Refine
Has Fulltext
- yes (23)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (23)
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (23)
Keywords
- Angststörung (6)
- Aufmerksamkeit (6)
- Funktionelle Kernspintomografie (4)
- Virtuelle Realität (4)
- fMRI (4)
- Kind (3)
- Kognition (3)
- Soziale Wahrnehmung (3)
- social attention (3)
- Angst (2)
Humans in our environment are of special importance to us. Even if our minds are
fixated on tasks unrelated to their presence, our attention will likely be drawn
towards other people’s appearances and their actions.
While we might remain unaware of this attentional bias at times, various studies have demonstrated the preferred visual scanning of other humans by recording eye movements in laboratory settings. The present thesis aims to investigate the circumstances under and the mechanisms by which this so-called social attention operates.
The first study demonstrates that social features in complex naturalistic scenes are prioritized in an automatic fashion. After 200 milliseconds of stimulus presentation, which is too brief for top-down processing to intervene, participants targeted image areas depicting humans significantly more often than would be expected from a chance distribution of saccades. Additionally, saccades towards these areas occurred earlier in time than saccades towards non-social image regions. In the second study, we show that human features receive most fixations even when bottom-up information is restricted; that is, even when only the fixated region was visible and the remaining parts of the image masked, participants still fixated on social image regions longer than on regions without social cues. The third study compares the influence of real and artificial faces on gaze patterns during the observation of dynamic naturalistic videos. Here we find that artificial faces, belonging to humanlike statues or machines, significantly predicted gaze allocation but to a lesser extent than real faces. In the fourth study, we employed functional magnetic resonance imaging to investigate the neural correlates of reflexive social attention. Analyses of the evoked blood-oxygenation level dependent responses pointed to an involvement of striate and extrastriate visual cortices in the encoding of social feature space.
Collectively, these studies help to elucidate under which circumstances social
features are prioritized in a laboratory setting and how this prioritization might be achieved on a neuronal level. The final experimental chapter addresses the question whether these laboratory findings can be generalized to the real world. In this study, participants were introduced to a waiting room scenario in which they interacted with a confederate. Eye movement analyses revealed that gaze behavior heavily depended on the social context and were influenced by whether an interaction is currently desired. We further did not find any evidence for altered gaze behavior in socially anxious participants. Alleged gaze avoidance or hypervigilance in social
anxiety might thus represent a laboratory phenomenon that occurs only under very specific real-life conditions. Altogether the experiments described in the present
thesis thus refine our understanding of social attention and simultaneously
challenge the inferences we can draw from laboratory research.
Biological Substrates of Waiting Impulsivity in Children and Adolescents with and without ADHD
(2023)
Focus of the present work were the questions whether and how the concept of waiting impulsivity (WI), defined as the ability to regulate a response in anticipation of reward and measured by the 4-choice serial reaction time task (4-CSRTT), may contribute to our understanding of Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and its neurobiological underpinnings.
To address this topic, two studies were conducted: in a first study, the relationship be-tween 4-CSRTT behavioral measures, neural correlates and ADHD symptom domains, i.e. inattention (IA) and hyperactivity/impulsivity (H/I) was explored in a pooled sample of 90 children and adolescents with (n=44) and without (n=46) ADHD diagnosis. As ex-pected, IA was associated with dorsolateral prefrontal brain regions linked with executive functions and attentional control, which was evident on the structural and the functional level. Higher levels of both IA and H/I covaried with decreased activity in the right ven-trolateral prefrontal cortex (PFC), a central structure for response inhibition. Moderation analyses revealed that H/I-related decreased activation in this region did not map linearly on difficulties on the behavioral level: brain activation was a significant predictor of task accuracy only, when H/I symptoms were low/absent but not for clinically relevant ADHD symptoms. Further, H/I was implicated in dysfunctional top-down control of reward eval-uation. Both symptom domains correlated positively with hippocampus (HC) activity in anticipation of reward. In addition, for high H/I symptoms, greater activation in the HC was found to correlate with higher motivation on the behavioral level, indicating that rein-forcement-learning and/or contingency awareness may contribute to altered reward pro-cessing in ADHD patients.
In a second study, the possible serotonergic modulation of WI and the ADHD-WI relation-ship was addressed in a sub-sample comprising 86 children and adolescents of study I. The effects of a functional variant in the gene coding for the rate-limiting enzyme in the synthesis of brain serotonin on behavior and structure or function of the WI-network was investigated. Moderation analyses revealed that on the behavioral level, a negative corre-lation between accuracy and IA was found only in GG-homozygotes, whereas no signifi-cant relationship emerged for carriers of the T-allele. This is in line with previous reports of differential effects of serotonergic modulation on attentional performance depending on the presence of ADHD symptoms. A trend-wise interaction effect of genotype and IA for regional volume of the right middle frontal gyrus was interpreted as a hint towards an involvement of the PFC in this relationship, although a more complex mechanism includ-ing developmental effects can be assumed. In addition, interaction effects of genotype and IA were found for brain activation in the amygdala (AMY) und HC during perfor-mance of the 4-CSRTT, while another interaction was found for H/I symptoms and geno-type for right AMY volume. These findings indicate a serotonergic modulation of coding of the emotional value of reward during performance of the 4-CSRTT that varies de-pending on the extent of psychopathology-associated traits.
Taken together, it was shown that the 4-CSRTT taps distinct domains of impulsivity with relevance to ADHD symptomatology: (proactive) response inhibition difficulties in relation with anticipation of reward. Furthermore, the two symptom domains, IA and H/I, contrib-ute differently to WI, which emphasizes the need to distinguish both in the research of ADHD. The results of study II emphasized the relevance of serotonergic transmission especially for attentional control and emotional processing. Although the present findings need replication and further refinement in more homogenous age groups, the use of the 4-CSRTT with a dimensional approach is a very promising strategy, which will hopefully extend our understanding of impulsivity-related mental disorders in the future.
The present cumulative dissertation summarizes three clinical studies, which examine
subgroups of patients within the fibromyalgia syndrome (FMS). FMS entails chronic pain and
associated symptoms, and its pathophysiology is incompletely understood (1). Previous studies
show that there is a subgroup of patients with FMS with objective histological pathology of the
small nerve fibers of the peripheral nervous system (PNS). Another subgroup of FMS patients
does not show any signs of pathological changes of the small nerve fibers. The aim of this
dissertation was to compare FMS patients with healthy controls, and these two FMS subgroups
for differences in the central nervous system (CNS) in order to explore possible interactions
between PNS and the CNS. Regarding the CNS, differences of FMS patients with healthy
controls have already been found in studies with small sample sizes, but no subgroups have yet
been identified. Another aim of this thesis was to test whether the subgroups show a different
response to different classes of pain medication. The methods used in this thesis are structural
and functional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), magnetic resonance diffusion imaging and
magnetic resonance spectroscopy. For the evaluation of clinical symptoms, we used
standardized questionnaires. The subgroups with and without pathologies of the PNS were
determined by skin biopsies of the right thigh and lower leg based on the intraepidermal nerve
fiber density (IENFD) of the small nerve fibers.
1) In the first MRI study, 43 female patients with the diagnosis of FMS and 40 healthy
control subjects, matched in age and body mass index, were examined with different MRI
sequences. Cortical thickness was investigated by structural T1 imaging, white matter integrity
by diffusion tensor imaging and functional connectivity within neuronal networks by functional
resting state MRI. Compared to the controls, FMS patients had a lower cortical volume in
bilateral frontotemporoparietal regions and the left insula, but a higher cortical volume in the
left pericalcarine cortex. Compared to the subgroup without PNS pathology, the subgroup with
PNS pathology had lower cortical volume in both pericalcarine cortices. Diffusion tensor
imaging revealed an increased fractional anisotropy (FA) of FMS patients in corticospinal
pathways such as the corona radiata, but also in regions of the limbic systems such as the fornix
and cingulum. Subgroup comparison again revealed lower mean FA values of the posterior
thalamic radiation and the posterior limb of the left internal capsule in the subgroup with PNS
pathology. In the functional connectivity analysis FMS patients, compared to controls, showed
a hypoconnectivity between the right median frontal gyrus and the posterior cerebellum and
the right crus cerebellum, respectively. In the subgroup comparisons, the subgroup with PNS
pathology showed a hyperconnectivity between both inferior frontal gyri, the right posterior
parietal cortex and the right angular gyrus. In summary, these results show that differences in
brain morphology and functional connectivity exist between FMS patients with and without
PNS pathology. These differences were not associated with symptom duration or severity and,
in some cases, have not yet been described in the context of FMS. The differences in brain
morphology and connectivity between subgroups could also lead to a differential response to
treatment with centrally acting drugs. Further imaging studies with FMS patients should take
into account this heterogeneity of FMS patient cohorts.
2) Following the results from the first MRI study, drug therapies of FMS patients and
their treatment response were compared between PNS subgroups. As there is no licensed drug
for FMS in Europe, the German S3 guideline recommends amitriptyline, duloxetine and
pregabalin for temporary use. In order to examine the current drug use in FMS patients in
Germany on a cross-sectional basis, 156 patients with FMS were systematically interviewed.
The drugs most frequently used to treat pain in FMS were non-steroidal anti-inflammatory
drugs (NSAIDs) (28.9%), metamizole (15.4%) and amitriptyline (8.8%). Pain relief assessed by
patients on a numerical rating scale from 0-10 averaged 2.2 points for NSAIDs, 2.0 for
metamizole and 1.5 for amitriptyline. Drugs that were discontinued for lack of efficacy and not
for side effects were acetaminophen (100%), flupirtine (91.7%), selective serotonin reuptake
inhibitors (81.8%), NSAIDs (83.7%) and weak opioids (74.1%). Patients were divided into
subgroups with and without PNS pathology as determined by skin biopsies. We found no
differences in drug use and effect between the subgroups. Taken together, these results show
that many FMS patients take medication that is not in accordance with the guidelines. The
reduction of symptoms was best achieved with metamizole and NSAIDs. Further longitudinal
studies on medication in FMS are necessary to obtain clearer treatment recommendations.
3) Derived from previous pharmacological and imaging studies (with smaller case
numbers), there is a hypothesis in the FMS literature that hyperreactivity of the insular cortex
may have an impact on FMS. The hyperreactivity seems to be due to an increased concentration
of the excitatory neurotransmitter glutamate in the insular cortex of FMS patients. The
hypothesis is supported by magnetic resonance spectroscopy studies with small number of
cases, as well as results from pharmacological studies with glutamate-inhibiting medication.
Studies from animal models have also shown that an artificially induced increase in glutamate
in the insular cortex can lead to reduced skin innervation. Therefore, the aim of this study was
to compare glutamate and GABA concentrations in the insular cortex of FMS patients with
those of healthy controls using magnetic resonance imaging. There was no significant
difference of both neurotransmitters between the groups. In addition, there was no correlation
between the neurotransmitter concentrations and the severity of clinical symptoms. There
were also no differences in neurotransmitter concentrations between the subgroups with and
without PNS pathology. In conclusion, our study could not show any evidence of a correlation
of glutamate and GABA concentrations with the symptoms of FMS or the pathogenesis of
subgroups with PNS pathologies.
Maladaptive coping mechanisms influence health-related quality of life (HRQoL) of individuals facing acute and chronic stress. Trait emotional intelligence (EI) may provide a protective shield against the debilitating effects of maladaptive coping thus contributing to maintained HRQoL. Low trait EI, on the other hand, may predispose individuals to apply maladaptive coping, consequently resulting in lower HRQoL. The current research is comprised of two studies. Study 1 was designed to investigate the protective effects of trait EI and its utility for efficient coping in dealing with the stress caused by chronic heart failure (CHF) in a cross-cultural setting (Pakistan vs Germany). N = 200 CHF patients were recruited at cardiology institutes of Multan, Pakistan and Würzburg as well as Brandenburg, Germany. Path analysis confirmed the expected relation between low trait EI and low HRQoL and revealed that this association was mediated by maladaptive metacognitions and negative coping strategies in Pakistani but not German CHF patients. Interestingly, also the specific coping strategies were culture-specific. The Pakistani sample considered religious coping to be highly important, whereas the German sample was focused on adopting a healthy lifestyle such as doing exercise. These findings are in line with cultural characteristics suggesting that German CHF patients have an internal locus of control as compared to an external locus of control in Pakistani CHF patients. Finally, the findings from study 1 corroborate the culture-independent validity of the metacognitive model of generalized anxiety disorder.
In addition to low trait EI, high interoception accuracy (IA) may predispose individuals to interpret cardiac symptoms as threatening, thus leading to anxiety. To examine this proposition, Study 2 compared individuals with high vs low IA in dealing with a psychosocial stressor (public speaking) in an experimental lab study. In addition, a novel physiological intervention named transcutaneous vagus nerve stimulation (t-VNS) and cognitive reappraisal (CR) were applied during and after the anticipation of the speech in order to facilitate coping with stress. N= 99 healthy volunteers participated in the study. Results showed interesting descriptive results that only reached trend level. They suggested a tendency of high IA individuals to perceive the situation as more threatening as indicated by increased heart rate and reduced heart rate variability in the high-frequency spectrum as well as high subjective anxiety during anticipation of and actual performance of the speech. This suggests a potential vulnerability of high IA individuals for developing anxiety disorders, specifically social anxiety disorder, in case negative self-focused attention and negative evaluation is applied to the (more prominently perceived) increased cardiac responding during anticipation of and the actual presentation of the public speech. The study did not reveal any significant protective effects of t-VNS and CR.
In summary, the current research suggested that low trait EI and high IA predicted worse psychological adjustment to chronic and acute distress. Low trait EI facilitated maladaptive metacognitive processes resulting in the use of negative coping strategies in Study 1; however, increased IA regarding cardioceptions predicted high physiological arousal in study 2. Finally, the German vs. the Pakistani culture greatly affected the preference for specific coping strategies. These findings have implications for caregivers to provide culture-specific treatments on the one hand. On the other hand, they highlight high IA as a possible vulnerability to be targeted for the prevention of (social) anxiety.
Hintergrund: Depressionen zählen zu den häufigsten psychischen Erkrankungen. Depressive Symptome umfassen beeinträchtigte kognitive Funktionen, vegetative Beschwerden und ein verändertes emotionales Erleben. Die defizitäre Wahrnehmung interner körperlicher Signale wird sowohl mit der Pathogenese der Depression als auch mit Angststörungen in Verbindung gebracht. Interozeptive Genauigkeit (IAc) beschreibt dabei die Fähigkeit, körperliche Empfindungen wie den eigenen Herzschlag akkurat wahrzunehmen und wird mit einer Herzwahrnehmungsaufgabe erfasst. In bildgebenden Verfahren wie der funktionellen Magnetresonanztomografie (fMRT) war eine niedrigere IAc mit einer verringerten Inselaktivität assoziiert. Während der Ruhezustandsmessung des Gehirns (resting-state fMRT) kann in Abwesenheit einer Aufgabe die intrinsische Aktivität des Gehirns gemessen werden. Dies ermöglicht die Identifizierung von kortikalen Netzwerken. Depressive Patienten weisen eine veränderte funktionelle Konnektivität innerhalb und zwischen einzelnen Netzwerken wie dem Salience Network (SN), welchem die Insel zugerechnet wird, und dem Default Mode Network (DMN) auf. Bisherige Studien, in denen überwiegend jüngere depressive Patienten untersucht wurden, kamen jedoch hinsichtlich der IAc und den kortikalen Netzwerken zu inkonsistenten Ergebnissen. Insbesondere ist unklar, inwieweit sich die IAc nach einem Therapieansprechen verändert, von der Herzratenvariabilität (HRV) moduliert wird und welche Auswirkungen dies auf die funktionelle Konnektivität kortikaler Netzwerke hat.
Ziele: Eine veränderte IAc und HRV wie auch funktionelle Konnektivitätsunterschiede im DMN und SN könnten Biomarker der Depression darstellen. Im Rahmen einer Längsschnittuntersuchung wurde getestet, ob ältere depressive Patienten über eine verringerte IAc, eine geringere HRV und über eine veränderte funktionelle Konnektivität im SN sowie DMN verfügen. Darüber hinaus sollte erforscht werden, in welchem Ausmaß sich Patienten, die auf die Behandlung ansprachen (Responder), von sogenannten Non-Respondern in Bezug auf die IAc, die HRV, das SN und das DMN unterschieden.
Methoden: In Studie 1 (Baseline) wurden 30 größtenteils medizierte, schwer depressive Patienten (> 50 Jahre) und 30 gesunde Kontrollprobanden untersucht. Die IAc wurde in einer Herzwahrnehmungsaufgabe ermittelt und die HRV bestimmt. Zusätzlich wurde eine resting-state fMRT durchgeführt. Eine funktionelle Konnektivitätsanalyse für Saatregionen im SN und DMN wurde mit einem saatbasierten Ansatz (seed-to-voxel) durchgeführt. Für eine Subgruppenanalyse wurde die Patientengruppe in ängstlich-depressive und nicht-ängstlich depressive Patienten unterteilt.
In Studie 2 (sechs Monate Follow-up) wurde die Studienkohorte nochmals untersucht. Es nahmen 21 Personen der Patientengruppe und 28 Probanden der Kontrollgruppe teil. Wiederum wurden die IAc und die HRV bestimmt. Außerdem fand eine resting-state fMRT-Messung statt. Die Patientengruppe wurde unterteilt in depressive Responder und Non-Responder.
Ergebnisse: In Studie 1 zeigten depressive Patienten eine funktionelle Hypokonnektivität zwischen einzelnen Saatregionen der Insel (SN) und Teilen des superioren frontalen Gyrus, des supplementärmotorischen Cortex, des lateralen okzipitalen Cortex sowie des Okzipitalpols. Zudem wiesen depressive Patienten zwischen der Saatregion im anterioren Teil des DMN und der Insel sowie dem Operculum eine erhöhte funktionelle Konnektivität auf. Die Gruppen unterschieden sich nicht in der IAc und der HRV. Ängstlich-depressive Patienten zeigten eine höhere funktionelle Konnektivität innerhalb der Insel als nicht-ängstlich depressive Patienten, jedoch zeigten sich keine Unterschiede in der IAc und der HRV.
In Studie 2 wiesen depressive Non-Responder im Vergleich zu Respondern eine Hyperkonnektivität zwischen dem posterioren DMN und dem Frontalpol sowie zwischen dem posterioren DMN und temporalen Arealen im SN auf. Keine funktionellen Konnektivitätsunterschiede zeigten sich für die Saatregionen im SN. Depressive Responder, Non-Responder und die Kontrollprobanden unterschieden sich in ihrer IAc und HRV nicht.
Schlussfolgerungen: Die Ergebnisse der Studien unterstreichen, dass bei depressiven Patienten, Respondern und Non-Respondern Unterschiede in der intrinsischen Gehirnaktivität funktioneller Netzwerke bestehen, jedoch nicht in der akkuraten Wahrnehmung des eigenen Herzschlages und der HRV. Therapeutische Interventionen, die auf eine Verbesserung der IAc abzielen, könnten insbesondere für Non-Responder dennoch eine zusätzliche Behandlungsmöglichkeit darstellen. Für eine personalisierte Medizin könnte die weitere Erforschung von kortikalen Netzwerken einen wesentlichen Beitrag leisten, um ein individuelles Therapieansprechen zu prädizieren.
Adapting defensive behavior to the characteristics of a threatening situation is a fundamental function of the brain. Particularly, threat imminence plays a major role for the organization of defensive responses. Acute threat prompts phasic physiological responses, which are usually associated with an intense feeling of fear. In contrast, diffuse and potentially threatening situations elicit a sustained state of anxious apprehension. Detection of the threatening stimulus defines the key event in this framework, initiating the transition from potential to acute threat. Consequently, attention to threat is crucial for supporting defensive behavior. The functions of attention are finely tuned to the characteristics of a threatening situation. Potential threat is associated with hypervigilance, in order to facilitate threat detection. Once a threatening stimulus has been identified, attention is selectively focused on the source of danger. Even though the concepts of selective attention and hypervigilance to threat are well established, evidence for their neural correlates remain scarce. Therefore, a major goal of this thesis is to elucidate the neural correlates of selective attention to acute threat and hypervigilance during potential threat. A second aim of this thesis is to provide a mechanistic account for the interaction of fear and anxiety. While contemporary models view fear and anxiety as mutually exclusive, recent findings for the neural networks of fear and anxiety suggest potential interactions. In four studies, aversive cue conditioning was used to induce acute threat, while context conditioning served as a laboratory model of potential threat. To quantify neural correlates of selective attention and hypervigilance, steady-state visual evoked potentials (ssVEPs) were measured as an index of visuocortical responding. Study 1 compared visuocortical responses to acute and potential threat for high versus low trait-anxious individuals. All individuals demonstrated enhanced electrocortical responses to the central cue in the acute threat condition, suggesting evidence for the neural correlate of selective attention. However, only low anxious individuals revealed facilitated processing of the contexts in the potential threat condition, reflecting a neural correlate of hypervigilance. High anxious individuals did not discriminate among contexts. These findings contribute to the notion of aberrational processing of potential threat for high anxious individuals. Study 2 and 3 realized orthogonal combinations of cue and context conditioning to investigate potential interactions of fear and anxiety. In contrast to Study 1 and 2, Study 3 used verbal instructions to induce potentially threatening contexts. Besides ssVEPs, threat ratings and skin conductance responses (SCRs) were recorded as efferent indices of defensive responding. None of these studies found further evidence for the neural correlates of hypervigilance and selective attention. However, results for ratings and SCRs revealed additive effects of fear and anxiety, suggesting that fear and anxiety are not mutually exclusive, but interact linearly to organize and facilitate defensive behavior. Study 4 tested ssVEPs to more ecologically valid forms of context conditioning, using flickering video stimuli of virtual offices to establish context representations. Contrary to expectations, results revealed decreased visuocortical responses during sustained presentations of anxiety compared to neutral contexts. A disruption of ssVEP signals eventually suggests interferences by continuously changing video streams which are enhanced as a function of motivational relevance. In summary, this thesis provided evidence for the neural correlates of attention only for isolated forms of fear and anxiety, but not for their interaction. In contrast, an additive interaction model of fear and anxiety for measures of defensive responding offers a new perspective on the topography of defensive behavior.
Immersive Technologien, wie Augmented und Virtual Reality, können bestehende Geschäftsmodelle entweder verbessern oder gefährden. Jedoch kann sich das förderliche Potential nur entfalten, wenn die Anwender:innen die Technologien akzeptieren und letztendlich auch nutzen. In dieser Arbeit wird beschrieben, was Akzeptanz ist und welche Einflussgrößen (Faktoren) für die Akzeptanz von Virtual Reality besonders relevant sind. Anschließend ist, basierend auf der diskutierten Fachliteratur, ein neuartiges, holistisches Akzeptanzmodell für Virtual Reality entworfen und mit drei Studien überprüft worden.
In der ersten Studie wurden 129 Personen gebeten entweder in Augmented oder Virtual Reality ein Schulungsszenario oder ein Mini-Spiel auszuprobieren (2x2-Design). In beiden Anwendungen sollten Flaschen von einem virtuellen Fließband entfernt werden. Im Fokus der Untersuchung stand die Immersion, die Nützlichkeit, das empfundene Vergnügen (Hedonismus) und die Zufriedenheit. Die Ergebnisse ergaben zum einen, dass sich die Immersion zwischen Augmented und Virtual Reality unterscheidet, und zum anderen, dass das empfundene Vergnügen und die Nützlichkeit signifikante Prädiktoren für die Zufriedenheit darstellen. An der zweiten Studie nahmen 62 Personen teil. Sie wurden gebeten das Schulungsszenario erneut zu absolvieren, wobei dieses mit auditiven Inhalten und animierten Figuren angereicht wurde, sowie über eine etwas bessere Grafikqualität verfügte. Die Daten wurden mit den Virtual Reality Szenarien aus der ersten Studie verglichen, um den Einfluss der Präsenz auf den Hedonismus zu untersuchen. Obwohl kein relevanter Unterschied zwischen den Gruppen festgestellt wurde, konnte nachgewiesen werden, dass Präsenz Hedonismus signifikant vorhersagt. An der dritten Studie beteiligten sich insgesamt 35 Personen. Untersuchungsgegenstand der Studie war die virtuelle Darstellung der eigenen Person in der virtuellen Realität (Verkörperung) und dessen Einfluss auf den Hedonismus. Die Versuchspersonen wurden gebeten das Schulungsszenario erneut zu durch-laufen, wobei sie diesmal das Eingabegerät (Controller) der Visieranzeige (head-mounted display) zur Steuerung benutzen. In der ersten Studie erfolgte die Bedienung über eine Gestensteuerung. Die Analyse dieser Manipulation offenbarte keinerlei Auswirkungen auf die Verkörperung. Allerdings stellte die Verkörperung einen signifikanten Prädiktor für den Hedonismus dar.
Im Anschluss an die Studien ist das Modell mit den Daten aus den Virtual Reality Gruppen der ersten Studie beurteilt worden, wobei es sich weitgehend bestätigt hat. Abschließend werden die Befunde in Bezug auf die Fachliteratur eingeordnet, mögliche Ursachen für die Ergebnisse diskutiert und weitere Forschungsbedarfe aufgezeigt.
The propounded thesis investigated fear learning including fear conditioning, its generalization as well as its extinction in 133 healthy children and adolescents aged 8 to 17 years. The main goal was to analyze these processes also in the course of childhood and adolescence due to far less research in this age span compared to adults. Of note, childhood is the typical period for the onset of anxiety disorders. To achieve this, an aversive discriminative fear conditioning, generalization and extinction paradigm, which based on the “screaming lady paradigm” from Lau et al. (2008) and was adapted by Schiele & Reinhard et al. (2016), was applied. All probands traversed the pre-acquisition (4 x CS-, 4 x CS+, no US), the acquisition (12 x CS-, 12 x CS+, reinforcement rate: 83%), the generalization (12 x CS-, 12 x GS4, 12 x GS3, 12 x GS2, 12 x GS1, 12 x CS+, reinforcement rate: 50%) and the extinction (18 x CS-, 18 x CS+, no US). The generalization stimuli, i.e. GS1-GS4, were built out of CS- and CS+ in different mixtures on a percentage basis in steps of 20% from CS- to CS+. Pictures of faces of two actresses with a neutral expression were used for the discriminative conditioning, whereby the CS+ was paired with a 95-dB loud female scream at the same time together with a fearful facial expression (US). CS- and GS1-GS4 were never followed by the US. Subjective ratings (arousal, valence and US expectancy) were collected and further the psychophysiological measure of the skin conductance response (SCR). The hypotheses were 1) that underage probands show a negative correlation between age and overgeneralization and 2) that anxiety is positively correlated with overgeneralization in the same sample. ANOVAs with repeated measures were conducted for all four dependent variables with phase (pre-acquisition phase, 1. + 2. acquisition phase, 1. + 2. generalization phase, 1. - 3. extinction phase) and stimulus type
(CS-, CS+, GS1-GS4) as within-subject factors. For the analyses of the modulatory effects of age and anxiety in additional separate ANCOVAs were conducted including a) age, b) the STAIC score for trait anxiety and c) the CASI score for anxiety sensitivity as covariates. Sex was always included as covariate of no interest. On the one hand, findings indicated that the general extent of the reactions (arousal, valence and US expectancy ratings and the SCR) decreased with growing age, i.e. the older the probands the lower their reactions towards the stimuli regardless of the type of dependent variable. On the other hand, ratings of US expectancy, i.e. the likelihood that a stimulus is followed by a US (here: female scream coupled with a fearful facial expression), showed better discrimination skills the older the probands were, resulting in a smaller overgeneralization within older probands. It must be emphasized very clearly that no causality can be derived. Thus, it was only an association revealed between
15
age and generalization of conditioned fear, which is negative. Furthermore, no obvious impact of trait anxiety could be detected on the different processes of fear learning. Especially, no overgeneralization was expressed by the probands linked to higher trait anxiety. In contrast to trait anxiety, for anxiety sensitivity there was an association between its extent and the level of fear reactions. This could be described best with a kind of parallel shifts: the higher the anxiety sensitivity, the stronger the fear reactions. Likewise, for anxiety sensitivity no overgeneralization due to a stronger extent of anxiety sensitivity could be observed.
Longitudinal follow-up examinations and, furthermore, neurobiological investigations are needed for replication purposes and purposes of gaining more supporting or opposing insights, but also for the profound exploration of the impact of hormonal changes during puberty and of the maturation processes of different brain structures. Finally, the question whether enhanced generalization of conditioned fear facilitates the development of anxiety disorders or vice versa remains unsolved yet.
Emotional-associative learning processes such as fear conditioning and extinction are highly relevant to not only the development and maintenance of anxiety disorders (ADs), but also to their treatment. Extinction, as the laboratory analogue to behavioral exposure, is assumed a core process underlying the treatment of ADs. Although exposure-based treatments are highly effective for the average patient suffering from an AD, there remains a gap in treatment efficacy with over one third of patients failing to achieve clinically significant symptom relief. There is ergo a pressing need for intensified research regarding the underlying neural mechanisms of aberrant emotional-associative learning processes and the neurobiological moderators of treatment (non-)response in ADs.
The current thesis focuses on different applications of the fundamental principles of fear conditioning and extinction by using two example cases of ADs from two different multicenter trials. First, we targeted alterations in fear acquisition, extinction, and its recall as a function of psychopathology in panic disorder (PD) patients compared to healthy subjects using fMRI. Second, exposure-based therapy and pre-treatment patient characteristics exerting a moderating influence on this essential learning process later on (i.e. treatment outcome) were examined using multimodal functional and structural neuroimaging in spider phobia.
We observed aberrations in emotional-associative learning processes in PD patients compared to healthy subjects indicated by an accelerated fear acquisition and an attenuated extinction recall. Furthermore, pre-treatment differences related to defensive, regulatory, attentional, and perceptual processes may exert a moderating influence on treatment outcome to behavioral exposure in spider phobia. Although the current results need further replication, on an integrative meta level, results point to a hyperactive defensive network system and deficient emotion regulation processes (including extinction processes) and top-down control in ADs. This speaks in favor of transdiagnostic deficits in important functional domains in ADs.
Deficits in transdiagnostic domains such as emotion regulation processes could be targeted by enhancing extinction learning or by means of promising tools like neurofeedback. The detection of pre-treatment clinical response moderators, for instance via machine learning frameworks, may help in supporting clinical decision making on individually tailored treatment approaches or, respectively, to avoid ineffective treatment and its related financial costs. In the long run, the identification of neurobiological markers which are capable of detecting non-responders a priori represents an ultimate goal.
In vorgegangenen Studien wurde bei erwachsenen Patienten mit Angststörungen eine verstärkte Furchtgeneralisierung, eine eingeschränkte Fähigkeit zur Reizdiskrimination sowie eine veränderte Aufmerksamkeitsverteilung nachgewiesen. In einer gesunden Studienpopulation konnte bei Kindern eine stärkere Furchtgeneralisierung nachgewiesen werden als bei Erwachsenen. Ihre Generalisierungsgradienten gleichen denen von Erwachsenen mit Angststörung. Möglicherweise haben gestörte Lernprozesse in der Kindheit somit langfristige Effekte auf die Entwicklung von Angststörungen. Obwohl die Vorgänge des Furchtlernens im Kindesalter entscheidend für das Verständnis von Angststörungen sind, gibt es kaum Studien in dieser Altersgruppe. Die vorliegende Studie untersucht die Zusammenhänge von Furchtgeneralisierung und Aufmerksamkeitsprozessen in einer klinischen Population mit internalisierender Störung im Kindes- und Jugendalter.
Hierzu durchliefen Kinder und Jugendliche mit internalisierender Störung (n= 49) sowie gesunde Kontrollen (n=48) im Alter von 9 bis 17 Jahre ein Furcht-generalisierungsparadigma mit Diskriminationstraining sowie einen modifizierten Dotprobe mit integriertem Eyetracking. Die Ängstlichkeit wurde mittels verschiedener Angstfragebögen gemessen. Im Generalisierungsparadigma wurden zwei weibliche Gesichter mit neutralem Gesichtsausdruck als Stimuli verwendet, die entweder mit (CS+) oder ohne (CS-) einem 95dB lauten Schrei sowie einem angsterfüllten Gesichtsausdruck gezeigt wurden. Zur Messung der Furchtreaktion wurden subjektive Ratings für Arousal, Valenz und Kontingenz erfasst, zudem wurde die Hautleitfähigkeit gemessen. Zur Auswertung des Dotprobes wurden die Reaktionszeiten und die Initialsakkade erfasst. Die statistische Analyse des Furchtgeneralisierungsparadigmas sowie des Dotprobe-Paradigmas wurde mittels Multivarianzanalysen mit Messwiederholung durchgeführt, gefolgt von t-Tests zur weiterführenden Analyse. Desweiteren wurden die Aufmerksamkeitsreaktionen von nicht-ängstlichen und ängstlichen Teilnehmern in Kategorien eingeteilt und mittels Chi-Quadrat Analysen verglichen. Zur Analyse des Zusammenhangs zwischen Furchtgeneralisierung und Aufmerksamkeitsprozessen erfolgte eine Regressionsanalyse mit einem GS Mittelwert als abhängiger Variable und der Ängstlichkeit und den Aufmerk-samkeitsprozessen als Prädiktoren.
Die Ergebnisse bestätigten eine solide Furchtkonditionierung anhand des „Screaming Lady“-Paradigmas in einer klinischen Population, dies war erkennbar an höheren Ratings für den aversiven Stimulus im Vergleich zum sicheren Stimulus in beiden Gruppen. Grundsätzlich höhere Furchtratings sowie höhere Ratings der Generalisierungsstimuli im Vergleich zum sicheren Stimulus wiesen auf eine stärkere Generalisierung in der Untergruppe mit höherem Angst-Trait innerhalb der internalisierenden Probandengruppe hin. Die Analyse der Dotprobe Daten ergab schnellere Reaktionszeiten sowie häufigere Initialsakkaden gegenüber furchteinflößenden Stimuli bei Patienten mit internalisierender Störung. Des Weiteren zeigten sehr ängstliche Probanden häufiger einen Attentional bias im Chi Quadrat Test als nicht-ängstliche Probanden. Dies wies daraufhin, dass sowohl bei Patienten mit internalisierender Störung als auch bei sehr ängstlichen Probanden ein Attentional bias gegenüber furchtrelevanten Stimuli vorliegt. Vor allem bei Kindern mit internalisierender Störung sagten die Ängstlichkeit und veränderte Aufmerksamkeitsprozesse die Ausprägung der Furchtgeneralisierung voraus. Somit kann ein Zusammenhang von veränderten Aufmerksamkeitsprozessen und Furchtgeneralisierung vermutet werden.