechanistic in vitro studies where microenvironmental cues are hardly addressed. Therefore, manifestable changes in cell proliferation behavior and multilineage differentiation potential might be triggered that eventually compromise the translation of results to clinics. This thesis aims to address the complexity of MSCs interactions within the skeletal niche microenvironment in order to provide alternative methods to bypass the current MSCs in vitro culture limitations. Firstly, the influence of ECM-chemistry on MSCs behavior in vitro was explored by means of decellularized human bone models here established. Basal or osteogenic tailored cell-derived decellularized 2D matrices (dECM), proved to be suitable culture substrates for MSCs expansion by providing close-to-native cell-ECM interactions. Moreover, quantified morphological shape changes suggested a material osteo supportive potential, further functionally validated by observable spontaneous mineralization of MSCs. Aiming to identify novel intrinsic ECM regulatory features specific to the skeletal niche, 3D decellularized human trabecular bone scaffolds (dBone) were additionally developed and comprehensively characterized. Remarkably, the MSCs cultured on dBone scaffolds exhibit upregulation of genes associated with stemness as well as niche-related protein expression advocating for the conservation of the naïve MSCs phenotype. vi On the other hand, the effect of biomimetic mineralization on MSCs osteogenic lineage differentiation potential was further addressed by hydroxyapatite functionalization of type-I collagen in presence of magnesium. Mineralized scaffolds exhibited higher cell viability and a clear trend of osteogenic genes upregulation comparing with non-mineralized scaffolds. Lastly, in order to mimic the complexity of the native MSCs environment, a dynamic culture system was applied to the 3D decellularized bone constructs, previously studied in single static conditions. Mechanical stimuli generated by (1) continuous perfusion of cell culture medium at 1.7 mL/min and (2) compressive stress from 10% uniaxial load at 1 Hz, resulted in an improved cell repopulation within the scaffold and boosting of de novo ECM production. The stress-induced gene expression pattern suggested early MSCs commitment towards the osteogenic lineage mediated by integrin matrix adhesion, therefore further corroborating the recapitulation of a reliable in vitro bone niche model in dBone scaffolds. To conclude, the here developed in vitro models provide a progressive increased biomimicking complexity through which significant insights regarding MSC interactions with microenvironmental features in the skeletal niche can be obtained, thus surely paving the way for a better understanding of the role of MSCs in bone homeostasis and regeneration.
Autologous bone still represents today’s gold standard for the treatment of critical size bone defects and fracture non-unions despite associated disadvantages regarding limitations in availability, donor site morbidity, costs and efficacy. Bone tissue engineered constructs would present a promising alternative to currently available treatments. However, research on preclinical animal studies still fails to provide clinical applicable results able to allow the replacement of currently applied methods. It seems that the idea of bone tissue engineering, which has now been integral part of academic studies for over 30 years, got somehow stuck at an intermediate level, in between intense preclinical research and striven stages of initial clinical trial phases. A clear discrepancy exists between the number of studies with preclinical animal models for bone tissue engineering and the number of clinically approved bone tissue engineered constructs available to patients.
The aim of this thesis was hence to evaluate preclinical animal models for bone tissue engineering as well as the perception of scientists and clinicians towards these models. Moreover, the general role of bone tissue engineering and its clinical need assessed by scientists and surgeons was investigated. A survey was conducted questioning both scientific and clinical opinions on currently available study designs and researchers’ satisfaction with preclinical animal models. Additionally, a literature research was conducted, resulting in 167 papers from the last 10 years that report current designs of preclinical orthotopic animal studies in bone tissue engineering. Thereby, the focus lied on the description of the models regarding animal species, strain, age, gender and defect design. The outcome of the literature search was evaluated and compared to the outcome obtained from the survey.
The survey data revealed that both scientists and surgeons generally remain positive about the future role of bone tissue engineering and its step to clinical translation, at least in the distant future, where it then might replace the current gold standard, autologous bone. Moreover, most of the participants considered preclinical animal models as relevant and well developed but the results as not yet realizable in the clinics. Surgeons thereby demonstrated a slightly more optimistic perception of currently conducted research with animal models compared to scientists. However, a rather inconsistent description of present preclinical study designs could be discerned when evaluating the reported study designs in the survey and the papers of the literature search.
Indeed, defining an appropriate animal species, strain, age, gender, observation time, observation method and surgical design often depends on different indications and research questions and represents a highly challenging task for the establishment of a preclinical animal model. The existing lack of valid guidelines for preclinical testing of bone tissue engineering leads hence to a lack of well standardized preclinical animal models. Moreover, still existing knowledge gaps regarding aspects that affect the process of fracture healing, such as vascularization or immunological aspects, were found to hinder clinical translation of bone tissue engineered constructs.
Using literature review and survey, this thesis points out critical issues that need to be addressed to allow clinical translation of bone tissue engineered constructs. It can be concluded that currently existing study designs with preclinical animal models cannot live up to the claim of providing suitable results for clinical implementation. The here presented comprehensive summary of currently used preclinical animal models for bone tissue engineering reveals a missing consensus on the usage of models such as an apparent lack of reporting and standardization regarding the study designs described in both papers from the literature review and the survey. It thereby indicates a crucial need to improve preclinical animal models in order to allow clinical translation. Despite the fact that participants of the survey generally revealed a positive perception towards the use of bone tissue engineered constructs and affirmed the clinical need for such novel designs, the missing standardization constitutes a main weak point for the provision of reliable study outcome and the translational success of the models. The optimization of reproducibility and reliability, as well as the further understanding of ongoing mechanisms in bone healing in order to develop effective tissue engineered constructs, need to form the basis of all study designs. The study outcomes might then fulfill the requirements of maybe today's and hopefully tomorrow's aging population.
Kritische Knochendefekte stellen heutzutage ein ungelöstes Problem in der klinischen Praxis dar, da die verfügbaren prothetischen Optionen oft die mechanische Anpassung an das Gewebe nicht gewährleisten oder zu wichtigen immunologischen und Implantat-bedingten Komplikationen führen.
In diesem Kontext ermöglichen Tissue Engineering-Ansätze neue Strategien, um in vitro Zell-Material Interaktionen zu untersuchen und so die Implantatmaterialien zu optimieren.
In dieser Arbeit habe ich Zell-Material Interaktionen eines neuen Kollagen-basierten Scaffolds untersucht, das langfristig als Trägerstruktur für eine zellbasierte Therapie für kritische Knochendefekte entwickelt werden soll. Im Rahmen der Dissertation konnte ich belegen, dass die Kollagen-basierten makroporöse Mikrocarrier für die Zellvermehrung humaner mesenchymaler Stammzellen (MSC) und deren osteogene Differenzierung unter GMP Bedingungen verwendet werden können. Außerdem habe ich die die Kokultur von hämatopoietischen Stammzellen des Knochenmarks und multiplen Myelomzellen funktionell charakterisiert. Ich konnte erstmals Kulturbedingungen etablieren, die die Langzeitkultur ohne die Verwendung von Zytokinen ermöglicht. Mittels dieser Kokultur konnte ich ein Knochenmarknischen-Modell etablieren und die Untersuchung der Expression von zentralen Signalkaskaden der Homöostase dieser Nische untersuchen. Ich konnte die Expression von zwei verschiedenen Isoformen von Osteopontin nachweisen, die in Tiermodellen nicht gefunden werden. Diese Isoformen des Osteopontins habe ich kloniert und die rekombinanten Isoformen exprimiert und ihre Rollen in der Homöostase der Knochenmarknische untersucht.
Critical size bone defects represent nowadays an unresolved problem in the clinical practice, where the available prosthetic options often lack adequate mechanical matching to the host tissue or lead to important immunological and implant-related complications.
In this context, Tissue Engineering approaches promise more effective strategies to study cell-material interactions in vitro and consequently optimize implant materials.
In this work, I investigated the cell-scaffold interactions of a new collagen-based scaffold for a putative cell-based therapy for critical size defects to be developed. In the context of this thesis, I could demonstrate that the collagen-based macroporous microcarriers could be employed for the expansion and osteogenic differentiation of human mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) under GMP-compliant conditions. Moreover, I functionally characterized the co-culture of bone marrow hematopoietic stem cells and multiple myeloma cells. I was for the first time able to establish culture conditions allowing their long-term culture in absence of externally supplemented cytokines. Using this co-culture, I was able to establish a bone marrow niche model to investigate the expression of key signaling pathways involved in the niche´s homeostasis. I was able to demonstrate the expression of two different isoforms of Osteopontin, that could not previously be detected in animal models. Finally, I cloned these Osteopontin isoforms, expressed recombinant versions of the isoforms, and investigated their roles in the homeostasis of the bone marrow niche.